Verizon has so far enjoyed more success indoors with enterprises for its millimeter wave 5G service, than with consumers who have been underwhelmed by the reach, or lack of it. GM and Honeywell are two notable recent recruits with both installing Verizon’s millimeter wave 5G Ultra-Wideband service inside buildings and working with the operator to address differing use cases there.
For GM, the focus is on industrial IoT with advanced manufacturing at its recently announced Detroit-Hamtramck Assembly Center, known as Factory Zero, for assembling electric vehicles (EVs). The ability of mmWave to enable ultra-low latency communications locally was a reason for the choice, helping accelerate some of the assembly processes, according to GM.
“Factory ZERO is GM’s flagship assembly plant in our journey to an all-electric future,” said Randy Mott, GM executive vice president and chief information officer. “This is another example of cutting-edge technology improving quality and speed as GM accelerates its rollout of EVs.”
Low latency also figured in Honeywell’s decision but the applications are different, being to demonstrate Honeywell IoT products at its new corporate headquarters in Charlotte, North Carolina. As it happens, Honeywell has also been working extensively with Verizon over some of those IoT use cases, having early 2020 integrated the operator’s LTE offering into smart meters and other edge devices for smart electric grid deployments.
The IoT has become a strong focal point for Honeywell with its legacy in smart building technologies and environmental control. One recent development that caught our eye was an expansion of its holistic Healthy Buildings Air Quality offering focusing on the underappreciated issue of indoor air pollution in enterprise buildings, with a nod to the ongoing Covid-19 coronavirus pandemic.
Honeywell deserves praise for flagging this issue at a time when global lockdowns confining people indoors raised concerns over health impacts earlier on during the pandemic. Various research had already confirmed that despite the focus on outdoor air pollution associated with diesel particulates, nitrogen oxides and ozone, air quality indoors was often worse.
Although some of the sources of indoor pollution, such as cooking and cigarette smoking, are often irrelevant for enterprise settings, one common point is that while building regulations have improved health in some respects, desire to reduce energy consumption through airtight insulation has actually worsened indoor pollution. In the absence of extraction or filtration, particles tend to accumulate in hermetically sealed indoor environments and are recirculated by air conditioning systems.
Honeywell’s solution is to combine monitoring, filtration and emission of ultra violet radiation, the latter targeting microorganisms in the air, including viruses. Therein lies the second reference to the pandemic, where we take some issue.
Honeywell’s offering now comprises three integrated components, Electronic Air Cleaners (EACs), ultraviolet light systems and a new line of indoor air quality (IAQ) sensors. The latter includes Honeywell’s Particulate Matter Sensor PM2.5, Total Volatile Organic Compound (TVOC) Sensor and All-in-One IAQ Sensor. The first of these, PM2.5, removes particles down to 2.5 microns in size, comprising one widely recognized category of particulates.
So far so good. What is more contentious is the claim that UV can “disinfect” the air, with the implication that could help make offices “covid safe”. There is no problem with the underlying science, since UV radiation is well known to kill or disable most pathogens, including viruses and bacteria. It does that by causing lesions, or cuts, in the chains of base pairs in DNA comprising nucleic acids, the genetic building blocks of the pathogens. In the case of viruses this renders them unable to replicate because their genetic code has been corrupted and so infection could not ensue.
As a result, UV has been applied successfully at low background levels insufficient to cause harm to humans in swimming pools, and also beamed at higher doses onto surfaces to disinfect them. But the problem for combatting infections such as Covid-19 is that the viruses are sheltered out of reach of UV in their human hosts and would have to be disabled during what can be relatively brief journeys as aerosols or droplets in the air between an infected person and a target sitting nearby in an office say.
To protect against that, the air would have to irradiated by UV continuously at levels dangerous to humans, bringing risk of skin cancer and cataracts. Various stratagems have been employed to counter this, for example confining the UV to the upper part of the room above head height and then circulating the air vigorously with fans, or performing the irradiation only within an air conditioning system.
But neither of these would always catch a substantial proportion of virus particles in the air close to humans in offices. This much has been confirmed by a recent study finding that UV irradiation cannot make much impact on indoor transmission of the Covid-19 virus, or indeed any other airborne transmissible virus.
Which all goes to show environmental technology providers should be careful when claiming their systems can halt virus transmission given that experts in the field have been arguing over exact mechanisms and dynamics throughout the pandemic.