Significance: In contrast with the early 3G roll-outs, on the first LTE networks, no sooner has capacity been boosted than users are eagerly consuming it. Verizon has speeded up its roll-out to ensure customers remain happy, even as they snap up data-hungry iPhones, but while throwing capacity at subscribers may work in the first stage, enabling the carrier to widen the gap with AT&T, soon it will need to ensure that the rise in data usage is profitable. Already, the 12% of its contract base with LTE devices account for 35% of its traffic and it expects that figure to surpass 50% soon. That will make it urgent to identify which pricing plans and service levels deliver the optimal combination of user satisfaction and profit, and as 4G cellcos round the world experiment with increasingly sophisticated and granular personalized tariffs, there will be a significant boost for policy and charging management systems. Tekelec has responded with the concept of ‘policy everywhere’ embracing over-the-top services and pushing network intelligence right to the device.
Verizon Wireless has accelerated the pace of its LTE roll-out to keep pace with user demand for data and to ensure a strong experience for the new iPhone. But as it turns on its 400th LTE market (Marquette, Michigan), it knows that a successful 4G service will not just rely on having the earliest, most powerful network, but on adopting pricing and policy initiatives that turn that world beating infrastructure into profit.
Although only 12% of Verizon Wireless’s contract subscribers have LTE devices (11m in total), over one-third (35%) of the carrier’s data traffic already travels over its 4G network, indicating how significantly new speed and bandwidth stimulates usage. With new devices, including the first LTE iPhone, making their debut, the cellco’s CTO Nicola Palmer believes half the data will soon be using the new network.
Palmer told the CTIA MobileCon conference that Verizon Wireless would beat its own build-out targets for LTE this year, deploying its 400th market (Marquette, Michigan) next week. It was two months ahead of schedule on roll-out, she said, and by the end of 2013, it will have LTE implemented everywhere it has 3G.
She indicated why the acceleration is necessary ‘ to stay ahead of AT&T, now ramping up its own deployment, and to handle the rising tide of traffic while delivering a competitive user experience. “It won’t be long before the majority of our traffic will go over LTE,” she said.
By contrast, it took Verizon twice as long to get half its traffic onto its 3G CDMA network when that was new. And as AT&T found with the original iPhone, mobile networks need to be prepared for a signature new device or risk customer dissatisfaction. “The iPhone 5 will be another acceleration point for LTE,” Roger Entner, an analyst for Recon Analytics, told CNet, anticipating that Verizon will sell several million iPhone 5s in the next few months, along with other data-hungry devices. Verizon has stated that it will now only sell smartphones with LTE capability, and about two-thirds of its devices are now smartphones.
The next step, even before the 700MHz network completely overlays the CDMA 3G system, will be to add capacity in selected areas using the higher frequency AWS spectrum which Verizon acquired from four cablecos plus Leap. It will start building in this band from mid-2013 and add supporting devices in the same timeframe. “The strategy will be to take our existing cell sites and add AWS to those sites,” Palmer said. “We’ll start to see deployment in mid-to-late next year. We’re already working on technical trials and we’ll have devices that can take advantage of AWS available next year.”
She added: “As we look at the growth of data in the industry, and we build out our network, we have to turn our attention to capacity in addition to coverage. LTE-Advanced is one tool in the toolbox.” However, there was no indication of when this would be implemented.
Boosting capacity alone is a blunt instrument. Most carriers see LTE as a way to reduce the cost of delivering large volumes of data, while also supporting multiple levels of services. That in turn allows different rates and QoS levels to be tailored to different types of customers, and new revenue streams added. The first step has been to shift away from unlimited data plans to tiered pricing, but far more sophisticated and granular pricing and policy tactics will be the key to improving profits as well as customer satisfaction ‘ and ensuring the shiny new network is optimized for the needs of the highest value customers.
As carriers broaden their mobile broadband pricing structures and increasingly need to deliver tailored services, policy management is becoming complex and business critical. One of the providers, Tekelec, has coined the term ‘policy everywhere’, reflecting the need for carriers’ pricing and QoS structures to embrace over-the-top applications as well as conventional services, but also to extend out to the device. The latter reflects trends in network intelligence and traffic management, where work traditionally done in the core is distributed outwards, reducing the cost and complexity of the core and bringing intelligence closer to the customer. In the era of personalized and localized services and tariffs, that can provide competitive advantage.
Tekelec itself recently launched a trio of offerings to support ‘policy everywhere’ – a Mobile Policy Gateway, Application Manager and Policy Analytics Platform, all of which integrate with the existing Policy Server. The vendor says this takes its platform beyond conventional cellco services and charging ‘ fair usage and tiered pricing, for instance ‘ and supports new trends such as subsidized or ‘toll-free’ data, opt-in mobile advertising, customer rewards programs, and application-based plans.
The Mobile Policy Gateway (MPG) also extends the reach of policy management to smart devices like high end handsets and tablets, tracking and billing for habits like intelligent Wi-Fi offload. This element will also help improve device security and limit the impact of ‘chatty’ applications, which can overload the network with signalling traffic. The MPG combines a standards based ANDSF (access network discovery and selection function) with dynamic network and subscriber aware policy management. That can make a device into a policy enforcement points, reducing the need for expensive functionality in the core, such as DPI (deep packet inspection) and policy enforcement since the endpoint handles functions like choosing to move to a Wi-Fi hotspot, or identifying cross- selling opportunities and offering them within the app.
Meanwhile, the Application Manager enables carrier to expose network APIs, policies and subscriber data securely to over-the-top services and service delivery platforms (SDPs). It converts web protocols like LDAP, SOAP, XML and HTTP to Diameter to create a single point of control for hybrid business models or for cellcos partnering with OTT apps partners. Carriers can insert targeted adverts in native or third party apps and support specific charging and service levels for different users.
The Policy Analytics Platform is the business intelligence module, making the data in millions of
policy event records available and comprehensible to IT and marketing departments. They can then examine how different policies and devices impact network traffic and user behavior, and the effect of new policies can be tested in advance.
‘Policy is the ‘everywhere’ technology that will transform service provider business models,’ said Houck Reed, VP of product management and marketing, in a statement. ‘As billions of smart devices become policy enforcement points and new features extend policy and analytics to over-the-top applications and mobile advertisers, new business models will emerge that match subscribers to the relevant, timely content they want.’
It is early days to discern clear trends in how carriers are pricing LTE services, apart from obvious shifts like that towards tiered pricing. While cellcos in many countries, such as Singapore and Korea, say the benefits of 4G have enabled them to increase their data fees, in Europe fierce competition between operators is leading to price wars and some of the lowest 4G tariffs in the world, reducing the ‘honeymoon period’ when early mover carriers hope to be able to charge a premium for a differentiated offering. According to Wireless Intelligence, LTE data costs $2.50 per Gbyte on average in Europe, around half the global average of $4.86. In Sweden, where all four mobile operators have launched LTE, a 4G data contract can cost as little as $0.63 per Gbyte per month (at Tele2 and 3 Sweden), oceans away from the best value option at Verizon, which equates to $7.50 per Gbyte.
However, cellcos are countering this trend in Europe by adopting pricing levels based on different speeds or QoS. Analyst Calum Dewar said: “This new mobile broadband tariff model, which operators have developed in line with the rationalization of their device portfolios, allows data to be priced on a quality of service basis for the first time, with operators offering mobile broadband packages at a range of differently priced download speeds – as many as six in the case of Vodafone and TMN in Portugal,’ he told TelecomEurope. This helps manage network capacity in a more revenue efficient way.
And France Telecom CEO Stephane Richard told a recent conference that LTE deployment was critical to being able to charge subscribers more for high speed data services. He said Orange had been successful in charging extra for faster speeds, though he admitted that the price for LTE access had not yet been decided. “There will be a premium. The model with HSPA+ has made it clear that customers will pay,” he added. “We want to accelerate the LTE roll-out in France in order to get ahead of the competition.” This will help Orange counteract the price war unleashed by Iliad’s Free Mobile unit ‘ which is building its own 3G network but also uses the France Telecom RAN on an MVNO basis. Since Free has no 4G spectrum, and the MVNO agreement does not extend to LTE, Richard sees 4G as an important way to dilute the impact of the new entrant.
According to ABI Research, on average round the world 4G pricing is about 20% higher than 3G for the equivalent data plan but that will not last long as competition heats up. “In South Korea, SK Telecom has cut its 4G pricing to remain competitive. Their ‘LTE 62 Plan’ for smartphones used to be priced at US$55.04 for 3Gbytes of data, but the monthly download quota has now been increased to 5Gbytes,’ said the firm, which has seen similar mobile data plan changes in Norway, Hong Kong and the US, adding: “4G technology has given operators, not just greater download speeds, but also greater capacity. Therefore there is a degree of price elasticity.’
In Asia, the main focus is on offering a wide range of different propositions to attract customers and add value beyond the basic monthly subscription fee. CSL of Hong Kong provides volumetric plans and family packages, with multiple devices bundled in a single monthly fee, while NTT Docomo in Japan is also a fan of the speed-based model. SKT of Korea emphasizes content bundles, with various video, ebook or music options provided according to which tier a subscriber chooses. In Singapore, StarHub is initially offering 4G at no extra cost compared to 3G, to boost uptake, but is also exploring differentiated pricing based on charging by app.
Another major issue for rapid LTE deployers like Verizon is voice. The cellco plans to launch voice over LTE (VoLTE) services by late 2013 or early 2014, according to Palmer, a timescale that has been pushed out progressively. MetroPCS has already rolled out VoLTE devices on its LTE network ‘ one of two carriers in the world, along with SKT, to do so. However, a new SEC filing indicates that, if the regional player’s proposed merger with T-Mobile USA goes ahead, the new entity could abandon the VoLTE plans.
The wide variety is, to some extent, a symptom of an immature 4G market where operators have not fully worked out the business model. However, it also signifies the greater flexibility with investment in LTE delivers to carriers, providing them with the capacity and cost base to experiment with many different pricing strategies, added value options and levels of service. That, in turn, will drive rising investment in tools which handle and analyze the traffic intelligently and support sophisticated policy management right down to the device.