The perpetual motion that is the US’s telecoms M&A merry-go-round continues – for every hiccup, like the collapse of Comcast’s plan to buy Time Warner Cable, there is another new deal proposed, most recently Verizon’s bid for AOL. The telco should add to its portfolio further, says analyst Michael Rollins at Citigroup, by acquiring Dish Network too.
“This AOL deal suggests a legacy business did not get in the way of Verizon’s strategic aspirations,” wrote Rollins in client note last week. “In contrast, Dish has highly valuable and strategic mobile spectrum and also owns a linear video business. Verizon should consider the purchase of Dish sooner than later, which could elevate its wireless and over-the-top video strategies even further.”
It would also help Verizon respond to AT&T’s own current acquisition plan, the $49bn buy of DirecTV, which should close in a few weeks’ time. That will net it more video subscribers than Dish (which has been rumored as an AT&T target in the past) – over 20m against Dish’s 13.84m (and currently falling). But the smaller firm’s dowry includes all that spectrum, and so would be a valuable asset for a mobile acquirer.
Dish is never far from the M&A rumor mill, partly because it has remained inscrutable about its plans to become a wireless player. It has accumulated an estimated $50bn worth of spectrum, initially in niche areas like the former mobile satellite frequencies, where it holds 40 MHz of in the AWS-4 band, and the 1.9 GHz PCS H Block, where it owns 10 MHz. More recently it won about half the licences on offer in the AWS-3 auction, adding 25 MHz to its store if those allocations are approved by the FCC.
It has secured an FCC waiver to operate terrestrial-only LTE services in the satellite frequencies and set out plans for a national LTE-Advanced network to add wireless services to its pay-TV/broadband bundles and potentially to support a wholesale business.
But through all that, deployments have not started and many still believe that the spectrum assets are an investment, whose value Dish will talk up by demonstrating their potential for LTE and quad play services, but ultimately look to sell on.
Alternatively, the licences could be an additional attraction to a firm looking to buy the whole company, as Citigroup speculate. Dish has often been linked with both Sprint and T-Mobile, as it would bring them greater scale and the content relationships they lack – a gap which means they will not be able to challenge the big two operators in their most valuable growth area, quad play. Of course, Dish also tried to turn acquirer when it bid both for Sprint itself and for its joint venture Clearwire.
In the end, Softbank won both, but the logic of a partnership between Sprint and Dish remains, even if that does not extend to a merger. Sprint has built its Network Vision infrastructure with a view to hosting third party networks and generating new revenues that way, and Dish has said it needs a network partner in order to make the economics of its nationwide LTE-A plan add up. Having built that network, it could then be a valuable roaming and sharing partner for Sprint, and perhaps agree a cross-marketing pact, similar to that which was planned (though dropped) between Verizon and a group of cablecos.
In recent months, though, the buzz has been around Dish and T-Mobile. The former’s chairman, Charlie Ergen, was asked on the first quarter earnings call whether TMo would be a natural partner, and responded: “We’re keeping all of our options open, but obviously we admire what John Legere [TMo’s CEO] and his team have done at T-Mobile, and certainly we follow what they do.”
Like Verizon with AOL, however, it may be time for Dish to look to non-traditional partners, for mergers or alliances that would support its progress towards a quad play and other business models. The firm’s EVP of corporate development, Tom Cullen, said during the results call that new video-sharing apps like Periscope and Meerkat, and the continued rise of mobile video traffic, is “opening up conversations with non-traditional players”.
Last week, there were clearer signs that Dish is sincere in its intentions to build out LTE. A confidential document obtained by Yahoo showed that the firm was looking for a chief marketing officer specifically to direct the wireless launch. “We are preparing for something big,” the document said. “We have reinvented ourselves in the past and we are preparing to do it again.” It also said that the CMO would be “an integral part of the team that changes entertainment forever as Dish enters the wireless business and becomes the only provider that can offer wireless voice, video and data.”
While that seems to ignore the ongoing acquisitions by both Verizon and AT&T, both geared to doing just that, the memo does suggest that Dish is coming clear to some real world plans at last, now it is armed with its AWS-3 spectrum (despite the controversy over the way it managed to take advantage of small business discounts on the price, by bidding through front companies).
Those are likely to involve wholesaling, and Dish could fill the hole left when LightSquared’s grand plan to create a wholesale-only LTE network in mobile satellite bands fell apart because of fears of interference with GPS. “The wholesale discussion is an increasing priority I think in the minds of some players whose business models are more dependent on high speed, high capacity, low latency cloud connections,” said Cullen.
The next step may be to participate in next year’s incentive auction of broadcast spectrum in the 600 MHz band. Ergen said Dish would like to take part, especially as it would help break the “duopoly” which AT&T and Verizon have in low frequencies, thanks to their extensive holdings, and deployments, in 700 MHz.
The major operators have been playing it cool about 600 MHz, even though they have joined in enthusiastically with some of the more obscure disputes about the exact rules the FCC will adopt. Verizon, AT&T and, this week, Sprint have made various statements that they are interested, but do not need 600 MHz licences to make their spectrum position competitive. Of course, this may be disingenuous, but it does reflect that the major MNOs have spent a great deal of money adding to their airwaves in recent years, and may feel relatively comfortable in the coverage-focused lower bands as they come close to the end of their first wave of LTE roll-out. Now the focus, especially for Verizon and AT&T, will shift to additional capacity, often through dense small cells deployed in higher frequencies.
That could make Dish the most needy of the major participants in the auction, since it lacks sub-1 GHz spectrum and has yet to embark on its LTE build-out. Alternatively, it could make that partnership with Sprint or TMo and forego the wide area coverage for which low frequency spectrum is so important, concentrating on targeting capacity and video services at areas of high growth and revenue.
Joe Euteneuer, Sprint’s CFO, was the latest to join the 600 MHz debate, just a couple of weeks after the firm’s CEO, Marcelo Claure, laid out plans for densification, using small cells and WiFi in higher bands. He told the JP Morgan Global Technology Media and Telecom conference: “The 600 MHz auction is something we’re looking at but not necessarily something we need to do,” because Sprint is achieving many of its goals with its current three bands (800 MHz, 1.9 GHz and 2.5 GHz) plus additions like WiFi Calling.
Two years ago, what will probably be the last US sale of sub-1 GHz spectrum for the foreseeable future would have been far more strategically unmissable, he added.
That apparent indifference has not stopped Sprint backing calls for the FCC to change the auction rules to benefit smaller players and increase competition to Verizon’s and AT&T’s LTE services. Together with TMo, Dish, C Spire and various public interest groups, Sprint is calling on the regulator to reserve up to 40 MHz – or at least half of the total available – exclusively for smaller participants.
Altice: A new partnership option for Dish?
Two French telecoms and media groups, Iliad and Altice, are emerging as major forces in the European quad play arena, and now in the Americas too. The latter is buying a controlling stake in Suddenlink, which though only the seventh largest cableco in the US, gives the company a first foothold in the huge market – no doubt with the ambition to use that presence to disruptive effect. And Altice is reported to have bigger prey in its sights – Time Warner Cable (TWC), the second largest cable operator, whose plan to be acquired by market leader Comcast recently collapsed.
If it succeeds in creating a major cable group, it is likely to want access to low cost wireless capabilities, harnessing WiFi and, preferably, a non-traditional mobile partner – a company such as Dish, which would need the cable lines and WiFi homespots as much as the MSOs themselves to improve its economics; rather than an MVNO negotiated from a position of strength by a quad play provider like Verizon or AT&T.
Dish will, we can be sure, be watching these cable developments closely, from the point of view of potential competition and partnership.
A TWC deal could see Altice importing some of the experience it has gained in its home market of France, whose mobile and broadband services have been turned upside-down by convergence of operators – Altice recently acquired second MNO SFR to merge with its Numericable unit to support a quad play, while rival Iliad has launched low cost fixed/mobile services with its Free Mobile brand. Iliad itself tried to enter the US market last year, with a failed bid for T-Mobile, and at the time, it seemed the country was missing out on a French-style shake-up which might have turned TMO from a plucky annoyance to the big two carriers, into a dangerous challenger. Now Altice, if armed with two cablecos and potentially a strategic wireless deal with TMO or Dish, could revive that specter for Verizon and AT&T.
One of the effects of the TWC-Comcast deal would have been to create a massive US-wide network of WiFi hotspots and homespots. The leading cablecos – Comcast, TWC, Cablevision, Cox and BrightHouse – have been active in building out WiFi coverage and capacity, where possible backhauled by their own residential lines and HFC plant. The aim is to leverage WiFi to add the wireless elements of emerging quad play services and to reduce their reliance on MVNO deals with mobile operators when it comes to supporting customers’ rising need to access the internet, and view content, from any location and device.
An Altice/TWC/Suddenlink combination could, like Free in France, leverage the residential lines and WiFi to support low cost quad play services in which the wireless cost of delivery is greatly reduced, because customers only move onto mobile connections when there is no WLAN in range. In addition, it could take advantage of TWC’s membership of the CableWiFi consortium, which supports roaming between the five major MSOs’ hotspot networks; and TWC’s early start on upgrading its WLANs to support carrier-grade capabilities such as Hotspot 2.0/Passpoint.
Altice has agreed to buy 70% of Missouri-based Suddenlink in a deal which values the MSO at $9.1bn. Existing investors – BC Partners and CPP Investment Board – will retain the other 30%. Suddenlink has around 1.5m residential and 90,000 business customers in Texas, West Virginia, Louisiana, Arkansas and Arizona and reported $2.3bn in revenue and $900m in EBITDA last year.
Altice said the US firm was experiencing strong growth thanks to its investment in its broadband network, but would benefit further from its new parent’s “operational expertise, scale and investment support”.
Suddenlink CEO Jerry Kent, who will leave after the deal is finalized later this year, hinted at the state of flux in which the US telecoms market finds itself, and the way in which second tier cable or mobile providers can become power brokers as well as attractive targets, saying Altice’s backing would allow his firm to become “a major consolidator” in the US cable industry.
Of course, a bid for TWC would be on a different scale, and would be a major undertaking for a company with high debt levels like Altice. However, Wall Street Journal sources indicated this week that the two companies had held talks, and that capitalization of $44.5bn and, since the collapse of the proposed acquisition by Comcast, has also been rumored to be a target for smaller MSO Charter Communications.
Altice’s move may tempt Iliad back into the US market too, as the rivalry between the maverick billionaires which control the firms – Patrick Drahi at Altice and Xavier Niel at Iliad – intensifies. Drahi has embarked on an acquisition spree since he led his firm’s IPO in January 2014, buying SFR, Portugal Telecom and an operator in the Dominican Republic. He is also said to have his eye on the third French mobile provider, Bouygues, though that might be a step too far for the competition regulator – or Bouygues might merge with Iliad.