Industry attention has been sharply focused on mobile WiMAX and the potential for mobile broadband technologies to squeeze the major cellcos by introducing new competition and lower priced mobile data services. Wi-Fi begun the process by introducing the reality, even in limited form, of flat rate IP-based data and VoIP on the move ‘ contrasting with the high costs and complex tariffing of the 3G data offerings. With WiMAX threatening, especially in the hands of non-3G license holders, to provide an even more robust alternative, the 3G-plus technologies and their backers are biting back hard. Last week we saw major carriers announcing aggressive plans for voice and data services over EV-DO Rev A, the ‘3.5G’ iteration of CDMA2000, while the equivalent in the GSM world, HSDPA, is also set to see first deployments next year. Those may address, at least for a while, the need for higher data performance to see off WiMAX operators. But they will need to go hand-in-hand with other, more pragmatic changes to compete with mobile broadband, notably in pricing structures and ease of use.
We have already seen Vodafone Germany introducing flat rate VoIP, recognizing that most customers move to IP solutions such as voice over Wi-Fi for the lower costs and the convenience and transparency of all-you-can-eat tariffs ‘ not as a technology choice. The improved spectral efficiency and bandwidth of the 3G networks will allow their owners to lower their prices ‘ as we have already seen with US cellcos’ first generation EV-DO services ‘ and introduce flat rate voice and data, and still command a decent margin, though this may be significantly lower than they hoped for when formulating their business plans at the end of the last century. 3G delivers voice, in particular, far more efficiently and cheaply than IP, but this was an benefit the operators had hoped to turn into increased profitability, whereas now it will be employed as a defensive tactic against the all-IP networks and the converged operators.
Another weapon that the Wi-Fi/WiMAX crowd has on its side is the familiarity and ease of use of the PC/IP environment for functions such as web browsing, email and data download. The 3G handset has struggled to achieve similar ease, although there is significant progress in the user interface, and there is the option of a 3G data card for laptop users, often combined, like Vodafone’s, with Wi-Fi. Now the big US cellcos are turning the increasing popularity of the wireless laptop into their next method of fighting back against Wi-Fi hotspots, VoIP and potential WiMAX services, by getting PC makers to embed 3G cards into their devices, rather than requiring a separate plug-in card.
Verizon Wireless has been promoting its 3G network, based on Qualcomm’s CDMA EV-DO technology, as a better alternative to hotspots since it started its serious roll-out to urban areas early this year. Now it has struck a real blow at claims that Intel Centrino laptops and Wi-Fi hotspots are the best high speed access option for people on the move, with deals with major PC makers to preinstall EV-DO cards in some laptop models. Hard on its heels, Cingular Wireless has announced a similar deal with key PC makers, notably Dell, for an embedded EDGE, and later HSDPA, card.
The Verizon EV-DO cards will be supported in selected models by Dell, Hewlett Packard and Lenovo (formerly IBM PC), alongside Wi-Fi. PCMCIA cards for EV-DO have been available for some time but had to be purchased separately and installed by the user. A pre-installed card puts EV-DO on the same basis as embedded Wi-Fi options such as Centrino, although it is only activated once the laptop owner signs up for a subscription with Verizon, which comes at a hefty $60 a month in addition to other 3G phone charges.
In areas where there is EV-DO coverage, the service would provide more ubiquitous access than public Wi-Fi and with mobility. However, it would currently be more expensive and there are no casual or pay-as-you-go options, though these could be expected to be introduced in future as they have been for 2G phone services. Also, until EV-DO is upgraded, from mid-2006, to its next generation Rev A, data rates are only around 700Kbps download.
Although Verizon Wireless’ joint parent, Verizon Communications, did roll out some Wi-Fi hotspots in payphone boxes in New York from 2003, the company’s core strategy is to use its cellular arm’s 3G network for mobile broadband and seek to sideline Wi-Fi and, in future, WiMAX by keeping EV-DO a step ahead in functionality. Verizon Wireless is the most advanced carrier in the US in its 3G build-out and the first to trial the next generation of EV-DO, which will achieve speeds of over 3Mbps.
Therefore, its enthusiasm for Wi-Fi has always been the most muted among the regional Bell operators and in May CEO Ivan Seidenberg denounced hotzones as ‘dumb’, and the company canned its phone box-based hotspots to avoid competing with its newly launched New York EV-DO offering.
For the previous two years, Verizon had been offering free Wi-Fi to its DSL customers when they were within 150 meters of a Verizon phone booth. Some executives believed this free option would hurt usage of EV-DO ‘ though it is more likely that it hurt uptake of non-Verizon, paid-for hotspots. At the start of this year, there were hotspots in 380 phone booths in Manhattan and Brooklyn, a contrast with the original target of over 1,000. Each cost $5,000 to deploy.
“As we continued to evaluate it the usage just wasn’t living up to expectations,” a spokeswoman told reporters. “The spots were not well utilized. Everybody’s trying to look for a business model around Wi-Fi. But the better business model in our mind is the EV-DO network.”
The three PC makers will all launch their EV-DO enabled models over the coming months. Hewlett Packard is already offering a bundled PC Card and will embed EV-DO chipsets into new notebooks from next spring. Lenovo’s new low cost Z Series Thinkpad range will boast some models equipped with EV-DO aerials and chips. Dell will also offer an embedded chip in the near future.
Such steps will help to shore up the 3G walls against the flow of converged and IP services. They certainly seem to be giving 3G supporters new confidence in trying to fight off the threat of WiMAX. Recently we saw the chief technology officer of Ericsson, which has been quietly cautious about WiMAX despite its obvious huge vested interest in W-CDMA, going on the attack and dismissing it as a mobile technology. This week saw similar comments from Vodafone, even though the giant had recently appeared more open to the idea of a multi-network approach and is even testing WiMAX, through its German fixed line unit Arcor, and the Flash-OFDM technology now owned by Qualcomm, in Japan.
The new confidence is springing from the fact that HSDPA and EV-DO Rev A networks are now close to being real, whereas at the start of the year there were still doubts over the timescales in which they would be deployable. Vodafone said this week that it would launch HSDPA next year, building on what is now the largest W-CDMA network in the world, with 50,000 base stations already deployed.
Speaking at an analyst and investor day at its UK headquarters, highly respected CTO Thomas Geitner said: ‘In the last year and a half we have been testing our four suppliers in four of our networks, and we are increasingly confident about the qualities it can deliver. This is why we think we will be ready for friendly user tests and pre-commercial tests in early 2006, then go to a full commercial launch by the middle of 2006.’ An initial trial has begun in Germany. The next upgrade, HSUPA (which speeds up the uplink) will be deployed in 2007-8. Vodafone, MMO2 and T-Mobile will all launch HSDPA some time next year, and Cingular plans to be ahead of them all in the US.
Like his counterpart at Ericsson, Geitner was dismissive of WiMAX. ‘It will offer mobility, but it will be a few years before it is going to be available in the market. To us it is not an option because it is three or four years later than HSDPA, and it wouldn’t be incremental to our W-CDMA network to go ahead and put it in.’
This is a common view among W-CDMA operators, although some like MMO2 are experimenting with a parallel WiMAX network to expand into the fixed home market or to deliver specific high bandwidth services. However, cellcos pursuing dual network roll-outs are more common in the CDMA world and outside Europe, with Sprint Nextel and South Korea Telecom among the prime examples. This is throwing a spotlight on Europe, and whether its cellcos, which paid so highly for their 3G rights, will be able to take a sufficient lead with HSDPA ‘ in terms of attractive rate plans and devices as well as applications ‘ to keep WiMAX and the converged operators at bay.
BOX
Verizon Wireless and its co-parent, Vodafone, which have not always exploited the synergies between their systems effectively, will support roaming across their networks for laptop users. Verizon Wireless’ Global Data Access offering will be able to access Vodafone’s W-CDMA system in relevant territories and users of Vodafone Mobile Connect can also purchase a package containing both links and various pricing options.
Because of the different networks, users will still need two cards, one for EV-DO and one for Vodafone 3G/GPRS. The dual-mode service costs $280 with a two-year contract and $380 for one year. Rate plans include unlimited EV-DO use in North America and up to 100Mb of GPRS/UMTS data throughput in a number of Tier 1 western European countries for $130 per month. Access in Tier 2 countries, including Australia, Brazil, China, Israel, Hong Kong, Russia, Singapore, South Africa, Taiwan and Thailand, is billed at three cents per kilobyte.
“Many of our enterprise customers have large numbers of employees who spend time traveling internationally,” explained Cindy Patterson, vice president of enterprise data for Verizon Wireless. “Our relationship with Vodafone allows us to offer our customers access to our wireless broadband network in the US and Vodafone’s Mobile Connect 3G datacard and dashboard software when they travel.’
Last year Verizon Wireless introduced its first handset and rate plans that allowed for roaming on to the Vodafone 3G network.