Verizon could raise at least $80bn in fresh debt if it were to buy out Vodafone’s 45% stake in Verizon Wireless, says one analyst, as support for such a deal rises on Wall Street.
Michael Rollins of Citigroup said in a research note that there is now a greater likelihood that Verizon will seek full control of the joint venture, its main growth driver, as it has wanted to do for some years. He wrote that a deal was “more open today from a combination of low interest rates, favorable VZW performance, lower debt leverage at the VZ parent level, strong dollar versus sterling and euro, VZW already paying a dividend to its parents, and improvement in domestic tlco valuations’.
Citigroup has upgraded Verizon to ‘buy’ from ‘neutral’ on expectation of the deal. It believes the
window of opportunity for a leveraged buy-out is now open and, despite the heavy funding with debt, it would increase Verizon’s earnings and cash almost immediately. It estimates the value of the transaction would be between $106bn and $137bn, which would require debt of between $70bn and $80bn. Funds could also come from selling Verizon’s portion of the venture’s Italian assets for about $3.5bn.
Rollins believes there is more than a 50% chance that the buy-out would be a cash-only transaction, and a 15% chance that Vodafone and Verizon will go for a full merger. He thinks it unlikely that, in the current climate, Vodafone would accept Verizon shares as payment for some or all of its stake. If that did happen, Vodafone could receive about $21bn to $31bn of preferred equity and $11bn to $22bn in common equity, equating to a stake in Verizon of 7% to 14%.
Vodafone would have US tax liabilities of about $5bn because the joint venture has stakes in Vodafone networks in Germany and Italy. If these were to become wholly Vodafone subsidiaries, and not included in the Verizon deal, then they would need to be transferred to a non-US holding company, triggering the tax bill.
Meanwhile, Verizon rival AT&T says it is would be open to selling some non-core assets, including its cell towers, to enhance its financial reserves.
Selling the towers could raise about $5bn in cash, according to estimates by RBC Capital Markets, pointing to similar moves by T-Mobile USA and others. Typically, the seller then leases back capacity on the towers but no longer has the cost of running the infrastructure.
‘We’ve seen others in the industry sell non-core assets, and if we wanted additional flexibility, that could be an option for us too,’ AT&T representative Brad Burns told Bloomberg. ‘In all cases, our decisions are driven by what’s right for the company and for our shareowners. So in that sense, nothing’s off the table. The bottom line is we have attractive assets that could be a potential source of cash.’
‘AT&T is actively considering the monetization of its tower assets in a similar fashion to several of its peers in the wireless industry,’ RBC’s Jonathan Atkin wrote in a client note. Last year, the operator sold a majority stake in its Yellow Pages division to Cerberus Capital Management for $950m. This reduced exposure to a non-core and slow growing business and helped boost funds for a year of major spending ahead ‘ the $14bn Project VIP network upgrade plan plus a stock buyback of over $11bn. Analysts estimate that AT&T will generate $14.8bn in free cashflow this year.
Although the potential transactions are clearly logical in the face of such high costs, the speculation has aroused some nervousness among investors that AT&T is short of cash to execute its grand plans.