Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 March 2013

Verizon’s LTE lead moves from coverage to roaming and voice

Verizon and AT&T have been issuing rapid-fire updates on their LTE progress, as much to stress how far ahead of the pack they are as to snipe at one another. The upshot is that both are hitting their coverage targets and will soon be looking to move beyond their initial 700MHz roll-outs to harness additional spectrum. Verizon’s progress has been quicker, partly because of skilful strategies ‘ a bold headstart, a roll-out pace everyone thought was a dream, taking advantage of the AT&T/T-Mobile merger saga and then pulling the rug from under its rival with its cable spectrum deal. But Verizon is also more desperate, to get away from a CDMA technology with no growth path, while AT&T can afford to be more leisurely, filling in LTE gaps with evolutions of HSPA.

Recent statistics from RootMetrics say that AT&T’s LTE network performs, on average, 4.3Mbps faster than Verizon’s (for download), at 16.8Mbps (9Mbps uplink), but the latter’s provides wider and more consistent coverage. In a Verizon market, Root testers were connected to a Verizon LTE signal 93.2% of the time, while for AT&T the number was 81.7%.

Entertaining as the race is, last month’s Mobile World Congress highlighted the fact that the LTE market has already grown up and moved beyond measuring operators purely by how many POPs they cover. There may be only a small percentage of cellcos with commercial LTE of any scale, but already the leaders are addressing more thorny problems than just coverage and capacity ‘ how to build HetNets, how to innovate in charging and services. Many of these are issues which have not troubled mobile operators much in the past, but the old concerns of 2G and 3G still linger too, among them voice support and roaming.

These are hoary old chestnuts as far as cellco concerns go, but they refuse to be sorted out easily with each successive generation of technology. Both are being addressed intensively in the US, whose carriers will prove valuable benchmarks for peers round the world.

Verizon is the one to watch again. Not just because it has the world’s largest LTE network, by size and subscribers, but because its challenges and situation are more akin to those of mainstream operators than the other frontrunners in Japan and Korea. NTT Docomo and SK Telecom are in the vanguard as far as deploying new LTE-Advanced features, but their customer bases and market conditions are very much out of the norm. So all eyes are on Verizon, to see how its strategy of rapid LTE roll-out, complete with full IMS, will pay off, and how successful it will be in its bid to escape CDMA as soon as possible ‘ with all the issues that brings for voice, roaming and coverage.

According to CTO Nicola Palmer, in an interview with FierceWireless,the build-out in 700MHz is almost complete and will cover 90% of the US population by year end. It currently covers 273m POPs. Verizon admits the last 10% will be the hardest, because it involves sparsely populated rural areas with limited profit potential ‘ hence the company’s program of partnerships with about 20 rural cellcos, giving them access to its spectrum in return for roaming deals.

Next, the operator plans to add 5,000 cell sites in the AWS (1.7GHz/2.1GHz) band this year, to provide extra capacity in busy areas. Verizon acquired significant swathes of AWS spectrum, to add to its existing holdings, via its landmark deal with four cablecos. Comcast, Time Warner, BrightHouse and Cox have offloaded their spectrum, along with their former dreams of creating their own mobile networks, and have also signed MVNO and cross-marketing agreements with Verizon. This alliance outwitted both their former MVNO host and spectrum partner, Sprint, and AT&T, whose own play for more frequencies, via a T-Mobile takeover, foundered last year on regulatory opposition. That left the company scrabbling for extra LTE spectrum from other sources, buying up small cellcos and turning to non-mainstream bands like WCS and unpaired 700MHz.

In 2014, Verizon will expand coverage in the AWS band and by then expects to have a strong selection of devices supporting both its LTE frequencies ‘ the first with AWS LTE will debut before midyear and the network will go live in the second half of this year. Its attention will be turning from coverage to capacity ‘ it has sufficient AWS spectrum to double its 4G capacity nationwide, and to triple it east of Mississippi. Verizon is taking the opposite route from many European and other cellcos, going for near-universal coverage first and then infilling capacity hotspots. By contrast, many carriers are using LTE initially just for those hotzones, relying on fallback to HSPA+ to provide decent broadband speeds on a nationwide basis, and then will overlay 4G as capacity demands grow. Of course, a key reason for the different strategy is that Verizon is coming to the end of what CDMA can offer, since there is no equivalent to the HSPA+ evolutionary roadmap to ensure that 3G customers can still receive strong, and improving, mobile experience.

The aggressive roll-out means that Verizon has the potential, ahead of almost every other major carrier in the world, to turn off legacy networks at an early stage and harness its entire spectrum holdings for LTE. Indeed, it believes it will have its first LTE-only handsets, for users who never need to leave an area of 4G coverage, next year. This ambitious timeframe also led it to take a critical decision on voice ‘ not to support any kind of fallback to 2G/3G, for users who roam out of LTE coverage, because by 2014 that would be such a rare occurrence that it would not be worthwhile investing in fallback support in devices.

But that, of course, puts pressure on Verizon to implement VoLTE ‘ the only carrier controlled voice option for pure 4G ‘ before its users defect to over-the-top alternatives. MetroPCS and the Korean operators have already gone live with VoLTE, but many challenges remain in terms of device availability, roaming, and the ability to generate any money from voice in the age of Skype. The most common approach to the last of these issues is to deploy VoLTE not on its own ‘ a new voice platform is no more than a finger in the dyke, keeping the cellco in the game ‘ but as part of a broader set of messaging and communication services. The aim of initiatives like RCSe (Rich Communications Suite ‘ enhanced), and its brand name Joyn are to create services which leverage the capabilities of the carrier network to offer superior functionality to OTT alternatives. MetroPCS, SK Telecom and others are pursuing full RCS platforms, while other operators, like those in Germany and Spain, are implementing RCS/Joyn while still at the 3G stage, addressing issues like interoperability before they have to grapple with VoLTE too.

Verizon plans to deploy VoLTE early next year ‘ indeed will have to, if it sticks to its plan of going LTE-only in some areas. CFO Fran Shammo told the recent Deutsche Bank telecoms conference that this would spur some fundamental changes in the carrier’s device strategies. Introducing LTE-only products for some users would lower costs and subsidies, and put Verizon in the driving seat in directing how OEMs and component makers design for this space. Lower cost ‘pure 4G’ devices could accelerate uptake of Verizon 4G services just at a time when competition from T-Mobile and Sprint will be gathering pace. Shammo said: “We will ultimately get to voice over LTE, probably end of this year, beginning of next year. Then if you look out into late 2014 then you start to think of things like, now I can start to take the CDMA chip out of the phone and just have a pure LTE handset. That also starts to reduce subsidies. So over the next two to three years I think we will start to see subsidies come down.”

Verizon seems lukewarm about RCS however ‘ VoLTE is very much part of its almost unique strategy to go 4G-only in a remarkably short timeframe. In her interview, Palmer seemed to dismiss the idea of supporting Joyn ‘ even as MetroPCS, in advance of its T-Mobile merger, was announcing that Ericsson would upgrade its core network to enhance the Joyn experience it offers. Verizon is more centered on taking a lead in roaming ‘ an area in which its options were limited when it was the CDMA flagship in a GSM-led world.

The carrier is looking for foreign partners, as Greg Dial, director for global roaming, explained at MWC. He said: ‘We have a plan, and we are surveying the market and looking at our travel centres to see where US customers are going. It’s a wide variety of destinations but certainly the UK is a market we look at very closely; the Caribbean and Latin America too, and Canada and Mexico.’ He said he was in Barcelona to build those relationships, ‘both outbound but we’re also open for business for inbound roaming as well. If the bands match up with either 700 or in the future AWS, or deeper in the future, with future bands, we are very excited to have customers come in and use what is, at least right now, the largest 4G LTE network in the US and I believe in the world.’

However, some companies believe the old system of bilateral roaming deals will be stretched to breaking point by LTE and the multitude of services and technologies ‘ including RCS and VoLTE ‘ that will need to be taken into account. Tata Communications is one organization that claims LTE roaming will be structured around hubs, not two-way agreements ‘ more like some Wi-Fi and former WiMAX arrangements. The advantage for carriers is that the hubs are usually run by a third party and so many of the complexities of the contract, set-up and management are hidden from the operator. The disadvantage for powerful cellcos is they lose their place at the top of the roaming pecking order, and their ability to charge accordingly.

A key technology to enable LTE roaming hubs will be routers and hubs supporting the Diameter signalling protocol and IPX. While Diameter handles signalling, authentication and policy control, IPX takes care of data roaming and transport. Ben Volkow, former CEO of Diameter specialist Traffix, and now VP of product development at its acquirer F5, said roaming and the challenges of VoLTE are the real opportunities for Diameter Signal Routers (DSRs), a category of equipment which came to prominence when a series of carriers, including Verizon, suffered outages a year or so ago. These were attributed to ‘signalling storms’ caused by excessive traffic from ‘chatty’ applications which constantly poll the network, such as social updates. Diameter routers are a way to handle those storms more efficiently, but also have broader application in roaming, real time charging and other critical LTE issues.

‘The Diameter debate has moved on from just defensive needs to the business model,’ said Volkow. Combining signal routing with expertise in billing, provisioning and roaming is key. ‘Billing and policy are where the activity is, more than signal traffic,’ he added. ‘Signal storms got us lots of profile but they are not the whole issue. Policy storms are far more unpredictable. It’s like having to take an umbrella all the time, not just when the weather forecast is bad.’

The Diameter vendors, such as Tekelec, F5, Syniverse and Tata (which recently launched its Diameter Signalling eXchange platform) are pushing themselves into the heart of cellco strategy and roaming will soon be in that spot. Tata’s VP of sales for Asia-Pacific, Conor Carroll, said: ‘Are operators really going to put together over 400 LTE roaming agreements one by one on a bilateral basis? I don’t think anyone is going to do this by themselves. Lots of operators do their roaming through managed services already. We’re seeing bilateral relationships at first, but we’ll see demand for hubbing.’

Tata’s LTE roaming service will be offered as bundled service with the SCCP (Signaling Connection Control Part) service, so existing customers can add LTE on top of their current roaming service, while new customers can get the full 2G/3G/4G package. Tata can handle settlements for roaming, and its policy control feature can enable different tariff plans, like day passes and other roaming package deals.

The sweet spots for these vendors were highlighted by last summer’s acquisition of Mach by fellow roaming services provider Syniverse. The latter had just announced its LTE Hub, which provides a portfolio of 4G roaming services, including customer care, billing, clearing and settlement. This is built around its Prime IPX Network Solution, which connects operators to the firm’s global all-IP network and a suite of 4G solutions. These include Diameter and SIP signalling to support LTE and IMS interworking and roaming, as well as compatibility with legacy networks; real time tracking of all the data travelling over the IPX system, which can be harnessed to optimize the customer experience; clearing and settlement; and interoperability for all kinds of messaging including video and RCS. Despite all these topical capabilities, Syniverse knew it would need even broader facilities to demonstrate to its customers that it could enable a profitable IP roaming model. Mach’s cloud-based portfolio brought additional functions including fraud prevention and revenue assurance, plus increased real time intelligence capabilities. Mach also extended its support for Wi-Fi offload, local break-out and multi-SIM roaming.

From 2013 there will be rising demand from consumers to be able to roam onto partner networks, and this will not just be about coverage, as in earlier generations, but the subscribers will also demand the same quality of experience as on the home system ‘ an experience for which cellcos increasingly hope to charge. Those drivers, combined with broad IMS deployment ‘ much delayed, but finally given its fillip by LTE ‘ will see operators embarking on a major change of approach to roaming, partly because they will be using IP-based standards like IPX and Diameter, rather than their familiar frameworks like GRX and SS7. That will create challenges, especially with regards to 3G integration, voice and fragmented spectrum bands. It will also open up opportunities to support different classes of service or to boost the user’s speeds by keeping their traffic on the remote network.

IPX is the next generation, all-IP successor to GRX (GPRS Roaming Exchange, the key roaming framework for 2G and 3G data). IPX was designed to support consistent user experience even on partner systems, and so can support the rising use of service level agreements in mobile, and the introduction of tariffs tiered by QoS levels. It does this by guaranteeing enough bandwidth to keep services running at optimum speeds. It is increasingly being adopted as a standard for interconnecting fixed and mobile carriers, MVNOs and over-the-top providers, enabling international giants like BT to work with large numbers of partners and deliver common services across vast networks.

IPX in the mobile world lives within a GSMA-defined communications ecosystem which supports multiple services – voice, data and signalling – over a single IP connection and provides many other benefits, including enhanced voice quality, cascaded billing and payments and ‘ because an IPX is physically and logically separate from the public internet – security. Within this, IPX enables the use of Diameter signalling for the exchange of policy, authentication and mobility information between networks as users roam, and for local break-out (LBO), a more efficient approach to handling roaming traffic, which reduces latency and boosts data rates.

The move to IP not only provides for a wider variety of interoperable services, but simplifies the topology for greater efficiency, with a distributed pattern closer to that seen in wireline broadband. IPX backbones and Diameter signalling enable LBO, in which data traffic is offloaded to the roaming network, rather than being routed first back to the home system. This was demonstrated last November by Australia’s Telstra and its Hong Kong arm CSL, using Telstra’s GRX (GPRS roaming exchange) to transport network signaling using the Diameter protocol between the two networks. Telstra LTE customers roaming on CSL tested apps like HD videoconferencing and video streaming, and using LBO delivered the same speed for roamers as local subscribers, and reduced latency by 90% compared to 3G roaming. Christian Daigneault, CTO at CSL, pointed out a key benefit of IPX/Diameter: “With 3G, there is no local break-out because operators want the traffic sent back home to them so that they can charge for it. LTE brings signaling into the picture, so you can still charge for data even with local break-out.”

There are other hurdles to effective roaming ‘ regulatory pressure on roaming fees, which carriers say will deter them from investing heavily; the fragmented nature of LTE spectrum bands, and the need for more multiband devices; and specific issues surrounding voice roaming in a mixed VoLTE/fallback environment. But LTE uptake is driven by users’ desire for better data rates and quality of experience, improvements which operators hope to be able to monetize ‘ which means that consistent QoS is perhaps the most vital challenge of all for roaming systems, and one which will drive growth for vendors of IP equipment, and also for the roaming providers which can offer the most profit-focused hubs or managed services.

All eyes will be on Verizon once it signs those promised LTE roaming partners, to see how it harnesses the new technologies to move beyond mere international coverage, towards a full portfolio of international services ‘ the same shift already seen in its home 4G strategies.