Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 July 2008

Vodafone and Lenovo point to new 3G notebook business models

The trend for laptop makers to offer embedded 3G and a contract with an operator is growing, and raises question marks over how keen the PC industry will be to embed WiMAX too, despite Intel’s huge influence over the sector. The latest development is an agreement between Vodafone and Lenovo, to pre-instal a Vodafone SIM and software in the X200 notebook, offering embedded 3G at no extra cost, plus a 30-day free trial for services.

At the end of the trial, prices will be about £12 ($24) a month, with automatic roaming in Europe for £8.50 ($17) a day. The deal indicates the eagerness of cellcos to get into the laptop, which ‘ despite the rapid evolution of smartphones and mobile internet devices ‘ remains the primary vehicle for business and heavy duty mobile data usage. Uptake of carrier’s 3G USB dongles has been rocketing, and embedded broadband provides even greater convenience ‘ at the downside, however, of making it hard for users to switch to an alternative service provider to the one supported by the PC firm.

This highlights the added attraction for cellcos of a deal like Vodafone’s with Lenovo ‘ the opportunity, just as the mobile world is shifting towards open access, to lock PCs into the carrier network in the same way as handsets. This is the opposite of the vision set out by Intel and the PC internet industry, of open networks such as Wi-Fi and WiMAX on which users can run any device they choose. The Vodafone move raises doubts over this vision, suggesting that subscribers will opt for coverage, roaming and ease of use over openness, and also places question marks over the assumption that, whatever its fortunes in other markets, WiMAX will triumph in the notebook. Lenovo said it had no firm plan to incorporate WiMAX, and its rivals may also be looking askance at using up valuable notebook real estate on another radio, at least until large networks are built out ‘ the perennial chicken and egg dilemma of the mobile world.

Research firm Gartner Group recently forecast that the use of embedded modems for mobile broadband connectivity will increase rapidly in the next few years, with sales estimated to grow at a rate of 94.3% between 2008 and 2012.

While embedded 3G may provide a useful spur to notebook sales and 3G uptake, some companies are looking for more disruptive effects from the wireless PC. A couple months ago we discussed the AOL UK business model of giving away a free laptop with its broadband service, something that would also be a logical extension of subsidizing handsets and dongles, for mobile operators. As laptops and ultra-mobile PCs with embedded cellular broadband come to market, why not subsidize these also to continue the mobile broadband subscriber landgrab?

Last week, Acer was reported to be in talks with several European network operators to supply its Aspire One ultra-mobile PC with built-in 3G. According to an Acer representative, the company is discussing supply with the likes of T-Mobile International, Vodafone Group and Orange in Europe, as well as Chunghwa Telecom and Taiwan Mobile in Asia. The Aspire One weighs around one kilogram and sports an 8.9-inch screen. In addition to supporting Wi-Fi, the device also has a slot available for a mobile broadband module, enabling support for HSPA, EV-DO or WiMAX. The UMPC costs around $499, but it appears that Acer sees the opportunity for mobile service providers to subsidize part of that cost to encourage subscribers to sign up for a 3G contract. According to Techworld, other UMPC makers are currently in talks with mobile operators, including Asustek Computer with its Eee PC and Taiwan’s ECS with its G10IL Netbook. ECS claims to have already signed up wireless service providers in Europe for distribution.

Make no mistake: the availability of subsidized laptops or UMPCs is a boon for consumers. Laptop prices have fallen dramatically over the past few years and penetration has jumped accordingly. Around 109m notebook PCs shipped worldwide in 2007, a growth of 33% compared to 2006. If an operator knocks another 50% off the cost, or a full 100%, sourcing a laptop from a carrier may become the preferred purchase option. It would be interesting to explore how such a development would impact the notebook OEM business mobile. Would the dynamics shift to mirror the operator/handset OEM model? Will there be specifications sent to the OEM requiring operators share branding on the device?

Regardless, with operators not having any value added content or service to upsell on a laptop or UMPC device, the business model ultimately boils down to a monthly subscription and fixed contract which allows the operator to recover the cost of the terminal plus provide revenue from mobile internet access. Essentially, this is a pure bitpipe offering. With few 3G networks worldwide at full capacity, operators view the retail of mobile broadband computing products as an incremental revenue stream on top of their core voice and messaging service. However, they should not be surprised at what’s in store for their future. As the practise spreads to all operators and with the lack of any product differentiation, prices will fall. Not only will this hit margins but, more worryingly, it will adversely affect how operators price their handset data tariffs. After all, how can an operator charge $30 to add an unlimited data offering to a handset tariff when they’re charging the same, or less, for a mobile broadband package which includes a free laptop?