Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 November 2015

Vodafone CEO fears ‘remonopolization’ will hit its ongoing recovery

Vodafone’s half-year results marked an “important turning point”, said CEO Vittorio Colao, with a return to organic growth in service revenue and pre-tax income. He took the opportunity of the call to discuss the results to dismiss the idea that Vodafone might break in two, hiving off its higher growth activities in emerging markets; and to launch another attack on BT’s proposed acquisition of the UK’s largest mobile operator, EE.

In organic terms, service revenue in the first six months of 2015 rose by a modest but significant 1%, year-on-year, to £18.43bn, while EBITDA was up 1.9% to £5.8bn. “This is a return to organic EBITDA growth and margin stabilization after six halves of contraction,” said CFO Nick Read during the earnings call.

However, in the full results, which also include non-organic factors (acquisitions and currency rates, mainly), the figures were less rosy – revenues fell by 2.3% to £20.3bn ($30.7bn), while EBITDA was down by 1.7%, to £5.8bn ($8.8bn).

And post-tax terms, Vodafone reported a first-half net loss of about £1.6bn ($2.4bn), reversing a year-ago net profit of £5.5bn ($8.3bn), mainly because of the heavy costs of its Project Spring network capex program.

“We are achieving 4G leadership in Europe, organic revenue growth in fixed and enterprise and sustained commercial momentum in emerging markets, all of which is consistent with our long term strategy and which is being accelerated through our Project Spring investments. We also remain keenly focused on increasing efficiency and improving margins,” Colao said.

For the past few quarters, there have been signs of recovery in Vodafone’s European heartland, which has been buffeted since 2008 by financial crises and the recessions in the south of the region. This means the logic behind splitting off the emerging market operations, which have generated much of the growth, to give them freedom from the burden of the legacy businesses, is weakened.

And in fact, one of the key reasons a demerger was reportedly under discussion was that it might have eased a merger with cable giant Liberty Global. The two companies were in talks about a deal that would have created a regional fixed/mobile superpower, but despite all the reasons to favour such an outcome, they failed to come to an agreement on valuations and other matters.

That proposed arrangement might have involved an exchange of European assets, with Vodafone’s other regions not involved. Similarly, periodic rumors that AT&T is interested in bidding for the UK-based mobile giant have usually revolved around a European deal, with the other territories spun off.

However, with Vodafone apparently going it alone for a while longer at least, Colao told the analysts that such a split would not be “value creating”. He said a global operation had greater procurement power as well as other advantages, saying: “In September we discussed the contribution that central functions give to emerging markets and the contribution of emerging markets to central functions. We buy a lot in India – data is democratizing the world, with the same devices used everywhere, and it’s better to remain in the current set-up.”

Vodafone is still, however, seriously considering an IPO of its Indian subsidiary and Colao hinted that the door has not entirely closed on Liberty. “We looked at swapping assets and couldn’t find an agreement on values,” he said. “We parked it but we are still here.”

Overall, Colao was in positive mood, despite the loss, for now, of the chance to accelerate its expansion in fixed-line and quad play services dramatically via Liberty. Vodafone has been building up these capabilities around Europe with piecemeal acquisitions such as Ono, Kabel Deutschland and C&W Wireless, but Liberty would have turned it into a genuine quad play giant overnight.

However, Vodafone has crossed some milestones all by itself. As well as the return to underlying growth, it says its massive Project Spring investment in its networks has started to pay for itself during this fiscal year. It increased its full year guidance slightly and now expects to generate EBITDA of between £11.7bn and £12bn ($17.7bn-$18.2bn) compared with an earlier forecast of £11.5 to £12bn.

Project Spring is the ambitious spending program designed to turn Vodafone into a converged giant without the help of Liberty. “Spring has helped us accelerate into a converged company,” said Colao. “We’ve been in a very intense year of launching broadband products and we’ll be launching TV in others in the remaining part of the year – in every country we are developing this strategy.”

However, the costs are hitting the results, as seen in the net loss. Capex as a percentage of revenue is currently about 20% because of Project Spring, up from the previous norm of about 13%, but Vodafone expects to return to customary levels once Spring is completed (it’s about halfway through). The spending is going on accelerating expansion of the LTE-Advanced networks and services in Europe, on upgrading 3G and 4G systems in the emerging economies, and on new generation fiber in its quad play markets.

These investments are designed to differentiate Vodafone in high value new services for consumers (quad play, with the UK set to get a TV launch next year); enterprises and the internet of things (IoT). While Vodafone has often been outpaced by rivals in pushing LTE to its limits, it is taking the lead in trialling the proposed NB-IoT standard, which will support low power wide area applications in areas like smart cities, on the LTE network.

Vodafone said its 4G network now covers about 80% of Europe and that it can provide high-speed broadband services to about 66m households, 42% of those on its own infrastructure and the rest through access deals with companies like BT.

The European businesses are still under pressure, with their service revenues down 6.2% to £12.1bn, while the Africa, Middle East and Asia Pacific unit enjoyed 1.8% growth in service revenue, reaching £5.9bn, or about half of the total. Vodafone noted “continued competitive pressures in a number of markets” in Europe, although revenue trends are improving. Key metrics in the mobile business, such as ARPU, are stabilizing, but the importance of the quad play strategy is clear in the fact that fixed lines now bring in almost 26% of service revenue in Europe, up from 22.6% a year ago.

It provides postpaid mobile services to 91m customers, up from 86m a year ago, and has 12.5m fixed broadband subscribers, though fewer than half of them (5.6m) are on next-generation connections – something Vodafone will need to chance to make sense of the wireline side of Spring.

“The more we are in fixed-line the more we are marching on to turf that someone else does not want us to be on,” Colao said, referring to incumbents like Deutsche Telekom and Telefonica. “We need to ask regulators to be firmer to avoid re-monopolization. That is a priority and will be more important in coming months.”

Colao is particularly concerned about the competitive position in Vodafone’s home country, the ultra-competitive UK, where incumbent telco BT hopes to finalize its acquisition of EE soon, having crossed most of the regulatory hurdles. Meanwhile, Telefonica is looking to sell its O2 UK mobile arm to Hutchison, to add to its 3UK holding, though this deal may have a tougher time with the antitrust authorities.

All this consolidation will put intense competitive pressure on Vodafone, and may drive it back to Liberty to negotiate a deal in the UK at least (Liberty owns the largest cableco there, Virgin Media). For now, Colao is still trying to put an eleventh hour spanner in BT’s works and used the earnings call to make his point again. “If as a result of consolidation one player controls 90% of backhaul and 60% of 4G-ready frequencies… and if BT ends up controlling three-quarters of access lines, then it’s bad,” he said.

In a radio interview after the results announcement, Colao went further, reiterating calls for stronger regulatory controls on an enlarged BT and accusing the firm of exploiting consumers. He cast doubt on the regulatory division between BT’s retail activities and its Openreach wholesale division, which is designed to ensure fair access for rivals to BT’s infrastructure. “Openreach is clearly…not working to help competition and choice,” Colao told BBC Radio 4, adding that the unit is “making extra profit out of what they charge to the British consumers and instead they should be an independent company really bringing next generation networks…to the homes of the British citizens.” Instead, those citizens are stranded in “slow lanes”, he said.

While the EE takeover is almost a done deal, Vodafone still has the chance to influence regulator Ofcom’s other review of BT, which is examining its structure and which could seek the break-up of the telco. Colao, naturally, supports the idea of splitting off Openreach to protect third parties’ access to mobile backhaul and broadband access lines on an equal basis with BT’s retail arm. Such a plan would avoid the rising risk of UK “remonopolization,” he argued, warning: “We are unwinding 30 years of competition.”

“Companies like these…like to use what they have, which is the copper network, and modernize it to basically reduce competition. And companies like us, but also Sky or TalkTalk or other companies, are forced to use it,” he said. “It might be working financially for Gavin Patterson and BT. They are overcharging consumers and now they want to use taxpayers’ money to bring internet to the rural areas.” With EE under its belt, BT will control 90% of mobile backhaul lines, and 60% of 4G-ready spectrum, he claimed.

Nevertheless, the UK’s Communications and Markets Authority (CMA) recently gave preliminary approval to the deal, saying it would not harm competition in the retail or wholesale markets.