The money is already on the table for Vodafone to give up its 45% holding in Verizon Wireless, with informal approaches confirmed this week by Verizon executives mentioning a figure of $40bn to UK newspapers.
In the mean time, the cellco has confirmed that it will sell its Japanese arm to Softbank, in a deal valued at £8.9bn. Of this, £6.8bn will be received by Vodafone in cash and £6bn of this will be distributed to shareholders in cash. SoftBank will assume approximately £800m of external debt and other liabilities outstanding from Vodafone Japan.
Vodafone and Softbank have also entered into discussions regarding the formation of a joint working relationship, involving participation in the supply and distribution of data and content. The purpose of the relationship, says Vodafone, is also to provide knowledge and information sharing between the two parties and to ensure that Vodafone continues to have access to the ongoing technological and service developments in the mobile industry in Japan.
The Softbank deal means rejecting an alternative approach from US private equity firms Cerberus Partners and Providence Equity Partners, which were working to secure financing, to the tune of many billions of dollars in debt, to counterbid for Vodafone Japan. Other private equity firms were also looking to mount a bid, including Newbridge Capital of Hong Kong, Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co of the US and Permira Advisers. The Softbank purchase will be the largest leveraged buy-out in Japanese history.
The speed of the Japanese deal will intensify speculation that the UK cellco will also exit the US. In January Vodafone shareholders put CEO Arun Sarin under increasing pressure to dump its 45% stake in Verizon Wireless hoping for a windfall of $43bn to perhaps $50bn. The figure of $40bn has been put out there merely to make it clear that Verizon is serious and given Sarin’s (and our) belief that it is the wrong time to get out of the US, he will take some convincing. Tough negotiation on behalf of his shareholders is one way for him to redeem himself in their eyes after warning last quarter that there are relatively lean times ahead.
Big Vodafone investors, Standard Life and Morley Fund Management, have both expressed concern about strategy, and leaked those concerns to UK newspapers in January.
Vodafone had one chance of getting a controlling stake in a major US mobile operation and that was when AT&T Wireless was for sale. Its shareholders let it down then by urging restraint and in the end this went for a very high price to Cingular. Most investors want Vodafone to work on low hanging fruit in third world countries, where there is less competition, to compensate for saturation of its core western European territories.
The strife between Vodafone shareholders and its board is now so evident that private equity groups are supposed to be considering a buyout of Vodafone for upwards of $170bn, but even those that have discussed it with the media have no real idea of how they’d raise that amount of money, given that it would eat all of Europe’s debt market in one go.
A speedy sale in Japan will restore some of Sarin’s favour among large shareholders, and he is tightening his CEO’s grip by reducing the influence of the ‘old guard’ of Vodafone executives associated with previous CEO Sir Christopher Gent. Gent himself said last weekend that he plans to step down as honorary life president of Vodafone after media speculation that he was interfering with senior management at the company and undermining Sarin. The increasingly acrimonious boardroom battle has not only led Gent to retire from the fray, denying any involvement in the ‘whispering campaign’ against the current CEO, but also seen Sarin getting rid of various senior executives, most recently head of marketing Peter Bamford. Deputy CEO Julian Horn Smith and finance director Ken Hydon, both also closely associated with Gent, are soon to leave also. Lord MacLaurin, Vodafone’s chairman, issued a statement of support for Sarin, but also said he was sad at Gent’s sudden departure, blaming it on ‘the appalling culture of spin’ that now pervades Vodafone.
However, whatever the boardroom politics, Sarin himself has done very little spinning lately. His ejection of Bamford and his U-turn on selling in Japan have been swift and pragmatic, and there has been little attempt to dress them up as anything other than what they are ‘ survival tactics for a CEO who needs some breathing space from shareholder frustration and boardroom divisions, to put together a coherent strategy for Vodafone’s future growth in its much changed markets. This growth will not be assured by personnel changes or sale in Japan but these could give Sarin some leeway to create some more compelling plans. We hope that his current pragmatism and short term necessities do not lead him to throw the baby out with the bathwater and pull out of the US.