Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 June 2015

Vodafone Connect an inadequate lifeboat in flood of UK consolidation

Vodafone has belatedly moved into the multiplay market in its home UK market, an essential move if the company is not to be drowned by the wave of consolidation in the country. The mobile operator urgently needs to increase its access to fixed-line and content platforms if it is to stay afloat in the race to offer quad play bundles, the primary source of new revenue and market share in the over-competitive UK market. It will be left disadvantaged if the current proposed UK mergers go ahead.

If so, BT will buy the largest MNO, EE, to create the most comprehensive multiplay platform in the country, while Hutchison Whampoa will acquire Telefonica O2, merging it with its own Three UK arm to create the largest MNO by subscribers – and leaving Vodafone as the smallest mobile carrier in its home market, and with no convincing quad play.

At least it seems unlikely Vodafone will have to deal with the fall-out from another recently rumored acquisition – a bid by German incumbent Deutsche Telekom for BT. Reports in the UK’s Daily Telegraph newspaper suggested that DT was planning a bid, having freed up funds by selling its 50% stake in EE, and potentially its 67% stake in T-Mobile USA (which has been linked, once again, to Dish Network). But although BT could significantly boost its German peer’s ambitions to create a pan-European IP network to support enterprise and carrier services, it could only be a near term target if its own purchase of EE fell through. The terms of the proposed deal preclude DT from owning more than 15% of BT for three years after the date of the sale of EE, which is expected in early 2016 (DT will become the firm’s largest shareholder after that transaction, with a 12% stake).

A BT-DT mega-merger may not be an immediate prospect, but the very fact that it is being rumored suggests that the country-by-country consolidation of fixed and mobile operators is likely to go pan-regional soon, as European markets saturate.

DT’s strategy is to exit the US and build a cross-border, all-IP network across the European region, though it says it is not looking to expand outside its current footprint for now. But its all-IP conversion could be the catalyst to grow more ambitious, according to analysts at Goldman Sachs. They believe DT could acquire operators in several regions to extend its IP reach, while improving margins by offloading all the pre-IP activities and employees.

“We believe that Deutsche Telekom’s decision to take BT equity in exchange for its share of EE creates a strategic option for Deutsche Telekom over the long term, should the case for pan-European consolidation become more concrete either due to regulatory change or as the existence of cross-border cost savings becomes proven in Eastern Europe,” wrote Tim Boddy, an analyst with Goldman Sachs, in a research note.

A Vodafone-Liberty combination would be another example of regional consolidation, if with different objectives – though the companies said, when they confirmed last week that they were holding talks, that they were not contemplating an all-out merger, but merely the exchange of certain assets. Those smaller deals could involve combining Vodafone UK with Liberty’s Virgin Media subsidiary, the country’s largest cableco. Competition regulators willing, that would enable Vodafone to build a full quad play platform, to keep up with BT’s plans in that area. The incumbent telco has already harnessed an extensive MVNO deal with EE, and aggressive WiFi activities, to add wireless to its broadband, telephony and TV services, and now hopes to go a step further with the full takeover of EE.

As a result, all the UK players are chasing the wherewithal to compete in the multiplay, the chief source of revenue growth in the consumer market in this hyper-competitive country, and potentially the basis of new businesses, such as internet of things services, in future.

Against that wider context, Vodafone’s initial quad play moves look modest, and rather late, given that EE, BT, TalkTalk and others have already announced launches. But unless it does merge with Virgin in future, its room for manoeuvre is limited, relying on its acquisition of Cable & Wireless Worldwide a few years ago and on fiber deals with BT. However, Cindy Rose, MD of Vodafone’s consumer division, said the firm will have passed more than 22m premises by the end of this summer, “to give us parity with BT”. She added: “In less than one year we’ve completed full technical trials, connected to more than 1,000 exchanges and have more than 20m premises passed.”

The main aim is to offer more services to existing mobile users, rather than to take on BT head-to-head in the wider market at this stage. Bundling should help Vodafone hang on to its mobile users, and to generate more revenues and stickiness from them by adding residential fiber connectivity as well as its growing range of exclusive content. Existing Vodafone subscribers will get the new service for £5 a month plus line rental, with a free router.

However, Vodafone really needs to reverse recent declines in market share by luring brand new customers, and despite providing an Easy Switching service, some analysts think it has not gone far enough to do that yet, largely because it is not offering an integrated multiplay. In particular, it needs to include more home entertainment, and perhaps some modern options such as smart home services, if only to make its differentiation clear, and make up for the fact that, though well-priced, it is not the cheapest choice.

John Delaney from IDC told TotalTelecom: “Vodafone Connect is certainly an emphatic and ambitious entry into the UK’s home broadband market. However, a growing and lucrative percentage of that market is looking for a multiplay bundle, either triple play or (increasingly) quad play. At present, one element of multiplay is conspicuously absent from Connect: TV.” With BT TV stealing market share from Sky and Virgin, the pay-TV market is already hotly contested, so while Vodafone has been hinting at a TV entry, it will be tough to stand out from the crowd.

Rose commented at the launch: “We started with our existing customers as a way of giving them first access to the product and to thank them. Our plan is to open up to new-to-Vodafone customers later in the year … We will be following with TV later this year, but I can’t say any more right now.”

There are some elements of differentiation in its Connect proposition however. For instance, it is launching a companion app to control WiFi usage, with options such as ‘Boost’, which gives bandwidth priority to certain devices; ‘Family Time’, which imposes time-based usage restrictions for other devices and controls guest access; and ‘Beam’, a beamforming signal booster.

Meanwhile, the UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) agreed this week to fast-track its review of the BT/EE deal, moving straight to phase two of the investigation. This was at the request of BT, but will nevertheless be a very detailed investigation, since the CMA has already decided the proposed merger does threaten competition in the UK market (that judgement makes phase one unnecessary).

“The transaction … gives rise to a realistic prospect of a substantial lessening of competition in relation to the supply of wholesale access and call origination services to mobile virtual network operators and fiber mobile backhaul services to mobile network operators in the UK,” the CMA ruled. Third parties will be able to present their views during the phase two investigation.

While the review process churns along, BT and EE are not standing still. Both have recently launched new video content services, harnessing LTE Broadcast and 4K. BT plans to leapfrog the BBC and Sky in launching 4K offerings while adding new exclusive sports content, including the UEFA Champions League and Europa League in soccer, to BT TV.

And EE has launched a real time 4G-enabled action and activities camera, Action Cam, allowing users to broadcast and live-stream content via its new personal broadcasting service, called skeegle. It comes with a choice of data plans – shared, monthly, or pay as you go.

This is part of a new, broader ‘Connected Strategy’, which will support “products that give [customers] the very best experiences, coupled with the most innovative and exciting ways in which to share them,” as CEO Olaf Swantee put it. Like other operators, EE is looking beyond smartphones to other connected devices which might generate new revenues. Its new strategy has four elements – Connected Home; Connected You, for users to “play, keep fit, interact and share on the go”; Connected Car; and Connected Business.