Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 November 2005

Vodafone prepares radical tactics to restore confidence

Japan is becoming Vodafone’s Vietnam, with the giant cellco determinedly staying in the market despite its deeply negative effect on financial results and investor confidence. It is one of a string of problems facing the company, whose shares tumbled in value by 11% last week ‘ the largest drop in seven years – on warnings that its free cashflow would actually decline next fiscal year and that it was seeing lower top line growth on smaller margins, because of tough competition in Europe and weakness in Japan. The company needs some drastic remedies, but it is already hinting that it is willing to take them. After all, this is never a corporation that could be accused of timidity, and it will be prepared to topple all kinds of sacred cows to get back on track, amid market conditions that will only get worse.

Already over the past weeks we have seen a shift from the old ambition of establishing the brand and a top two market share in every major market, towards a more selective focus on high growth territories. Vodafone Sweden, then, was sold to Telenor, while Vodafone is to spend £1.35bn on increasing its stake in South Africa’s Telkom to 50% and £820m on a 10% share in India’s leading cellco Bharti, and is also making investments in eastern Europe.

This was one sign of a new Vodafone in the making and several others followed in the various briefings from CEO Arun Sarin in the wake of the cellco’s Black Tuesday last week, when Vodafone suffered a 23% year-on-year fall in half-year profit and warnings of falling margins and increased competition.

One was, after years of dismissing WiMAX, the admission from Sarin that Vodafone was looking seriously into broadband wireless and ‘mobility based wireless DSL’. This could be as a parallel business alongside 3G deployments, or even a way to penetrate new territories in the absence of 3G licenses. Although Vodafone has some small scale broadband wireless trials ‘ of WiMAX at its German wireline unit Arcor, and of Flarion Flash-OFDM, now owned by Qualcomm, in Japan ‘ its most senior executives were arguing until very recently that WiMAX would gain only a marginal market, and mainly in the fixed broadband sector. Chief technology officer Thomas Geitner recently told a conference on next generation networks that, while Vodafone would ‘continue to screen new radio access technologies to determine future options’, he saw mobile WiMAX as no more spectrally efficient than HSDPA and further from standardization.

Now, Sarin is saying that Vodafone is looking to expand the broadband wireless market and ‘equally, we’re looking at new technologies that come along. Tomorrow it could be Wi-Fi, it could be mobile WiMAX. We’re quite agnostic.’

He added of 3G: ‘We’re completely convinced it’s the right platform for us. We’re comfortable 3G and HSDPA have a long life.’ Of course, with the levels of investment that Vodafone has made in spectrum and systems, it needs to believe this and convince shareholders of it too. As for other 3G carriers, its challenge will be to reduce operating costs and deal with a world with very different economics from those envisaged in the late 1990s ‘ with increased competition from broadband wireless, flat rate services such as VoIP and fixed-mobile convergence operators moving in from the wireline sector. Against this backdrop, it is still true that the 3G customer spends 15% more month on average, especially on data, but Vodafone also has to spend more on customer acquisition, handset subsidies are higher, and there is another year at least of high capex to finish the network, upgrade to HSDPA and improve indoor coverage. Also, it is not clear that, as 3G becomes mainstream, that 15% premium can be maintained in lower income groups, especially with competition from services such as wireless VoIP. Already, Vodafone Germany has defended itself against flat rate VoIP by introducing its own low cost, flat rate cellular services, but such moves will have a terrible effect on margins that were supposed to rise with the increased spectral efficiency of 3G compared to GSM.

This is the heart of the problem for Vodafone, and for most of its rivals, and all will have the same series of challenges ‘ addressing different markets and customer groups with different networks in order to maximize the overall ROI, rather than sticking religiously to one technology; penetrating high growth new territories to compensate for saturation in areas such as Europe; keeping a ferocious control on opex costs; and balancing the direct brand with the opportunities to exploit the network assets in other ways, such as MVNO deals.

For Vodafone, there are also specific challenges. One is its mobile-only status, once seen as its greatest advantage, now looking like a disadvantage in a world where operators want to offer uniform services across fixed and mobile, wired and wireless networks. This is where, in the medium term, broadband wireless could help by offering a fixed connection without the need to buy a wireline carrier ‘ especially if HSDPA’s indoor coverage does not improve as rapidly as its supporters hope.

Another is its massive global reach, and the fact that in some key territories it does not have control, as in the Verizon Wireless joint venture, which many investors want Vodafone to exit. Sarin takes the view that this activity generates growth and cash and that, eventually, the whole operation will fall into Vodafone’s hands. Japan is a far worse situation, and one that reflects, on an exaggerate scale, many of the dilemmas facing the world’s leading cellco.

The unit generates 20% of Vodafone’s revenues and so would not be lightly cast away despite its draining effect on margins and the company’s legendary cashflow. But while Sarin says the recovery plan is on track and just needs another 18 months or so to work, there will be three new 3G licenses awarded in Japan, while market leader NTT DoCoMo has stepped up its aggressive customer acquisition spend to take advantage of its rival’s problems. Vodafone, under its new Japanese chief Bill Morrow, is trying just about all the options to improve its fortunes, from trialling broadband wireless to trialling a new 1.7GHz frequency.

It is also turning to wholesaling, breaking its general resistance to leasing its network to MVNO partners (although it does have the Fusion partnership with BT in the UK). It has held talks with about 30 companies in Japan and, according to Morrow, is ‘feverishly in negotiations with quite a few’ potential MVNOs, with Sarin confident that Vodafone will host one of the three new Japanese 3G license holders. The aim is to sign up about 10 such deals within two years, with the eyes on the dramatic effect such moves had on Sprint Nextel’s fortunes in the US. The Japanese leaders, DoCoMo and KDDI, say they lack capacity on their networks to enter the MVNO sector so, like Sprint, Vodafone could have the market almost to itself.

Sarin believes that, despite the pressures on Vodafone, all he needs is time to adjust the company to new market conditions, to fix Japan and possibly gain full control of a US operation. He wants 18-24 months to achieve all this, and Vodafone has plenty of natural advantages that will help, notably its brand, its web of global alliances, and the fact that capex will peak in 2006-7 and then tail off, leaving a more efficient network and cheaper, simpler service deployment in its wake. But Vodafone, like many UK companies, is saddled with risk-averse and short term investors, and one of its greatest challenges will be convincing them to stay the course and trust in the very clear abilities of Sarin and his team. To achieve that, it may well need to exit Japan, and it will certainly need to reduce operating costs and deliver new services, so that the investment in 3G can be seen to be delivering results ‘ even as it looks likely that Vodafone will not remain wedded to just one technology for very much longer.

BOX

Vodafone reported that profit for the six months to the end of September dropped 23.5% year-on-year to £2.8bn ($4.8bn), down from £3.68bn in the same period last year. Revenues increased 9% year-on-year from £16.7bn to £18.25bn.

Other negatives were the probability that Vodafone will have to pay £5bn of £9bn in disputed tax liabilities and the regulatory squeeze on termination charges in several European countries. These generally overshadowed positives such as a further £2bn of buybacks on top of the £4.5bn already promised, and a 15% increase in dividends.

Revenues for Vodafone’s home market in the UK remained flat at £2.5bn for the six month period, as the market continued to be one of the operator’s most competitive arenas. ARPU decreased from £26.6 a year ago to £24.9, while the total number of subscribers reached 15.7m.

Vodafone Spain recorded the biggest increase in revenues, up 26.6% to £1.96bn, driven by the retention of high value customers and a successful summer campaign. ARPU at the Spanish operation increased 4.5% to €37 ($43.2).

Despite its problems, Japan reported an upturn, with revenues for the six-month period up 15.9% to £3.6bn, although ARPU dropped to Y5,983 ($50) from Y6,279 a year ago. The total number of subscribers was also down year-on-year, reaching 14.9m compared to 15.1m.

The total number of Vodafone Live! active devices surged from 11.1m to 35m while 3G devices topped the 4.9m mark. Non-voice services as a percentage of revenue increased from 17.7% at end-September last year to 18.8% at end-September 2005.