Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 July 2014

Vodafone/Liberty showdown drives M&A, now reaches Ireland

The wave of mergers between European operators continues apace, and will result in a larger number of MVNOs, and a rising investment in fixed lines by the mobile-led carriers.

Perhaps the most interesting of the recent developments, though not the largest, are seen in Ireland, where the battle of the giants between Vodafone and Liberty Global is playing out in miniature. These two pan-regional carriers are going head-to-head for the quad play ‘ Liberty with heavy investment in WiFi-first and MVNO deals; Vodafone acquiring fiber lines. In Ireland, the European Commission set conditions for approval of Hutchison Whampoa’s acquisition of O2 – while allowing the number of operators to be reduced from four to three, it insisted on more network access for MVNOs, and Liberty’s UPC subsidiary looks set to be a beneficiary.

Meanwhile ESB, the largest electricity supplier in Ireland, has signed up Vodafone in a joint venture to plow €450m into revolutionizing Irish broadband, offering speeds up to 1Gbps and mirroring Google’s activities in the US. This makes Ireland the first country in Europe to use existing electricity infrastructure on a nationwide basis to deploy fiber directly into homes ‘ though it has been done on a regional basis by Fastweb in Italy and some initiatives in the Nordics.

The new venture will reach 50 Irish towns and around 500,000 out of the 1.65m homes in the country. The new network will be 100% fiber to the building broadband and will offer speeds from 200 Mbps to 1000 Mbps, which is hoped to propel Ireland into the ranks of the world’s fastest broadband countries. ‘The fiber will be deployed on ESB’s existing overhead and underground infrastructure, ensuring roll-out to every county in Ireland and reversing the digital divide between the capital and regional towns. ‘

This is a crowded market though. Sky has over 600,000 homes subscribing to its satellite TV service and Liberty/UPC has another 458,000 for cable, so the pay-TV market is already 75% saturated. Success will rely on a triple or quad play of services.
Sky has already said that it plans to begin offering broadband and telephony in the country, and Liberty has around 348,000 broadband lines out of a total of just over 1m already installed, with the bulk of the remainder being held by incumbent Eircom. Vodafone has 200,000 fixed broadband customers in Ireland.
‘
The big problem in Ireland is that the ADSL broadband is slow with around 43% getting speeds below 10Mbps, claims ESB, and fiber is seen as the only way of shaking up market share. Eircom has committed to build out fiber too and said last quarter that it had now passed 800,000 homes and is on track to pass 1m by summer and 1.4m by 2016. And in the first quarter Eircom became one of the first operators in Europe to deploy ADSL vectoring, which should help it reach speeds up to 100Mbps.

The fiber build-out and Vodafone deal, therefore, represent ESB’s last chance to create a strong alternative to Eircom before the market is sewn up.
‘
Subject to European Commission approval, the 50:50 joint venture will begin rolling out the new network across Ireland in the coming months, with first customers at the start of 2015. The initial phase of the project is expected to complete by the end of 2018, with scope for a second phase if this goes well. ‘The partners said that they would offer open access to all telecoms operators in Ireland on a wholesale basis.

The EU conditions for the merger of O2 Ireland and 3 Ireland, in some ways, presaged those for the far larger merger of Germany’s Telefonica O2 and KPN/E-Plus cellcos. This has been approved almost a year after the €8.6bn deal was announced, but Telefonica had to make significant concessions before the regulator would countenance the removal of one player in the largest European mobile market, and the creation of a new market leader there.

To keep competition buoyant, the Spanish operator must sell up to 30% of the merged entity’s capacity to between one and three MVNOs, at fixed fees; and it must divest spectrum and other assets to a new MNO or MVNO too. It has also had to agree to extend both companies’ current wholesale arrangements and offer LTE MVNO services to other providers in future.

The ESB JV is just one way in which Vodafone is expanding its fixed line and quad play activities in order to increase ARPUs and market share in the European region, where mobile-only competition is fierce and user bases saturating. The UK-based giant has also won EU approval to buy Spanish cableco Ono for €7.2bn ($9.7bn); while Italian regulator Consob has approved Vodafone’s offer for telematics specialist Cobra, which will help it expand its connected car business.