Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 May 2006

Wi-Fi specialists seek differentiation from Cisco

Wi-Fi has promised to make a huge impact on the communications market, both by shifting the economics of outdoor, wide area voice and data services, and by unwiring the enterprise Lan. However, while it is starting to make its presence felt in both these areas, it has consistently been held back by a key problem ‘ that its performance and spectrum constraints make it difficult for either systems vendors or service providers to form an attractive business model. The vendors, after an initial rush of revenues from the eager uptake of access points and client devices, are now facing rapid commoditization and the growing power of Cisco/Linksys/Airespace. The service providers know they need to combine Wi-Fi with licensed spectrum radios, capable of delivering premium services; and to achieve an effective indoor/outdoor network, making the growing crowd of metrozones suitable for supporting business and residential broadband, not just best effort access to roaming visitors, and so more competitive with cellular offerings. This month has seen the WLan specialist vendors, conscious that they must differentiate in these areas or die, making strong moves to plug Wi-Fi’s gaps. Symbol and Meru are adding twists to their enterprise systems while the outdoor mesh vendors are improving their methods of getting indoors.

Symbol:

Symbol, second placed in the enterprise WLan market, is one of the vendors facing the gravest challenges in the wireless world. With its long established core business in barcode scanning, which gives it strong presence in retail, manufacturing and other non-office environments, it has struggled to move into the enterprise sector with its WLan products, yet remains too large and complex a player to be snapped up easily as most of the smarter Wi-Fi start-ups will be in the coming two years. To makes things worse, it has battled with a string of accounting scandals and management changes, and last fall Cisco muscled in on its natural extension market, RFID smart tags.

Its responses have been creative even it if its refocusing of its sales and distribution structures have been slower than hoped to take effect ‘ they were kicked off by well respected ex-Cisco CEO Bill Nuti, who largely pulled the company out of its financial mire and a string of patent disputes, but he departed last summer. The company is attempting some Cisco-style expansion of its range to embrace software and provide end-to-end facilities. In 2004, it announced its Mobility Services Suite (MSS) to monitor corporate WLans and mobile devices and provide detailed information to the network manager.

Its latest attempt to increase its margins and differentiation, and so offer an alternative to Cisco, is to build on its strengths in RFID and embrace the trend towards multiple radios. As in the outdoor world, the enterprise sector is also increasingly aware that future performance and cutting edge applications will require the strengths of different networks, and that advances in chip and software technology will make the combining of various technologies cost-effectively more practical. Symbol’s Wi-NG (Wireless Next Generation) platform centers on a set of switches that will consolidate Wi-Fi, RFID, mesh points, and potentially most other mainstream radios, including WiMAX, HSDPA and CDMA EV-DO. The aim is to promise enterprises that start off with a WLan switch the potential to expand their systems to new technologies in future, without ripping out the initial investment.

The first product in the Wi-NG series will be the WS5100 Wireless Switch. It will be enabled with Layer 3 roaming and the ability to adopt RFID readers. The switch can be coupled with the AP-5131 mesh access point that Symbol announced last year, although the mesh can also be deployed without a switch control. As in its software strategy, Symbol is looking for strategic partners to enrich its platform, with the first one for Wi-NG being security specialist AirDefense.

Clearly, the medium term opportunity is in the enterprise shift to fixed-mobile convergence (FMC), and Symbol has announced a handset, the MC70 , that supports GSM and 802.11, plus a partnership with start-up enterprise FMC player Divitas, which is also working with Nokia, Meru and Trapeze.

Meru:

Meru has been relying on its claims to superior quality of service, particularly for wireless VoIP, to penetrate the enterprise market and it has consistently announced new features for its switch range ahead of its rivals. Last year it debuted a ‘single channel WLan’ with Extricom, claiming advanced QoS and performance, and now it is unveiling a wireless backbone, which bonds multiple channels together to create a 100Mbps backhaul link from access points to switches, removing another layer of wired connection for greater flexibility and integration.

Meru is not unique with this idea ‘ Xirrus has also announced a bonded backhaul option which is available as a software upgrade for its Integrated Access Point. This bonds three radios together for links up to 162Mbps (though in practise these are likely to be closer to 80Mbps).

Meru claims a full duplex link with its trademark QoS, and this differentiates it from another wireless backhaul approach gaining some ground, mesh. It has adopted a ‘blanket’ architecture, in which the APs all use the same WLan channel or channels, leaving others free for backhaul or a specific application like VoIP. By contrast, Xirrus uses a sectorized architecture in which one AP contains up to 16 radios, which use directional antennas to reach a section of the building and avoid interfering with one another.

Meru’s bonded Wi-Fi option, AirChannel, is similar to EtherChannel, which bonded multiple Fast Ethernet links to create higher capacity connections before Gigabit Ethernet became available. In the same way, Meru claims AirChannel is a migration step towards the fast Wi-Fi standard, 802.11n.

Mesh comes indoors:

The Wi-Fi mesh vendors have eyed enterprise backhaul as a possible application for their networks, and are also keen to improve the capabilities of their outdoor metrozones to deliver indoor access. FireTide and Tropos, both of which plan to incorporate WiMAX and other radios from next year, are also announcing mechanisms to improve this facility using Wi-Fi.

Tropos has developed a specification for third party devices to boost indoor performance.
“What we’ve done is taken all our learning in deployments and put together requirements you can think of as best practises for client devices to operate in a metro scale Wi-Fi network,” said head of business development Chris Rittler. The specs, called Tropos Metro Compatible Extensions (TMCX), are designed to work with any metro network, not just a Tropos one, but of course the performance is superior when used with the Tropos MetroMesh architecture. This shows smaller players emulating the Cisco approach of creating extensions to draw partners to support a vendor’s product set, by guaranteeing compatibility and better performance or security ‘ although lacking Cisco’s market power, Tropos has taken a somewhat more open tack. The TMCX extensions address RF performance, security, QoS and network management, including the mandating of certain standards such as 802.11i, and are aimed particularly at indoor/outdoor operations.

The first company to issue a product using TMCX is Hong Kong-based PePLink, which makes CPE for small offices. Tropos will sell this to its customers. Also promising TMCX support is Ruckus Wireless, specialist in indoor multimedia networks.

Meanwhile FireTide has introduced a new line of HotPoint mesh access points with models for both outdoors and indoors, to allow its HotPort meshes to bridge the two environments. Both feature the same suite of Wi-Fi features such as WPA2 security, multiple SSIDs and QoS, through a new release of the company’s HotView management software, moving to version 3.3.