Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 March 2006

WiMAX accelerates shift of telecoms equipment towards PC model

Whatever the precise fortunes of the WiMAX platforms in the years ahead, the IEEE standards have introduced a fundamental shift of thinking to the wireless infrastructure world, which can be simplified as the application of the PC business model to telecoms. This has been most obvious at the consumer end, with Wi-Fi, for all its limitations, condemning the cellular operators to work forever with flat rate, true broadband, fully open connections on a phone, largely unfettered by garden walls. But in terms of telco economics, the PC approach is just as important on the infrastructure side. WiMAX has accelerated the trend towards using open components and interfaces in the base stations and other network elements, so that hardware becomes, like the PC, largely a collection of off-the-shelf, low cost technologies, and the differentiation comes from two key areas ‘ high level software to support rich services, and support for flexible operator models, including multiple radios.

A clear example of the trend is the ATCA (Advanced Telecommunications Computing Architecture) standard, which enables off-the-shelf components to be used in the backplane to boost the performance of the telco server at affordable cost. Heavily backed by Intel and Alcatel, ATCA is also supported by makers of communications servers, such as Motorola and Sun, and most recently Nortel, while IBM is working with Motorola’s Avantellis server architecture. ATCA, which has emerged from the world of the PCI computer bus, provides a standardized chassis and blade server architecture that supports very high rates ‘ 2.4 terabits per second on the backplane ‘ for next generation multimedia applications. It holds out the promise for infrastructure vendors of upgrading the chassis using commoditized components and mass market silicon, greatly reducing their costs as they come under heavy pressure from operators to provide platforms with lower associated capex and opex. In essence, this brings the enterprise server model associated with Intel into the world of rarefied telecoms servers.

Another key development in applying PC economics to telecoms has been the OBSAI initiative to create standard interfaces within base stations, to enable vendors to reduce R&D spend by offering a single set of specifications that can be applied to many current and future radios and base station designs. For instance, multiple networks ‘ W-CDMA, CDMA2000 and WiMAX, and potentially the next 3G iteration, LTE ‘ can be supported with common interfaces, as can various base station concepts including the distributed approach favored by Siemens.

OBSAI chair Tero Mustala (of Nokia) commented: “A chief benefit of the OBSAI open interface specifications is that they have been devised to go beyond existing technologies so that they are virtually future proof. We expect to have WiMAX fully integrated into the full range of OBSAI specifications, by the first half of this year.”

OBSAI’s head of technology, Dr Peter Kenington of Andrew, said that WiMAX vendors ‘ which now account for over one-third of the organization’s 130-plus members ‘ have been an important driver because they have no legacy designs to support and welcome reusable technologies that will enable them to get their products to market quickly post-standardization. ‘Our highest profile this year will be in WiMAX. The specifications that I have seen from WiMAX companies have exclusively supported OBSAI interfaces.’

As in the PC world, the use of standards will draw large components makers into the sector, even to support relatively specialized products such as high power radio heads, since they can sell across the range of smaller OEMs, rather than designing from scratch for each proprietary architecture. This in turn will lower component prices rapidly, which will be essential to the equipment makers as they come under increasing pressure from operators to lower prices and develop products more quickly.

A standards base also reduces the risk in a base station maker supporting a particular design concept. This is seen in the Nokia Flexi Base Station, the first commercially available product to support OBSAI, and in Siemens’ recently announced distributed base station architecture.

The Flexi Base Station is a compact design, that can be installed indoors or outdoors, and claims to reduce installation and maintenance costs by up to 70%. It currently supports W-CDMA in the 2.1GHz, 1.7GHz, 1.8GHz and 1.7/2.1GHz frequencies and next year other frequencies will be added such as 1.9GHz, 850MHz and 900MHz. But its clear roadmap is towards multiple radios, which can be slotted in and out of the OBSAI system of interfaces, with the potential to include WiMAX and W-CDMA, for instance, in one cabinet.

“We believe that this open, modular base station offers all our customers a new and easier way to build 3G networks, now and in the future,” said Robin Lindahl, vice president of radio networks at Nokia. “The small size and flexibility of the Nokia Flexi WCDMA Base Station will make a real difference to our customers’ operating and capital expenditure since existing and new sites can be used in a very efficient way. In addition, this new platform will make it easy for operators to deploy new radio technologies.”

Over at Siemens, the company is a cheerleader for distributed base stations, an architecture that can also be supported by Nokia Flexi. Siemens recently unveiled a 3G product family that will allow operators to install radio components at separate locations, enabling them to build new 3G networks without having to redesign existing GSM networks.

Traditionally, radio components have been integrated into the base station and connected to the antenna by cable. Siemens has broken that model by separating radio head from server with its Pico Remote Radio Head for indoor coverage; Macro Remote Radio Head for outdoor coverage; and radio servers for controlling radio equipment. Under the new distributed approach, while the radio head and antenna are installed as usual on a roof or a transmission tower, the server can be located in a basement, for example, where the site and installation costs are much lower. Granswindt estimated this could reduce site rental cost by as much as 70%, physical deployment by 65% and power consumption by 50%. The distance between the radio head and the server, connected via fiber or copper wire, can be up to 50 kilometers, and one server can serve up to 12 radio heads, reducing the cost of network deployment.

Kenington explained that the flexibility of the OBSAI architecture meant that it could devise a version of its critical RP3 interface for remote radio heads ‘ the key is that a standards platform should be agnostic to whether the market does, indeed, move heavily towards this design, or stays with in-cabinet base stations.

The introduction of off-the-shelf components and open interfaces to the base station and core architectures is undoubtedly being accelerated by the WiMAX community, with its need to develop technology quickly and cheaply, and the huge influence of Intel on its approach. This in turn will set new benchmarks for cost of development and cost of ownership of base stations across all the wireless technologies as they each seek a powerful place in the next generation of networks, one where low costs and openness in the hardware will shift the differentiation to applications and middleware.

Motorola’s MicroTCA

While Intel, along with its close ally Alcatel, has been the strongest cheerleader for ATCA, Motorola aims to take the leading position with a related standard, MicroTCA. As always, there is a strong whiff of vendor politics between Intel and Motorola, which have very different agendas for the next generation network market. While Intel is pushing PCIExpress as the switching fabric for ATCA, Motorola is supporting Ethernet and is aiming to steal a march on the chip giant in MicroTCA, an implementation for smaller telco systems, which should be Intel’s natural home.

So while promising full support for the key standards involved in a Communications Server ‘ ATCA, SA Forum and also Carrier Grade Linux, the most usual operating system for telco servers ‘ Motorola claims to have set two standards directions of its own with the MicroTCA form factor and the use of Ethernet in ATCA (other contenders to be the primary fabric include Infiniband, and arguments over this aspect of the technology have been a major stumbling block to uptake so far.) Motorola is convinced that affordable high availability telco servers will only emerge quickly if the industry focuses on one architecture ‘ and of course, aims to dictate the elements itself.

Therefore it has taken a firm lead on MicroTCA. This is a cutdown version of ATCA, supporting smaller equipment at the edge of the network, such as WiMAX base stations, which be included in the superfast converged architecture, but at a cost level appropriate to these smaller systems. The target price for a MicroTCA baseline box, once equipment hits volume, is just $500, and a product incorporating this can be managed by the same system as ATCA.

‘We see MicroTCA being used in telecom edge applications where small physical size and low entry cost are key requirements, such as WiMAX access points, DSLAMs and VoIP access gateways,’ said Motorola’s Shlomo Pri-Tal, CTO of the embedded group.