There is already controversy surrounding the more important UK auction due this year, in the 2.6GHz band. WiMAX supporters are claiming they may be effectively excluded from the running because the five cellcos may be planning to bid even for the TDD portion of the spectrum, even though this is the area most suited to WiMAX. Richard Robb, finance director at WiMAX start-up Urban WiMAX ‘ which runs services in London, but is forced to use license-exempt bands ‘ told Unstrung that ‘there is considerable risk [of spectrum hoarding] because they have the competing technology with LTE. It could be economical for them to buy it and sanitize it – that is, buy it and not use it.” Ofcom has not attached any build-out obligations to the licenses, as is now common in the US and some other European countries.
Of course, such fears ignore the fact that both WiMAX and LTE have a roadmap to span both TDD and FDD spectrum, as both look increasingly similar and aim to support the whole range of an operator’s commercial requirements. Although 90% of current spectrum in use for mobile services is FDD in nature, because this is the most suitable technique for voice, the balance with TDD ‘ unpaired, and optimal for IP and data ‘ will shift significantly with the new allocations of spectrum in 2.6GHz and elsewhere, as operators look to shift their business models heavily towards data, VoIP and all-IP. So in many European countries, regulators are already increasing the amount of the 2.5GHz-2.7GHz band they plan to allocate for TDD usage ‘ or, like Ofcom, will leave this largely to the market.
In the light of this trend, the traditional cellular community is taking new interest in TDD technologies and Ericsson has spearheaded the development of LTE for both FDD and TDD, with the latter variant largely based on work done in China, where 3G and 4G standards are TDD-based. Meanwhile, Vodafone has led the operator call for WiMAX to converge with LTE, probably by providing its TDD element, though this is unlikely, for technical, commercial and political reasons, to happen until a future generation of the standards. WiMAX will be reluctant to let go of its headstart advantage in TDD just yet, and is now ramping up its efforts to create its FDD profile of 802.16e in 2.3GHz-2.6GHz.
Thus the five UK cellcos may well win the prizes in the Ofcom auction, since their deep pockets ‘ and those of BT ‘ should be easily able to outbid would-be disruptive forces such as a potential alliance of smaller WiMAX players, or a wholesaler like Arqiva that would support a multitude of smaller providers. Some WiMAX specialists are testing the viability of banding together to buy licenses, perhaps on a regional basis. Nortel and Alvarion are supporting a WiMAX showcase by independents including Urban WiMAX, which is currently running demonstrations in Kent in south west England.
But given the cellco’s need to deliver 4G services and network efficiencies in order to improve their data business models, they are unlikely to hoard the spectrum for long.
“The way we’ve designed the spectrum award is to promote competition,” an Ofcom spokesperson told the reporter. “There are no use it or lose it conditions and no roll-out obligations because we’re not stipulating what the spectrum should be used for.”
The only countries to beat the UK to the 2.6GHz post will be Norway, which has awarded licenses to the tune of $43m, and Sweden, whose auction is seven days into the process, amassing bids worth $195m so far. So the UK will be closely watched in many respects, including the applications and TDD/FDD divide that operator finally favor, and whether new rules like spectrum trading impact the result, for instance by encouraging speculators.