Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 May 2007

WiMAX World: Motorola questions WiMAX backhaul

Backhaul or middle mile applications were traditionally seen as a mundane but safe market for WiMAX gear, and the niche into which equipment based on the fixed 802.16d standard might retreat once 802.16e was under way. But despite the heritage of the 802.16 standard in the backhaul market, the bulk of the development funds in recent years have gone on access, and now Motorola has publicly voiced the doubts of many about the technology’s future in this area.

The company’s US head of WiMAX business, Thomas Mioraj, recently told an audience at the Interop show that WiMAX was not well suited to single high throughput applications such as backhaul, and at WiMAX World Europe, the company’s focus was more heavily on non-802.16 products in its canopy range for backhaul. Mioraj said the company had learned a lot about backhaul in the municipal mesh market, and “what we found is that backhaul is very tough. WiMAX is unsuitable as a backhaul solution.”

Motorola’s interest is partly to boost the specialized backhaul and point-to-point technology it acquired with Orthogon Systems, now part of the Canopy family and seen as a strong fit with WiMAX access systems. Other WiMAX vendors that are associated with backhaul strength, such as Redline, also look to cross-sell with access systems, but retain proprietary offerings at the back. This is particularly the case since the WiMAX community defocused so rapidly on 802.16d and on a 5.8GHz license-exempt profile – the aspects of the Forum’s early work that were most relevant to backhaul.

Of course, build-out of new networks such as WiMAX and Wi-Fi mesh is stimulating the demand for backhaul of all kinds, while the cost of leased lines is driving much of this demand towards wireless. In particular, the need in some markets to implement WiMAX in relatively high frequencies such as 3.5GHz is leading to very dense networks being planned, with consequently heightened requirements for backhaul capacity and flexibility. This is a major opportunity for the early movers into all-IP wireless backhaul, such as Canada’s Dragonwave, whose major customer is Clearwire, and which recently floated on London’s AIM exchange with a view to expanding internationally. Dragonwave perceives its main direct competitor to be Israel’s Ceragon, which after years of uncertainty has been performing strongly in recent times, and which last week announced a contract with fixed wireless provider NextLink, a subsidiary of XO.

But despite the vendors’ belief that a specialized technology is needed for wireless backhaul, some operators are still looking to use 802.16 in this way. Sprint Nextel has often said it will look to use WiMAX to replace up to 20% of its T1 lines – though it may now look to other wireless options too – and AT&T, at least before it was subsumed into the local carriers, was a major exponent of using WiMAX for enterprise use, claiming it had sufficient capacity and range to replace leased lines in 90% of cases.