Undoubtedly the key theme of the device world this year will be the ‘post-PC’ form factors that gain a long term mass market ‘ and which are remembered in future years as fads. It is now clear that the traditional desktop and notebook PC is entering its death spiral, which will be slow but has certainly begun. And for the first time, the PC vendors which have lived firmly under the Wintel rules have the chance to choose between different chips and operating systems, and to play the majors off against one another. Nothing demonstrates this new balance of power better than Acer, which has made no secret of its anger with Microsoft for launching its own tablet, and is now talking up Google Chrome at the expense of Windows 8.
This highlights that there are several broad formats picking at the PC corpse. The first set of these vultures aims to preserve as many of the norms of the PC experience and supply chain as possible, notably superslim laptops like Intel Ultrabook and Apple MacBook Air; and tablets running Windows 8 Pro. These products will increasingly sport some features of the smartphone world such as touchscreens, but will still be running on Intel chips, while many will still have Microsoft OSs. Other would-be PC replacements come from the handset world and include ARM-based tablets of various sizes. This group has a common underlying chip architecture and more homogeneous in physical appearance and interface (fewer hybrids and Frankenstein machines in the world of monolithic slates). But it is more fragmented in terms of OS, with iOS, Android, Windows RT, BB10 and potentially other Linux-based platforms playing a role.
And then there is the Chromebook, the only major representative of a nascent ‘cloudbook’ category. This is an odd one out not just because it fully endorses the idea of a thin client ‘ with nearly all files and content accessed over the air from the cloud, and consumed in the browser ‘ but also because it takes elements from both the other camps. Early Chromebooks are netbook-like in appearance and most have come from traditional PC vendors, but they run an OS from Google and, commonly, chips from Intel. Given Acer’s new enthusiasm for this slow-burning device type, Intel would do well to pay more attention to it, and deepen its existing alliance with Google for Android. It could compensate for Microsoft’s defection to ARM with its RT platform by fully supporting the Chromebook, and ensure it keeps ARM at bay in a future post-PC category which taps into many of its traditional partnerships.
Acer’s sudden enthusiasm for Chromebooks is not just related to sour grapes over Surface. It reminds us that, along with Asustek, it was the chief beneficiary of the netbook boom. The netbook’s flame burned brightly for a couple of years, and the low power, mobile laptop had an importance beyond its shortlived sales burst. It established many consumer expectations about portability and battery life for a PC-shaped device; and it helped vendors adapt their component purchasing and user interface to fit very low price points. These are useful lessons for the new device categories, such as ultrabooks (superslim but with far greater processing power than a netbook) and the netbooks’ true heir, the cloudbook/Chromebook. This is the latest in a continuum that stretches back to the ‘network computer’ conceived by Sun and Oracle in 1995, setting out a thin client idea, now taken up by Google, where almost all the data and processing takes place on a remote server (then company mainframes, with network computers synched over physical links; now the cloud and ubiquitous wireless connectivity).
According to Acer president Jim Wong, Chromebooks accounted for between 5% and 10% of its US shipments since it launched the models in that market in November. He thinks that ratio will be sustainable and the company is considering launching Chrome products in other developed markets.
By contrast, Wong said: ‘Windows 8 itself is still not successful.’ This is somewhat premature, given that Windows RT models are new to the market and Windows 8 Pro has not appeared on the shelves yet. And he seems to be expected W8 to reverse the downward spiral of the whole PC industry, telling Bloomberg: ‘The whole market didn’t come back to growth after the Windows 8 launch. That’s a simple way to judge if it is successful or not.’
Clearly W8 has not had time to reignite the PC space, and anyway, it is unrealistic to believe it will do so, if the PC is defined in conventional ways. There will be some fillip from the enterprise and from W7 upgrades, of course, but the real challenge Microsoft has set its dual-stranded new OS is to take its platform into new form factors – hence the launch of the Surface tablet to convince buyers that the Redmond giant has successfully adapted its OS and UI for a new type of product at the first attempt, something that took it a decade on the cellphone. But that means going up against an entrenched frontrunner, the iPad, plus various Android players, rather than sticking to the comfort zone of the PC, where perhaps Acer wishfully thinks it could stay.
While Windows in total still makes up 92% of the global PC market (the rest belonging to Apple and Linux), that space will slowly shrink, and as of the end of 2012, W8 – released in October – accounted for 1.7% of computers in use.
It does seem that W8 will have a slower start than its predecessor because of OEM confusion over the two strands and over Surface, and the general malaise in the PC space. More radical designs are needed, offering something clearly different to a PC or an iPad. Apple, by adding a 128Gbytes option to its tablet range, has helped remove one of the attractions of the Surface, for instance ‘ Microsoft needs to be setting new rules of engagement rather than setting itself up to be easily outmanoeuvered by its rivals in this way. The Windows giant itself has blamed its PC partners for the downbeat performance of its new OS in the holiday season, saying they did not come up with sufficiently attractive and differentiated designs to catch customers’ eyes.
This month, Microsoft announced sales of 8m W8 licences, but of course many will have been to OEMs for products not yet sold. It is thought to have sold about one million Surface tablets, about half of what was expected.
One of the reasons for slow burn in W8 is the caution of traditional OEMs about the RT flavor, because of Surface and because it forces them to move to new form factors. Acer is still evaluating RT and will not launch a product until late summer at the earliest, while Samsung cancelled the launch of its own offering in the US. This helps to explain the new enthusiasm for Chrome OS, which Wong claims has limited share, but takes most of its users from high value categories ‘ professional, heavy internet users; enterprises; and colleges. ‘You saw that all the marketing and promotions were not as broad as Windows 8, so to reach this success is encouraging,’ Wong said. Of course, starting at $199, Chromebooks are an easy purchase, down there with smaller Android tablets, so it is hardly fair to place them in the same category as W8 products ‘ nor will they generate the same margins for OEMs. But W8 will have to take account of the sub-$200 price points too, and in this age when consumers are accustomed to getting massive performance for a few hundred dollars ‘ courtesy of the smartphone ‘ that will be the biggest transition of all for Microsoft and its PC partners.
It will also finally achieve what Sun CEO Scott McNealy glimpsed when he pushed his network computer idea onto Oracle chief Larry Ellison. A while back, Computerworld reporter Don Tennant remembered a conversation he had with Ellison in 1997, when the Oracle leader recalled discussing low cost computers with then-President Clinton, as well as McNealy and Apple’s Michael Spindler. Ellison said: “I asked the President to challenge our industry to build a computer that’s inexpensive enough to put on the desks of all children. And we just picked a number – $500 seemed like a magic threshold. And Scott McNealy said, ‘The heck with $500, how about $200?’ Shut up, Scott.”