Two weeks Palmsource, owner of the Palm operating system, drove another nail into the coffin of the platform when it sold out to Japan’s Access and signalled a total shift towards Linux. Now Palm itself, the hardware arm of the formerly united company, has made the expected move of announcing its first non-PalmOS unit, with the release of a version of its Treo smartphone running Microsoft Windows Mobile 5.0.
The demise of the Palm platform, which once dominated the PDA market and is still the leader in that niche, was inevitable once the phonemakers entered the game, creating the smartphone, which has a far broader reach in terms of applications and target base than the traditional PDA. Palm went from being a whale in a small pond to a minnow in a large one, especially as the new importance of the phone as an enterprise client device spurred Microsoft ‘ whose cutdown version of Windows was the only other major PDA OS ‘ into new aggressiveness, targeting Windows Mobile at the phone market and signing new partners in the PDA space.
Palm’s shift to Windows is likely gradually to seep through the whole range and leave PalmOS dead, apart from the preservation of its well liked user interface in the Access/Palmsource project to apply these upper layers to Linux. The decisions by both Palm branches are interesting to the market at large more for their potential impact on Microsoft than for their contribution to the decline of a platform that was already on the way out. Converting the Palm range to Windows will certainly help Microsoft keep hold of the main market where Windows Mobile has succeeded, the enterprise PDA/smartphone. But a Linux strengthened by the addition of something it has always lacked in the mobile world, a decent interface and browser, could be a threat to that success, as well as helping to keep Windows out of the lower cost cellphone market.
The Windows-based Treo will ship early next year, initially on Verizon Wireless’ EV-DO network, and was considered significant enough for Microsoft to field chairman Bill Gates at the launch. He focused heavily on Palm’s strengths in mobile email, the key application on which most mobile enterprise strategies are initially built, and where most smartphone makers are now gunning for the well established RIM BlackBerry. Microsoft has recently shown signs of relaxing its stance that all devices in the mobile world, as in the PC era, should run Windows and focusing instead on its .Net web services framework and its ability to be the key middleware for a mobile corporation, even supporting multiple devices such as BlackBerry or Nokia/Symbian phones.
However, while it would do well to open up its platforms to non-Windows clients, to keep control even in a world where there will certainly be multiple client OSs, Microsoft also needs to push its technologies into sites that have chosen a different middleware route, notably IBM’s WebSphere. Here, it will be important to Microsoft to keep Windows devices in the mix, to prevent entirely Windows-free organizations emerging. Not only does the snaring of Palm promise to eliminate a declining but still well installed competitor, but it could insinuate Windows into the important joint development and marketing deal that Palm formed two years ago with IBM to integrate its handhelds with WebSphere.
However, that deal was heavily focused on Java, and highlights the always interesting issue of whether Microsoft, if it aims to keep Windows near-universal on the client end, will have to support Java far more actively to keep its software competitive in a mobile environment that increasingly revolves around the Sun-owned framework.
Deals like Palm’s do indicate the improvements that Microsoft has made to Windows Mobile with release 5.0, which was announced earlier this year. It is starting to look more like a real smartphone OS, with support for features such as miniature hard drives and push to talk. It no longer looks like a miniature version of grown-up Windows, with Microsoft finally realizing that this was never a selling point in the mobile world. Uniform tools that can be leveraged by the vast developer community across multiple platforms are a great advantage for Windows, and one that only Java echoes; uniform look and feel between a desktop PC and a cellphone is not. So now, release 5.0 goes further than previous versions in reflecting how mobile users really behave, for instance with easier and faster access to address books and calendar.
It is still clumsy and over-large compared to real cellphone operating systems, but for a mobile enterprise device it is far more attractive than it used to be and could attract further licensees geared to this market. In the meantime, the Palm platforms will soon be a thing of the past, and with Microsoft and Nokia both determined to take their place, RIM could be the next to fade away.
Also looking to mobile enterprise applications to boost its fortunes is SCO, the Unix company that is still embroiled in lawsuits claiming patent rights in key aspects of Unix and Linux. While those actions drag on, SCO seems to be hunting a new revenue stream that is free from associations with the long running patents debate. It has launched a mobile product for distributing communications to workgroups, which is notable for a strong branding that virtually excludes the SCO name and logo.
The service, called Me Inc, lets handheld devices ‘ initially Palm Treos but later Windows Mobile, SymbianOS and BlackBerry products – distribute voice and text messages to groups and individuals, as well as record and display real time research data.
The subscription software is targeted at the medium to large enterprise and allows people not only to share messages with groups of any size but to plan projects, delegate tasks and track the progress of work.
Also strengthening the bid of the old Wintel alliance to maintain its grip on the enterprise client device, even as this goes mobile, is a deal between Intel and RIM. The BlackBerry maker will use the chip giant’s Hermon 3G chipset in future models, claiming it will improve battery life.
Recent research figures from Gartner Group estimate that RIM shipped 840,000 Blackberrys in the second quarter of 2005, an increase of nearly 65% over the 510,000 units shipped in the second quarter of 2004 and making it leader of the PDA/hybrid market with 23%. It is followed by Palm on 18% and Hewlett-Packard on 12.5%. About 46% of PDAs ship with Windows Mobile, a figure that will increase as Palm adopts the Microsoft OS in more models.