Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 November 2007

WRC: Resolution, despite compromises, on UHF, WiMAX and satellite

Every four years, the World Radiocommunications Conference (WRC) is convened in Geneva by the International Telecommunications Union (ITU) and seeks to set global policy for a harmonized approach to radio spectrum. Inevitably this results in compromise solutions and aggrieved interest groups, and some of the guidelines set out will be twisted or ignored in the often lengthy process of implementation by more local authorities. But the WRC still has massive impact on the market and in many parts of the spectrum has, against all odds, succeeded in accelerating the shift towards globally unified policies on certain bands and technologies, which in turn drives the availability of low cost, high bandwidth wireless services. The 2007 event, recently concluded, was no exception to any of the above, but among its many topics, it is likely to go down in history for its decisions, compromises as they were, on global wireless adoption in UHF frequencies, as well as policies for WiMAX and satellite bands.

In the wake of the recent ITU decision to put WiMAX on the list of approved technologies for use in IMT-2000 networks (3G and beyond), the WRC has now agreed that two key WiMAX bands ‘ the 2.3GHz-2.4GHz WiMAX/WiBro spectrum and 3.4GHz-3.6GHz ‘ will be designated as IMT radio frequency bands. This increases the flexibility for operators to implement 3G and 3G-plus networks using a variety of technologies, including WiMAX, UMTS and CDMA2000, in a wider selection of RF bands than previously permitted.

However, there is to be less freedom of movement for wireless operators in the satellite C-band in 3.4GHz-4.2GHz (a typical C-band satellite uses 3.7GHz’4.2GHz for downlink, and 5.925GHz’6.425GHz for uplink, though there are variations in various parts of the world, and the ‘super-extended band’ reaches down to 3.4GHz). The WRC guaranteed uninterrupted use of the band to the satellite operators and gave assurances that any future IMT networks will provide them with full protection from interference, restricting the chances for 3.5GHz WiMAX in some key areas of the world, notably Asia.

Despite pressure to open up the C-band for a wider variety of users, the WRC decided against doing this on a global basis ‘ which would have provided a huge opportunity for radio technologies like WiMAX – pointing to a major geographical split in how mobile broadband will be deployed, which means that satellite providers will require more spectrum and greater protection in some markets. Instead, the status quo was maintained, although a limited number of countries in favor of change will be ‘identified’ in an opt-in footnote. As well as stepping back from global harmonization, the WRC also further cramped radio’s freedom of action by insisting on stringent requirements for anti-interference, including cross-border protection.

This ruling was, predictably, heartily welcomed by the satellite broadcast and services sector. “This outcome represents a strong endorsement by a large number of administrations of the critical nature and value of C-band satellite services as they exist today,” said Rob Bednarek, CEO of SES New Skies, in a statement.

In Region 2 (the Americas and the Caribbean), 14 countries have their mobile service allocation in 3.4GHz-3.5 GHz upgraded to allow IMT operations, under the anti-interference conditions. In Region 3, (most of Asia), only eight countries inserted their name to the footnote identifying IMT. In Region 1, which covers Africa and Europe, there was broad support for inclusion in the footnote identifying IMT for national usage in the 3.5GHz band.

In addition to this compromise, which could have significant impact on WiMAX adoption in various regions in its key 3.5GHz band, the WRC also adopted a halfway solution in the even more vexed issue of reallocating terrestrial TV spectrum in the UHF band (in most countries, various frequencies between 400MHz and 800MHz). UHF spectrum is being eyed by mobile broadband providers for its propagation qualities, which make it ideal to address sparsely populated markets at relatively low capex and opex cost, a factor that has been thrown into sharp relief by the intense interest in one of the first planned auctions of analog TV spectrum, the US 700MHz sell-off scheduled for January 2008.

The issues of whether, when and how to transfer UHF TV bandwidth to wireless operators have been fraught, but the WRC finally reached a compromise proposal last Wednesday after a 20-hour plenary session. US officials had lobbied hard for a single global agreement on spectrum use, based on its own rulings, which would drive the emergence of low cost universal devices and international roaming. However, Europe and Africa were not prepared to go as far as the Americas and Asia-Pacific and these regions decided to limit the amount of bandwidth available for mobile services to half of what will be offered in other regions, a move seen as a concession to their national broadcasting companies. The ITU finally adopted a proposal led by African governments to identify a swathe of UHF spectrum for the provision of mobile broadband services in developing countries and rural areas, and Europe and the Middle East, together with parts of Asia, supported the identification of the same 790-862MHz band for this purpose, while the Americas and much of Asia (notably China and India) identified a wider 108MHz (698-862MHz) of UHF spectrum. Much of this UHF spectrum will be reserved for mobile broadband services, while a chunk of spectrum in the higher bands – 3.4GHz -3.6GHz, currently key to WiMAX – will create capacity for the next generation of advanced mobile services, likely to be ‘4G’

The European Commission has been focusing on opening up the current GSM bands to advanced services, partly to compensate for making concessions to broadcasters over the deadlines for transitioning out of UHF bands. Most European countries will do this later than the US deadline of 2009, but before the Asian average of 2015, though some are pushing transition out as far as 2014 themselves. Last week, against the backdrop of the WRC, European TV broadcasters slammed even the watered-down EC proposal to open UHF frequencies to mobile operators, claiming consumers would experience disruption to digital television services.

For all this, and despite disappointments at some of the compromises, this year’s WRC has set some important precedents and and managed to win consensus on key issues, all of which can only help stimulate new services in developed countries and the spread of wireless broadband in all regions to bridge the digital divide.

L-band rulings in the US:

The FCC has agreed to divide the L-band spectrum for mobile satellite services (MSS) between CDMA operator Globalstar and TDMA operator Iridium, and it will also seek public comment on a proposal to give Globalstar the ability to offer ATC ‘ the hybrid satellite/terrestrial wireless technology that many MSS operators see as key to future growth – on most of its MSS frequencies. To date, only three providers can implement ATC capabilities ‘ MSV, Terrestar and Craig McCaw’s ICO, all in 2GHz spectrum.

Now, the FCC has given Globalstar and Iridium each exclusive MSS use of 7.775MHz of spectrum in the L-band (1.6GHz) and could allow Globalstar to incorporate ATC in more than 19MHz of the 27.85MHz of spectrum it controls in the L-band and S-band (2.4-2.5GHz).

Sprint and the WiMAX Foru have been among the parties opposing Globalstar’s request that the FCC remove a ban on its using ATC, because of their own interest in the 2.5GHz band. The WiMAX players claim that allowing ATC, rather than satellite-only, in this spectrum range would cause interference with broadband wireless networks around 2.5GHz. Globalstar says these claims are false, and that it can only gain a level playing field if it is allowed to use ATC, as are its main mobile satellite rivals, which operate in the less restricted 2GHz band, and gained new spectrum allocations last year in order to build out ATC and stimulate new mobile satellite services. A victory for Globalstar would put it in a better position to make an alliance with a broadband wireless operator or vendor, in a world where combining satellite and terrestrial spectrum and business models will increasingly be a feature of the move to convergence.

Globalstar originally petitioned the FCC in June 2006 but was turned down on the basis that it might interfere with Iridium and terrestrial wireless networks, gaining ATC authority in only a small portion of its frequencies, a portion that would more than double under the current proposal. ‘We are extremely pleased with the FCC’s proposal to increase our ATC authority, which would provide Globalstar with the ability to continue its leadership role in the development of innovative products and services and to work with others to develop a broader range of seamless terrestrial and satellite voice and high speed data wireless solutions,’ said CEO Jay Monroe.