Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 July 2015

Xiaomi hits setbacks to its bid to usurp Samsung’s crown

Unless Apple ever bites the bullet and launches a genuinely low cost iPhone, the battle royal for volume growth will be between Samsung and Xiaomi, with a multitude of Chinese and Indian vendors trying to muscle in too. However, both contenders for the crown have experienced setbacks in the second quarter, even as Xiaomi looks to expand into more territories, like Brazil, which have been Samsung heartlands since the decline of Nokia and Motorola.

According to Korean reports, Samsung is going to report lower than expected operating profits, with a year-on-year fall of perhaps 24%. That would dash investor hopes that the launch of the Galaxy S6 and S6 Edge would be enough to revive the giant vendor’s recent lacklustre performance in handsets.

Meanwhile, Xiaomi’s first half shipments were up 33% compared to the same period in 2014, but that is a sad comedown from 227% growth in full year 2014. According to a tweet by Hugo Barra, the company’s VP of international operations, Xiaomi shipped 34.7m smartphones in the first six months of 2015, which would put it well away from its target of 100m units for the full year.

Reuters reported that CEO Lei Jun has since lowered that target to 80m, with both Chinese and Android growth expected to be slower than the worldwide mobile market’s for the first time. Chinese shipments fell by 4.3% year-on-year in the first quarter, according to various analyst estimates, to 98.8m – the first decline in six years.

This will make it more urgent for Xiaomi, and other Chinese vendors, to reduce their reliance on their home market and seek territories which are still experiencing high growth in smartphone adoption – which will create new challenges for Samsung as the incumbent.

However, the race for the massive handset markets of India and Brazil is not producing results quite as expected. In India, the increasingly wide gap where Nokia used to live is certainly being filled by Chinese and Indian handset makers, as anticipated, but market leader Samsung is proving surprisingly resilient, and its Tizen-powered Z1 model was the shock success story of the first half of 2015.

Meanwhile, Xiaomi’s launch into India, begun last year, has been hampered by legal attacks from Ericsson, but the company has now turned its attention to Brazil, where it will also seek to dislodge Samsung from its current leadership position.

According to the Economic Times, Samsung has sold one million Z1s this year in India. The Korean giant’s Tizen operating system, once seen as a tool to reduce the vendor’s reliance on Google and Android, has suffered from delayed launches and carrier apathy. Indeed, it had largely been written off as a handset OS, with Samsung refocusing many of its Tizen efforts on wearables and other non-cellphone categories.

But it is carving out a niche in the Indian sub-$100 smartphone space, which shifts 2.8m devices a month, and according to Reuters, Samsung is to launch several new Tizen models this year, at various price points. Some, like the Z1, will undercut similar Android models. Samsung presumably calculates that the damage to sales by low cost vendors will outweigh the possible cannibalization of its own low end Android models.

Other supposed Tizen launches will be in the midrange, and there could even be a premium device. Samsung is a master of supporting large numbers of models and platforms, leveraging its unparalleled marketing and distribution resources to address every possible sub-segment of the user base. However, it has pulled back from developing such large numbers of handsets in the past couple of years, as it has sought to reduce costs and strengthen brand awareness. It will need to be careful not to confuse the premium market, and so detract from the power of Galaxy, with a Tizen flagship, even if that does enable it to improve its balance of power with Google.

Meanwhile, Tizen may have done better than expected in India, but it remains a minnow compared to the Android vendors, and this is a market Samsung needs to defend with all the weapons at its disposal. Its market lead is being eroded by homegrown players, particularly MicroMAX, which according to some calculations (Canalys’s in particular) overtook the Korean firm in smartphone sales in Q414 (Samsung and some other analyst firms dispute that). Other Indian majors, Karbonn and Lava, were third and fourth in Canalys’s league table.

This creates a challenge for Xiaomi, and other handset makers entering from China, which need to expand outside their home country in order to keep growing sales and global share. Xiaomi has overtaken Samsung in China itself, but is hampered from attempting the same in India by the strength of the local players and by Ericsson’s patent-based legal action, which barred Xiaomi from importing some models into India from late in 2014. Indian reports indicate that case might reach settlement soon, but it has disrupted some of Xiaomi’s efforts in the country – though the firm still claimed to have sold onem handsets in its first six months in India, from June 2014, and is investing in manufacturing and R&D resources in the country.

However, it is also looking beyond Asia, and this week started sales outside Asia for the first time, with the launch of its Redmi 2 handset in Brazil. This will sell for BRL499 ($160), aiming to offer high end features for a midrange price and so hit popular Android models from Samsung and others. Xiaomi will assemble its products locally via a partnership with manufacturer Foxconn, which has a major plant in Brazil.

Unlike India, Brazil’s homegrown brands are not well-established, and the market is dominated by Samsung, Motorola/Lenovo and LG. Samsung has 30% share, according to Canalys, and Motorola 23%. However, Brazil is still quite a fluid market, and has been a key area to launch new mobile options. For instance, it was the first commercial launchpad for the Mozilla Firefox Mobile OS, via Telefonica’s Vivo operator.

Xiaomi helps keep its prices low by subsidizing hardware costs via its software and app store. This will be particularly important in Brazil, where there are high import taxes (hence the local manufacture) and electronics are generally sold at premium prices (an iPhone 6 retails for $1,100). For $160, Brazilian consumers will get a Redmi 2 with LTE, a 4.7-inch 720p screen and an 8-megapixel camera, all running on a Qualcomm Snapdragon 410 processor.