Sprint Nextel knew its market when it announced plans for its Xohm WiMAX-based service and put such heavy emphasis on innovative devices ‘ to the extent of selecting only handset makers to supply the WiMAX infrastructure. But as the company gears up to merge Xohm into the Clearwire joint venture, bringing its clear vision on mobile internet devices, and the relationships it has already formed with manufacturers, to the party, how many products will actually be available as the first networks go live?
Nokia has shown off the WiMAX version of its N810 Internet Tablet, a key weapon that Sprint wanted from the start for its armory, but this is not yet certified by the WiMAX Forum. More seriously, Intel has delayed the WiMAX iteration of Centrino, and while Samsung has shown WiMAX handsets and PDAs, these are currently only working on the Korean version of the network, Wi-Bro. At a WiMAX conference in South Africa this week, one of the key complaints expressed by integrators and operators from the southern African region ‘ seen as one of the most important medium term opportunities for the technology ‘ was the shortage of devices, and the vague timescales for their availability.
Sprint’s need for devices is even more urgent, with its first commercial Xohm network going live in September in Baltimore, followed by further systems in Chicago and Washington DC this year, not to mention Clearwire’s first few commercial networks based on 802.16e rather than its old proprietary technology from NextNet. Pre-merger, the old Clearwire’s predicament is less serious, since it has initially mainly focused on fixed and nomadic clients, rather than talking up an advanced mobile web vision centered on a new breed of open multimedia handheld products, as Sprint envisages. However, even the unreconstructed Clearwire will need laptop availability to drive uptake of its services beyond in-home fixed CPE or portable units from Motorola.
Also important will be USB modems, but the first vendor of those for Sprint Xohm, ZTE, also has no certification for its products ‘ and Sprint has been insistent that certification is vital for consumer confidence and its own economics and risk avoidance. But it may have to go live with non-certified devices and no handsets (it does have its own interoperability testing program though the tests are different from those required for the Forum kitemark).
In June Xohm chief Barry West said the initial devices for Baltimore and the other cities would be a Samsung card, a ZyXel modem, a ZTE dongle and the Nokia N810, along with laptops with Centrino embedded. In reality, the only one of these to be certified so far is the ZyXel, along with subscriber modules from Airspan and Samsung, and subscriber unit chips from Beceem, Intel and Sequans. This means that the chips that ZTE and Nokia are using (Beceem and Intel respectively) are safe, but Intel itself will not have its full product available.
Given Intel’s disproportionate influence on WiMAX, its delay of an implementation of the Centrino wireless notebook chipset for its favorite technology is likely to be given disproportionate attention, as a sign that the momentum behind 802.16e is weakening, even among its greatest supporters. Combined with the perception that the Forum is moving slowly on certification, this only adds fuel to those parties arguing that WiMAX’ headstart on LTE is narrowing dangerously, an outcome that would put Intel under massive pressure to come up with an LTE chip strategy itself.
The highly anticipated Centrino 2 mobile notebook platform is launching this week as expected, but without the dual-mode Wi-Fi 11n/WiMAX option, codenamed Echo Peak. Intel now says that will ship later this year, but could not guarantee that would be in time for the Sprint and Clearwire live dates. Centrino 2, itself delayed earlier this year, is the fifth generation of the platform and its main new feature is support for the 802.11n draft standard for fast Wi-Fi. PC makers such as Fujitsu, HP, Lenovo, Sony and Toshiba are launching new notebooks concurrently with the release of Centrino 2, previously codenamed Montevina.