Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 March 2013

ZTE’s first ever loss epitomizes wireless vendors’ challenges

ZTE has reported its first ever full year loss for 2012, blaming a range of factors, many of which epitomize the challenges facing the whole mobile sector. For instance, delayed or scaled-back carrier roll-outs; squeezed margins on infrastructure; and the decline of CDMA and of featurephones, are all issues which, to a greater or lesser extent, affect ZTE’s rivals too. However, others are more specific, and sound some warning bells for this year too, particularly the failure to continue to grow international sales as a percentage, partly because of US hostility to Chinese suppliers.

The decline of overseas revenues is concerning for a company which has worked hard to reduce its reliance on its home market and establish itself as an international brand. In 2012, the healthy Chinese economy and the operator’s continuing 3G expansions helped keep ZTE’s domestic sales stable, while revenue from other markets fell by 4.5% compared to 2011. Chinese revenues were 47% of the total.

One factor is the attitude of the US authorities, which was highlighted again this week when it was reported that a condition of Softbank’s purchase of a 70% stake in Sprint might be government supervision over the purchase of network equipment. That was taken as code for keeping Chinese suppliers out of Sprint, which once got very close to hiring Huawei for its huge network modernization project, until it was warned off by government agencies, citing security concerns. . In January, the FCC was asked to delay the Softbank-Sprint deal on the basis of national security concerns.

While some believe US restrictions on Chinese vendors in critical infrastructure contracts owe more to commercial fear than real security risks, that has not stopped Huawei and ZTE being effectively blackballed in major network deals. A report issued last year by the. House of Representatives’ Intelligence Committee argued that the Chinese vendors had close ties to their government and could use malware in their equipment to breach US security. The report urged businesses not to buy the two firms’ equipment despite Chinese warnings that such action violates free market principles and risks political and trade disputes.

Such factors limit ZTE’s opportunities in a key market (and it has faced obstructions in others too, like India). That will not help it bounce back from its 2012 loss of CNY2.84bn ($457m) ‘ reversing last year’s profit of CNY2.06bn. For the year, revenue was CNY84.22bn, down 2.4% from CNY86.25bn.

Most of the factors at work are affecting all vendors though, notably carriers’ belt tightening, which is leading to deals being delayed or reduced in size, and to a trend noted by Ericsson ‘ for cellcos to focus on modernizations rather than new build-outs.

In its statement, ZTE said it ‘continued to focus on in-depth business development and operation in major populous nations and with mainstream global carriers to enhance the capabilities for long term sustainable development’ and added that it was ‘vigorously establishing its presence in the market for government and enterprise networks’. A total of CNY41.6bn came from carrier networks (down 10.57% year-on-year), CNY25.84bn from terminals (down 4%, and CNY16.78bn from telecom software, services and other products (up 31%). Again this reflects an industry-wide trend to supplement pressurized equipment revenues with a shift to software and services.

Other factors in the loss, according to ZTE, included a drop in featurephone sales as the world shifts towards smartphones, and the impact on gross profit margins of pursuing low margin contracts in China, Africa and South America. The margin was down 6.36 percentage points to 23.9% partly because ZTE remains heavily focused on legacy technologies. It suffered from the world decline in CDMA, a market where it has been a strong player in emerging economies. It said it had strengthened its relationships with existing GSM, UMTS and CDMA customers while also ‘vigorously exploring new market niches’, a statement which suggested it remains heavily focused on legacy technologies.

The mention of featurephones suggests that ZTE’s bid to shift its handset business towards high end, branded models is still immature, and it remains dependent on its traditional low end and white label devices. Device operating revenue fell in line with the fall in low end handsets and data cards, but ZTE claimed smart terminals were ‘accounting for an increasing percentage of the group’s revenue of terminals, giving rise to a more reasonable product mix, a more balanced market distribution, and more diversified sales channels’. Gross profit margin in this unit was 16.6%, up from 15% in 2011, because of the gradual shift to smartphones.

However, there were brighter signs. ZTE reported positive cashflow for the first time in three years, at CNY1.87bn, and achieved revenue growth in some regions. Asia-Pacific sales were up by 2.8% on the previous year, while combined revenue from Europe and the Americas rose by 1.6%, in what ZTE said was a sign it is gaining ground in the US market.

The company said in its statement that it was ‘well positioned in 2013’ to cash in on rapid growth in wireless and wireline traffic, and in global demand for smart devices. ‘The competitiveness of ZTE’s products will allow the company to deepen our relationship with customers globally,’ it added.