Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 May 2007

Verizon backs Qualcomm view that CDMA will be adequate for years to come

Beset by licensing disputes and even prepared to spin off its legendary patents business if necessary, Qualcomm continues to position itself as a critical player in the intellectual property picture that will evolve to support ‘4G’. It now claims over 1,000 essential patents for OFDM and MIMO – the lynchpins of all the would-be 4G platforms – and is also insisting that CDMA will have a continuing role in the mobile broadband platforms, rather than being obliterated by OFDM-based alternatives. But of the four major networks that are jostling for a position in the 4G future, Qualcomm’s own – Ultra Mobile Broadband, or EV-DO Rev C – perhaps has the shakiest future, up against LTE, WiMAX and even the Chinese Future Network. This makes it essential that the company has products and patents in all the candidates, and that it sorts out the relationship between its licensing and chipmaking activities now, during the 3G generation, rather than letting the current uncertainties spill over into a new and very different mobile world.

In a recent interview with the IDG news service, Qualcomm’s senior vice president of investor relations and international marketing, Bill Davidson, said the company has been interested in OFDM since its formation, and that back then, “OFDM was considered a path instead of CDMA. The company ended up going down the CDMA route because CDMA was better able to handle all the things you want to do on a wide area wireless network. We believe that to this day”.

This is very much the Qualcomm line today – OFDM is good for broadband, and Qualcomm will excel in it should the market want it, but it will not match CDMA-based options for mobile wide area performance any time soon. However, as Davidson argued, the availability of larger blocks of spectrum – 10MHz and larger – makes OFDM more viable, and while he claims it is no more efficient than CDMA, he agrees that in wide bands it is simpler to implement.

Although actions such as the recent acquisition of the 802.16e assets of TeleCIS suggest that Qualcomm will soon feel obliged to move into the WiMAX chip market itself, it remains reluctant to acknowledge the technology’s advantages and would clearly rather the next generation was based just on LTE and UMB – even though the former is as-yet poorly defined and could, in theory, include no more Qualcomm IPR than 802.16e. The CDMA giant may have been converted to singing the praises of OFDM as a whole, but it continues to criticize WiMAX as a poor implementation of that technology, at least for the mobile world, arguing that it suffers in efficiency terms from its heritage as a fixed wireless standard.

Yet 802.16e has attracted a level of vendor support that UMB has not, with CDMA giants like Nortel and ZTE sitting on the fence about whether they expect UMB to become a commercial system at all (although market leader Alcatel Lucent is designing its EV-DO Rev A base station with the RF components to support UMB, allowing for just a software/antenna upgrade).

With the next generation technologies all looking increasingly similar, and with UMB using OFDM on the downlink, Qualcomm loses, for the first time, its key advantage – offering operators a seamless upgrade path. Unlike GSM carriers, CDMA players have not had to undergo complete network rebuilds to support new services, but they will be forced to do so if they move to Rev C (although developments like Alcatel’s will cushion the blow), as well as needing additional spectrum to support wider channel sizes. This untethers them from the CDMA path and will encourage many to weigh up all the possible options – as Sprint Nextel already has for its 2.5GHz build-out, despite its continuing commitment to CDMA in its PCS bands.

At worst, UMB fails to come to market and Qualcomm focuses entirely on LTE and, probably, WiMAX, and seeks to maximize its influence over the future directions for those systems. At best, UMB does achieve a role as a separate option, giving Qualcomm strong control over at least part of the 4G market, but the chipmaker becomes more reliant on the good graces of flagship operators like Verizon Wireless, and so weakens its negotiating position with carriers and equipment makers.

Carriers like Sprint and Verizon are taking the view that all the choices for the next generation are similar on the downlink, with the OFDM/MIMO basis, and so there will be huge advantage to the technology that is available at the right time and price. For Sprint, with its large swathes of spectrum and strategy to move into 4G-style services as early as possible, that put WiMAX in the frame, because LTE and UMB were not yet available and other options lacked sufficient ecosystem. Vice president of technology development, Ali Tabassi, has said he would not look to support a second OFDM system in future (presumably referring to UMB) as the two networks would provide similar benefits. (In timing terms, UMB is set to be ratified by the 3GPP2 body this month, with LTE following in 3GPP about five months later. Commercial products are expected for both systems in 2009, around the same time the next generation of WiMAX comes into play.)

Verizon Wireless has the opposite issue with timing – not seeing any urgent need to move to any of the OFDM networks, instead focusing on maximizing its benefits from CDMA EV-DO Revs A and B by taking a strong position on software technologies like IMS. Chief technology officer Dick Lynch said recently that he was remaining neutral about which OFDM network to favor – and questioning how soon Verizon would need one at all. ‘Let’s back into this question,’ he said in an interview. ‘Let’s ask ourselves what do we need this technology for? What do our customers need that they can’t get on 3G? I think the jury is still out there.’

This is especially true, he argues, when 3G systems are evolving so rapidly and, increasingly, in direct response to operator requirements. For instance, EV-DO Rev B will offer the option of a ‘super channel’, delivering peak data rates of 7Mbps or more by aggregating Rev A channels and so supporting high bandwidth applications, while Revs A and B both support IP applications such as VoIP. And Lynch does not yet see a pressing need to invest in Rev B, taking the line that current networks are more than adequate for the applications cellcos need to deliver, and that consumers demand.

This is right against the received (and often vendor driven) wisdom that is influencing many carrier decisions – that 3G is entirely inadequate for mobile broadband and needs to be upgraded or supplemented as quickly as possible for increasingly demanding customers. Yet, so far at least, Verizon Wireless is showing high measures of success with 3G services like VCast, and where the network is not up to the job, it will look for a parallel system, as it has by adopting Qualcomm’s MediaFLO for mobile television.

Qualcomm is often accused of kow-towing to Verizon Wireless, but if it does, Lynch’s comments show the reason why. Seldom are a manufacturer and a leading customer heard to voice such similar views on the evolution of their platforms. Lynch’s view must be music to Qualcomm’s ears – and, indirectly, to all those companies, such as Ericsson, that want to make a lot more money out of current technologies before they move to new ones. Apart from the hesitancy about deploying Rev B at an early stage, Verizon is echoing Qualcomm’s own line – that CDMA platforms will be powerful enough for cellco needs for a long time to come; that OFDM has its advantages, but these are marginal in a mobile model; that where 3G does have failings, operators can more cost effectively turn to supplementary solutions such as MediaFLO than invest in an entire new network. Continuing aggressive enhancement of its CDMA and UMTS/HSPA offerings; plus new revenue streams that support emerging operator needs (including MediaFLO and its content frameworks based around Brew) – this is a combination that will generate maximum revenue and market influence for Qualcomm, and in the mean time, it will build up its OFDM arsenal for the day (in its dreams, long delayed) that this becomes unavoidable. The argument will hold weight with some risk-averse and cash strapped operators, and with some innovators like Verizon too – but whether the market holds back on OFDM, or rushes towards it, forcing Qualcomm to unleash its OFDM weapons earlier than it would like, there does not seem to be an obvious major role for UMB.

Latest on the Nokia row:

The stand-off between Nokia and Qualcomm over the renewal terms of their licensing agreement continues, with Nokia reiterating that it has no intention of renewing under the old terms of the now expired deal. CEO Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo told the annual general meeting of shareholders that to do so would be tantamount to handing Qualcomm ‘dictatorial reign over the entire wireless industry.’

Kallasvuo said: ‘Talks are ongoing, the situation is open, but I have to say agreement cannot be reached before both parties are in accord. It’s completely clear that we cannot give one company, in this case Qualcomm, a chance to dictate rules for the whole industry. The issue is not Qualcomm versus Nokia, it’s more about Qualcomm versus the rest of the industry.’

Qualcomm argues that, by creating a technology that many companies can license, it has actually increased competition to Nokia, which would otherwise have a pricing stranglehold on the handset sector.

However, Qualcomm has yet to sue over Nokia’s continued use of the patents at issue, even since the licensing deal expired. This is being interpreted as a sign that the CDMA giant is wary of pushing its rival too far. Nokia is setting aside royalty payments at the level that it feels to be reasonable.

Recently, Ericsson – which engaged in the last massive licensing dispute with Qualcomm, resulting in the Swedish company acquiring its antagonist’s infrastructure business – warned that a prolonged stand-off between the pair will hurt the wider global mobile industry.