Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 June 2007

FCC reiterates 3.65GHz ruling despite WiMAX objections

The US regulator has largely upheld its decisions of 2005 on the licensing scheme for the 3.65GHz band, which is closely watched by the WiMAX community because of its closeness to 3.5GHz, which is commonly allocated for broadband wireless outside the US. The WiMAX leaders expressed mixed feelings about the latest ruling – welcoming the end to uncertainty and debate, but disappointed about some rules on spectrum sharing.

The FCC decided in 2005 to open up the 3.65-3.7GHz band on a lightly licensed basis, going back on an earlier policy of making it fully license-exempt. This was mainly to protect existing satellite users of the band and allow for higher power levels, since a major objective was to promote better rural services in the US. Once higher power, 24W operations were proposed for rural areas, the FCC shifted to a non-exclusive, shared use licensing scheme under which access to the band is unrestricted, but operators have to register with the regulator and obey anti-interference and good neigbor policies. Similar schemes are used elsewhere, for instance by the UK in 5.8GHz.

The main source of controversy in the two years of debate that have followed has been the FCC’s insistence that products certified for the band must support contention-based protocols, as the primary way for operators to avoid interfering with one another when sharing spectrum. This approach is part of Wi-Fi and is common in technologies geared to unlicensed bands, but WiMAX relies on accurate scheduling to avoid interference, rather than on dealing with traffic collisions. The WiMAX Forum and several vendors such as Intel and Alvarion therefore opposed the 2005 ruling, claiming it would take years to rewrite and implement a WiMAX solution that met the FCC requirement.

At the heart of the debate was an issue that is pertinent across unlicensed or lightly licensed bands – how to combine more open spectrum policies with quality of service. WiMAX supporters claim that their technology is capable of delivering carrier class services in unlicensed bandwidth, even to the extent of supporting service level agreements, as enterprise focused providers like Towerstream do. However, predictable quality of service must rely on a scheduler, not contention-based protocols, which are suited to best effort offerings, they argue.

However, in its new statements, the FCC said that using contention-based protocols would “facilitate operation of the widest variety of broadband technologies with minimal risk of interference”.

Intel and Motorola also claimed that a ‘listen-before-talk’ contention protocol was unsuited for long range operations. The FCC responded that Cisco and Tropos Networks had shown that such protocols could be added to networks at a reasonable cost.

Also included in the FCC’s 30-page ruling was a clarification of an earlier decision to restrict the operation of contention-based protocols to the lower 25MHz of the band. The band has been used for federal and private radio location services and, since 1984, for international communication satellites. The FCC specifically ruled out adding new regulations to limit interference with satellites although it created radio exclusion zones around 100 grandfathered earth stations. Future satellite systems in the band would have secondary rights to new terrestrial broadband services.

Not all the objections to the 2005 proposals concerned the method of avoiding interference in a shared use model. Some companies still held out for completely unlicensed use, while the Wireless Communications Association and Motorola wanted an exclusive licensing scheme to ensure zero interference (and likely raise the value of the spectrum, limiting the ability of start-ups to challenge the wireless majors). Some petitioners also asked for different licensing schemes for urban and rural areas. All these ideas were rejected by the FCC. Intel, Redline and Alvarion had warned against ‘squatter’ licensees who bought rights but did not build out networks but the Commission said it agreed with a Cisco comment that a licensee’s slow build-out would not hamper others from using the spectrum, in the shared model.

The long awaited clarification of rules for 3.65GHz will at least set the stage for vendors to adapt their 3.5GHz gear for this market, and so could stimulate new wireless services in the US, and a reawakening of the dormant interest in WiMAX outside licensed bands. Already, some vendors are responding, including NextWave (see separate item), which aims to launch chips and reference designs geared to 3.65GHz, among other bands, and to open metrozone models.

While the WiMAX vendors now gear up to make their technology dominant in the new band, with a view to getting as close as possible to a globally harmonized spectrum chun around 3.5GHz, the US agency is still focused mainly on rural services. ‘Our licensing regime for the 3650 MHz band will serve as a wireless highway between small towns and the big city’it will facilitate the delivery of broadband to all corners of the country by serving a different user group, one that often is driven by more localized, community-based needs,’ stated Commissioner Jonathan Adelstein.