Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 June 2007

US regulator bombarded with innovative proposals for 700MHz

US regulator the FCC is being bombarded with proposals that would repaint the spectrum picture and use new allocations to turn the mobile balance of power on its head. There are the rival suggestions from Cyren Call and Frontline Wireless, to set part of the upcoming 700MHz allocation aside for a combined commercial/public safety model; Google’s recent outlining of a scheme that would auction bandwidth on an on-demand basis, to stimulate smaller providers with innovative services; and now a coalition of wireless leaders is calling for the creation of a nationwide ‘open access’ wireless network that could bypass the cellcos’ spectrum.

The Wireless Founders Coalition for Innovation (WFCI) has sent a letter to FCC chairman Kevin Martin spelling out its recommendation that a slice of 700MHz radio spectrum should be designated for open access – a proposal that echoes similar, but less well supported, suggestions that some of Europe’s soon-to-be-released 2.5GHz frequencies should be reserved for open or municipal use.

Among the 15 people who signed the letter are the founders of Virgin Mobile USA and mobile download company Zingy; and the CEOs of mobile email provider Seven Networks and handset software maker mPortal. As in the Frontline and Google proposals, this idea would enable various parties to bid to be the network operator, wholesaling out access to other providers.

However, the cellcos are obviously bringing their huge lobbying power to bear against such ideas, which would provide an alternative to their own systems, stimulate new entrants and remove a chunk of the spectrum on offer from their reach. Verizon has been particularly vocal, and has aggressively opposed the Frontline Plan. And these plans cannot normally rely on active support from handset and software giants, since for all their interest in keeping the cellcos subordinate, they will not risk their vital relationships with the carriers. This is why the entry of internet giants like Google, which have no vested interest in the mobile status quo, has been so important for putting real weight behind creative new approaches. And with Nokia’s increasingly diverse route to market strategy, in which it is de-emphasizing US cellcos in favor of direct channels and enterprise units, it is not inconceivable that it might put some – at least muted – support behind new open models that could boost uptake of advanced mobile internet devices. In particular, device makers large and small resent the length of time it takes to get a handset approved for a US carrier network, and that the cellcos keep secret the specifications that would enable companies to make their products compatible with carrier networks.

“We believe the wireless industry is ripe with opportunities for innovation and economic growth, but the large wireless carriers currently act as gatekeepers to block or deter many of these opportunities,” the group wrote in the letter.

“When you come up with an idea for the internet, you just put it on the web, but when you come up with ideas for mobile phones, it’s really hard to try them out and get them in front of customers,” said Amol Sarva, co-founder of Virgin Mobile USA.

The FCC was swamped last week with tens of thousands of comments containing 250,000 signatures from citizens advocating open access in the 700MHz band along the lines proposed by Frontline Wireless, while Cyren Call remains heavily supported by the powerful public safety lobby.

The FCC wants to issue 700MHz rules this month to give prospective bidders six months to prepare for the auction. A complicating factor is the agency’s consideration of options to create a 700MHz license for national commercial broadband wireless access and national public safety broadband services. Frontline has proposed setting aside a 10MHz block to help further broadband and public safety policy goals based on a wholesale, open access business model. In addition to the 10MHz, Frontline’s plan would have the E-block licensee gaining access to a separate chunk of first responder frequencies at 700MHz. Frontline plans to compete in the 700 MHz auction and backs the Google auction plan. It wants the E-block licensee to use 25% of its commercial capacity for open active auctions.