The US MVNO sector may be under severe pressure, but another class of mobile challengers, the flat rate providers, is certainly storming the citadel, prompting response from the big four and likely to spur further consolidation.
The carriers that have pioneered the flat rate calling model in the US are MetroPCS and Leap Wireless, and there is rising speculation that these two largely complementary players will merge to create a significant counterweight to the national cellcos in some key growth markets. Even separately, they are proving highly disruptive, and have provoked Sprint Nextel, in particular, to step up its move towards unlimited voice and data plans. MetroPCS offers an unlimited calling plan for $30 a month, about one-third of most major carrier tariffs, and is stealing significant market share. “It’s perfectly conceivable that they will be taking 50% of [new customers] in the US market in the next one-and-a-half years,” Andrei Jezierski, partner with venture consultancy i2 Partners, told Business Week.
MetroPCS, which traded its first shares in April, almost doubled its net subscriber figures in the first quarter and boosted service revenues by 60% year-on-year, largely from expanding into new territories. At the end of Q1, it had 3.4m users, up 85% on a year earlier. It currently operates in parts of California, Florida, Georgia, Michigan, and Texas and has been acquiring spectrum to serve more large markets, with the forthcoming 700MHz auctions firmly in its sights.
The problem for the flat rate model is that it spurs high growth when the carrier launches in a new territory, but this rapidly tails off unless the operator adds new higher value services – which changes the model and eats into currently healthy margins – or keeps pushing into new geographies. MetroPCS’ first quarter results indicated this, with growth remaining flat in its established territories, and the impressive uptick coming from geographical expansion and some ARPU increase. Leap and MetroPCS have so far kept away from major head-to-head collision, concentrating on poaching business from the majors rather than each other, but as both are driven to expand, a merger would become ever more logical, and could create a new near-national player. So far, Leap, which emerged from bankruptcy protection in 2004 (six years after MetroPCS, then called General Wireless, did the same thing) has focused on midrange markets while its larger rival has targeted major cities.
Analysts are predicting that MetroPCS could have 10m subscribers by 2011, but this is clearly a business of scale, especially as the US market saturates and the giants introduce fixed/mobile convergence bundles, including lures such as ‘free’ wired broadband, and launch their own flat rate deals. Long term viability, then, relies on the two carriers merging with each other and, potentially, they could also make a good fit with Alltel, which has expanded rapidly in the past two years to become near-national itself. Alltel would complement one or both of the flat raters as it has focused on high value services and an early move into advanced mobile internet. However, the combination would dilute some of the key advantages of the flat rate model, which is often compared to that of the no-frills airlines – taking out every possible cent of cost and capping the average cost per new customer at about $100, roughly one-third that of the majors. Among the techniques are use of low cost, unsubsidized handsets and sales dominated by retail and online channels.
Just as the major airlines bought or launched their own no-frills arms in response to the emergence of SouthWest and Easyjet, so the major cellcos have to bite the bullet of embracing an approach that will impact on their own margins painfully. Sprint Nextel has launched flat rate schemes recently, though they are kept distinct from the core brand by using the Boost Mobile sub-brand, which is aimed at the same youthful demographic as MetroPCS. These are a major threat to the flat rate specialists, despite the significant new spectrum swathes that both players acquired in the recent AWS auctions. Sprint is responding to the popularity of flat rate by launching its Boost offering in markets with extra CDMA network capacity, and in places where Leap and MetroPCS do not currently offer service. The primary aims would be to limit the expansion potential of Leap and MetroPCS, and reduce churn of lower end customers without having to invest in additional capacity.
But other carriers may look to buy a flat rate company which they could run at arm’s length and with its own brand, in order to take advantage of the cashflow and growth opportunities without seriously diluting the core brand. Though Alltel is the most rumored to be interested in such a move, Verizon Wireless would not be out of the question, especially as it uses CDMA systems, as do both the flat raters. Perhaps the most interesting suggestion is that Clearwire would snap up MetroPCS or Leap, gaining a readymade revenue and customer base while it waits for its WiMAX offerings to ramp up, and enabling it to provide full mobility and voice roaming alongside its high bandwidth but geographically limited data services.
The US cellcos bite back:
In Europe, T-Mobile has been one of the frontunners in introducing flat rate voice and data schemes, and even its ‘all you can eat’ mobile internet offering Web ‘n’ Walk. In the US, it is looking at similar moves, and last week introduced a set of new promotional price plans and expanded its offerings at the increasingly popular $40 price point.
The carrier added a $40 per month ‘Get More 1,000 Plus’ individual plan that includes unlimited night and weekend calling, but does not include mobile-to-mobile minutes. The carrier also introduced a 1,500-minute individual plan at the same monthly price that does not include off-peak or mobile-to-mobile calling. Customers can add unlimited on-network calling to both plans for $7 per month. The pair of new offerings join T-Mobile’s 300-minute myFaves plan that includes unlimited off-peak calling at the crowded $40 price point, which is still undercut by MetroPCS.
And Sprint Nextel is expanding its unlimited access trials to new markets under the Boost Mobile brand. This is now available in San Francisco, Minneapolis, Philadelphia, Sacramento and Tampa and further territories are coming online. The Unlimited Access Packs give customers unlimited voice, text and data for $120 (plus mobile broadband and PC access, if desired, for an extra $30), and is taking on MyFaves and Alltel’s more expensive MyCircle plans head-to-head.
Like 3 in Europe, Sprint has to perform the dual trick of boosting market share in the short term while being squeezed between larger incumbents and rising low cost carriers; and of taking the lead in the high risk but inevitable move towards open mobile internet. Its aims are to increase the appeal of cellular services for all forms of voice and data, sidelining Wi-Fi (in contrast to T-Mobile, with its heavy investment in hotspots), trying to harness lower costs and new, more price efficient technologies to bring mobile rates down to the level of Wi-Fi plans, and to promote 3G on laptops as well as handsets. Wi-Fi access contracts for PCs typically cost $60 per month.