Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 July 2007

Femtocells gain ground with Netgear support and new Forum

The much vaunted femtocell came two steps closer to consumer-class volume last week with home Wi-Fi major Netgear entering the fray and the official formation of the Femto Forum, dedicated to promoting the technology and acting to avoid the greatest brake on any home-oriented platform, fragmentation.

With Cisco’s Linksys widely expected to enter the sector soon, Netgear – next in line to Linksys in the consumer WLan sales stakes – has stolen a march, and is working with femtocell specialist Ubiquisys on a home gateway product that will combine a 3G femtocell with Wi-Fi/VoIP and DSL. The femtocell – a miniaturized indoor base station designed to improve indoor wireless coverage and support pricing models such as homezones – was once perceived as a direct challenge to WLan-oriented approaches to convergence, but the two technologies are starting to converge themselves, giving the femtocell an enhanced opportunity to compete as a consumer device like a Wi-Fi access point, as well as an extension of the carrier infrastructure.

Netgear and Ubiquisys will create an all-in-one gateway for operators to offer at “consumer level pricing”, with commercial availability scheduled for early next year. The partners will build the functionality of the current Ubiquisys 3G access point, the ZoneGate, into Netgear DSL/WLan home gateways, a combination that the larger company said could also be extended to WiMAX in future, especially for the small business sector. This would also be a natural space for Linksys and Samsung, and the WiMAX option would appeal to carriers that do not control DSL lines, because of its ability to support the backhaul too.

Products like these will blur the lines drawn between consumer Wi-Fi APs and cellular femtocells, and support mobile carrier models that can behave more like those of the DSL providers. An important element in this will be full standardization of the equipment and interfaces, to drive volume economics and simplicity, and this is the driving motivation behind the newly launched Femto Forum. That will require uniform standards, a broad ecosystem and support from at least some of the majors on the consumer electronics as well as the infrastructure sectors. Meeting all these requirements can potentially be aided by a strong industry forum, hence the formation of the Forum, which aims to promote the concept and educate the market; influence standards bodies; and foster an ecosystem, all in the name of avoiding fragmentation and driving volume and operator confidence.

The initially announced members are the usual femtocell suspects (plus the newly converted Netgear) – Airvana, ip.access, picoChip, RadioFrame, Tatara and Ubiquisys. However, the Forum’s chairman, Professor Simon Saunders, says a decent number of large operators has also signed up, though not gone public yet, as have several large equipment players, including majors from the home hub market (we have to assume Cisco/Linksys). The operators, of course, will lure in the major vendors and it will be particularly important to gain the endorsement of Ericsson, which lent its mighty weight to the femtocell cause at the 3GSM show in February with a product announcement, but is just as capable of seeking to drive its own standards as supporting those of others (it is almost alone in favoring the semi-standardized IUB interface over SIP or UMA for femtocell-core interaction).

With the silicon majors also poised to take their positions, the even greater wild card is the normally forum-allergic Qualcomm, which has been showing growing interest in femtocells lately. Although a dual-mode approach might seem more appealing to Qualcomm, with its heavy focus on multi-radio chipsets, UMA has not gained ground in its CDMA heartland, and politically it has been positioning 3G femtocells as a reason why nobody should need WiMAX for convergence. In taking this line, it needs to distance itself from the more all-embracing approach that the nascent femtocell sector is adopting, and certainly from the efforts of the WiMAX Forum, picoChip and others to apply both femtocell and UMA ideas to WiMAX itself. The culture of Qualcomm, and the peculiarities of its political drivers, may lead it to work outside the industry mainstream once again, which could itself create a measure of fragmentation.

The Femto Forum reflects a general trend towards creating highly specialized industry groups rather than allowing emerging technologies to be swamped by the byzantine processes of the larger groupings. Indeed, some major organizations, notably ETSI, are actively fostering small forums, recognizing that the wireless standards bodies and industry alliances run the risk of making themselves redundant by failing to move in time with the market. A clearly focused forum, if well managed, can make decisions more quickly and help drive a technology to market, though it still faces the challenge of having to liaise with multiple larger bodies, a complex task for which it may have insufficient resources – especially without the active participation and funding of several tier one players (compare the rapid progress of the Qualcomm-backed FLO Forum with the flounderings of the UMTS TDD Alliance, for instance).

However, the new Forum will certainly be important to sustain the momentum that has built up behind femtocells this year, but which needs to be translated quickly into usable and affordable products if a backlash is not to ensue in 2008. A valuable element in this will be the work done to support UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Access) as an alternative interface to SIP, for carriers that remain nervous about moving to all-IP too soon. So far, in moving towards fixed-mobile convergence, homezones and the quad play, the larger providers have split between those relying heavily on Wi-Fi and using UMA to hand off calls from the WLan to the mobile network; and those aiming to move straight to full IMS, and therefore more inclined towards SIP and femtocells.

The choice used to seem simple – carriers could act quickly and relatively simply with Wi-Fi and UMA, with the downsides of having to support dual-mode handsets, and to lose control of a large amount of traffic as it moved off the closed network and on to the WLan (though if 3G networks approach capacity, that could be an advantage too). Or they could adopt the more strategic route of supporting SIP standards all across the network. This would take longer to implement and would involve greater impact on the core and thus higher risk and cost, but would support the overall move to all-IP and IMS, and could use existing handsets. Adding the femtocell to the SIP picture also enabled the carrier to improve indoor coverage and support homezones of a small enough size to be commercially viable (unlike the unprofitable homezone schemes introduced by the German cellcos, whose cells are so large that very little traffic passes over the full-tariffed network).

Now the choices are becoming more blurred – though also more appealing to mobile operators, in particular. This is largely because companies like UMA cheerleader Kineto Wireless and Ubiquisys have started to break down the association between Wi-Fi and UMA, making it clear that the advantages of UMA, such as its simplicity, can also be applied to cellular femtocells (and, of course, WiMAX). This provides cellcos with their potential dream scenario – eliminating Wi-Fi again from the equation, supporting convergence and homezones, but without having to upgrade the whole core too rapidly. It has also helped bring the home electronics vendors like Netgear into play.

In transferring call sessions between the local network and the core network, using the broadband connection, the femtocell can use various interfaces, but a fully standardized one will be vital for mass market scaling, with UMA and SIP the main options. Although UMA was designed with unlicensed access in mind, it is not tied to these technologies or to Wi-Fi. It uses open interfaces between the RAN and core, in the shape of Iucs and Iups, and services implemented in the existing core will automatically be available to the femtocells. It offers some advantages over other connectivity options and should be considered as a generic way to link access points to the core, not specific to one wireless network. It offloads as much traffic as possible to the home network – essential to avoid congestion when scaling the RAN to millions of users – and supports the concept of moving the phone around and retaining its ID, a challenge for femtocells.

Of course, UMA could also be the connection between the cellular network and WiMAX, and this may be a major opportunity, since early WiMAX plans by major carriers rely heavily on dual-mode operation with GSM, for hand-off and coverage. The Koreans will lead here. Kineto, for instance, worked with Samsung on a WiMAX/3G handset with UMA, which the Korean vendor needed to demonstrate for a proof of concept.

Kineto sees a scenario where UMA is used to connect to the network controller and mix and match with many different femtocells and access points, allowing for highly commoditized networks but with internet security. This would be cheaper and would support mobile internet business models more naturally, proponents argue, than the proposed creation of a new SIP specification for a collapsed, secure SIP node. Using UMA in this way would save such effort and provide an integration between the UMA and IMS environments.

Other carriers believe IMS is now sufficiently evolved to enable them to bypass UMA. Notable among these are the CDMA operators, plus original UMA supporter AT&T Mobility, which will now base its multinetwork convergence plans on SIP. It claims UMA no longer has a major time to market advantage over IMS/SIP and is widely expected to be a femtocell supporter at an early stage. A likely supplier could be 2Wire, whose residential gateways AT&T already uses for its satellite/DSL Homezone services, and which is working on incorporating UMTS and EV-DO femtocells into its HomePortal product, Netgear-style (no doubt with an eye on its largest customer). 2Wire has investment from AT&T itself, Alcatel-Lucent and Telmex.

Since a SIP-based architecture removes RAN resources from the equation, it is
extremely cost effective in terms of capex for carriers that are well down the IP road, like AT&T. The development of all-IP flat architectures is accelerating, and the femtocell specialists are moving with the wave – for instance, 3Way Networks, now part of Airvana, is working with convergence software specialist Tatara Systems on an all-IP femtocell platform. SIP and IMS support should bring the femtocells into emerging new core architectures and enable large scale femtocell deployments.

The debate rests partly on the question of whether the femtocell is perceived as an extension of the network or a consumer device, and therefore how far it should be tightly incorporated into the cellco’s critical infrastructure. The answer to this will lie with an individual operator’s circumstances – whether it has significant investment in Wi-Fi, whether it owns its own mobile network, how far it wants to promote fixed-mobile substitution, and so on. The important challenge for femtocells will be to embrace sufficient technology options to support almost any model, while retaining the uniformity required for volume and carrier confidence.

Femtocell figures:

Research firm IDC believes femtocell users will surpass the 5.7m mark in western Europe by the year 2011, with spending on femto-enabled services rising to $900m a year in the same period.

“The main benefits for operators will include improving indoor coverage; freeing macro network capacity; reducing latency, capital, and operational expenditures; enabling flat rate voice and data tariffs at home; migrating users to W-CDMA; adding revenue opportunities from bundling fixed and mobile services; and being able to capture whole households and thus contain churn and increase total subscriptions,” said senior analyst Joao da Silva.

Meanwhile, a recent study from ABI Research forecasts that by 2011 there will be 102m users of femtocell products on 32m access points worldwide.

Convergence in the USA:

T-Mobile USA, along with BT and Orange, has been the flagwaver for UMA and last week its Hotspot@Home service went national after trials around Seattle. This gives the fourth largest US cellco a considerable headstart in convergence over Verizon and AT&T, which are both working on SIP projects, and Sprint Nextel, which will rely mainly on its WiMAX network for quad play, and has issued an RFP for femtocells. T-Mobile’s choice was partly one of necessity, since it has not begun build-out of its 3G nework yet, and UMA allows it to leverage the one network where it does have superior coverage, its Wi-Fi hotspots. Its strategy also demonstrates the key argument for UMA, that it is relatively simple and quick to get to market. Like Orange, it will enable T-Mobile to offer pricing incentives such as flat rate, low cost calls within a home zone, with calls handing off seamlessly to the cellular network when out of range of the home or public hotspot. In the US, home-based solutions have an even more basic appeal to customers than in Europe since cellular coverage remains so poor in many areas, even for voice, making an indoor access point the only way to deliver service at all – it is noticeable that T-Mobile is currently concentrating its marketing almost entirely on voice quality, availability and cost, rather than extending it to data services as Orange has done with Unik.

Of course, the major downside to UMA, compared to a femtocell all-3G approach, is that specialist dual-mode handsets are required, and these remain less plentiful and more expensive than average cellphones, requiring fairly hefty operator subsidies. The initial Hotspot@Home phones are the Nokia 6086 and the Samsung SGH-t409, both of which will cost only $50 to the user with a two-year contract, which means T-Mobile is paying about $150 for each customer acquisition in subsidies. The carrier says it will also be offering free wireless home routers from Linksys and D-Link that have been optimized for voice/data services with support for WMM, part of the 802.11e standard that sets up the secure link and improves quality of service. However, T-Mobile will not guarantee call quality.

Users of the T-Mobile service can make unlimited VoIP over Wi-Fi calls by adding $10 a month (or $20 for a five-line family plan) to an existing T-Mobile account of $40 per month or more. If a call starts on the WLan, it also remains unmetered when it hands off to the GSM/EDGE network and calls at T-Mobile hotspots are free.

UMA models have had mixed fortunes in Europe so far, but could potentially be more disruptive in the US, where the other major carriers remain some way from convergence, and where cellular coverage remains such an issue. Investor research firm ThinkEquity hailed Hotspot@Home as ‘the most important architectural shift in cellphone technology since the introduction of digital GSM in 1992″ – a rather more enthusiastic reception than investors gave BT Fusion or Orange Unik.

Other smaller operators are also rolling out dual-mode services. Regional player Cincinnati Bell pipped T-Mobile to the post last month with the introduction of CB Home Run in the Dayton, Ohio area, where the operator has 300 hotspots. CB also uses the Nokia 6086, which is becoming a useful element in the Finnish company’s bid to increase its penetration of US cellcos (see separate item). CB’s unlimited Wi-Fi calling service can be added for $10 per month to wireless plans of $40 per month or more. Also, Embarq – formerly the local wireline arm of Sprint and now an MVNO on that company’s CDMA network – has upgraded its trial convergence service to commercial availability in six markets. Embarq Smart Connect is initially aimed only at business customers. The basic version can be used on any voice phone from any wireless provider as long as the customer has Embarq service for the business landline, with calls being transferred between the two handsets with the press of a button. The more expensive Smart Connect Plus transfers the calls seamlessly using a dual-mode phone, but requires the purchase of Embarq’s most expensive device, the UTStarcom Pocket PC 6700, which retails for $570. Prices for Smart Connect range from $15 to $20 per month, while Smart Connect Plus will cost customers $20 to $25 a month.