Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 July 2007

Globalstar at odds with WiMAX in battle to relax 2.5GHz spectrum rules

The long neglected US bands between 2.3GHz and 2.5GHz are increasingly seen as beachfront spectrum, and as the various candidates to offer mobile broadband services sharpen their weapons, so the disputes over frequency rights are heating up too. The latest centers on a bid by satellite operator Globalstar to have restrictions on its use of its 2.5GHz licenses removed, a claim that is fiercely opposed by the WiMAX community. The company’s CEO James Monroe bitterly attacked the FCC last week for long delays in addressing a petition that was originally made a year ago, saying this was hobbling potential business decisions and going against US government calls to turn underused spectrum to help in efforts against terrorist and natural disasters.

For WiMAX, 2.5GHz is the most attractive and plentiful spectrum in the US and will drive its hopes of becoming the leading mobile broadband standard in the country, through the build-outs of Sprint Nextel, Clearwire and others. Sprint and the WiMAX Forum, then, are among the parties opposing Globalstar’s request that the FCC remove a ban on its using ATC (ancillary terrestrial component, which supports hybrid satellite/terrestrial services) in most of its spectrum in 2483.5MHz-2500MHz. They claim that allowing ATC, rather than satellite-only as is currently the case, would cause interference with broadband wireless networks around 2.5GHz.

Globalstar says these claims are false, and that it can only gain a level playing field if it is allowed to use ATC, as are its main mobile satellite rivals, MSV, Terrestar and Craig McCaw’s ICO, which operate in the less restricted 2GHz band, and gained new spectrum allocations last year in order to build out ATC and stimulate new mobile satellite services. (Currently, Globalstar can only use ATC in about 5.5MHz of its downlink band – see inset). By introducing a terrestrial element, ATC supports far better economics than other systems, and allows satellite operators more easily to roam or integrate with cellular or WiMAX services. MSV is the major patent holder in ATC and is working with Boeing on its network, and with Nortel on WiMAX/ATC integration; while ICO is working with Alcatel-Lucent on a hybrid platform for mobile television, using the French giant’s favored technology, DVB-SH.

A victory for Globalstar would put it in a better position to make its own alliance with a broadband wireless operator or vendor, in a world where combining satellite and terrestrial spectrum and business models will increasingly be a feature of the move to convergence. A partnership with a mobile satellite provider can bring a larger operator additional spectrum plus specific capabilities in emergency response and rural access. Some broadband wireless companies are also joining forces with satellite broadcasters, as the Clearwire tie-up with Echostar and DirecTV – which could, in future, also involve Clearwire stablemate ICO – demonstrates. On its own, the mobile satellite model still looks non-viable in advanced economies outside the public safety sector and some rural niches, although Globalstar has been looking for large investments in new fleets, encouraged by double-digit revenue growth in its security and government agency sectors. It is about a year into the $1.2bn design and construction of its second generation constellation.

The Wireless Communications Association, as reported by RCRNews, has responded to Globalstar’s calls for relaxed rulings, saying MSS-ATC operations in the band would cause harmful interference to wireless broadband licensees. It was supported by the WiMAX Forum, Sprint Nextel, the cellcos’ association CTIA, the Society of Broadcast Engineers and Globalstar competitor Iridium Satellite (which, unlike its rival, does not have the capability to integrate ATC into its current satellite fleet and so would be disadvantaged by a ruling in favor of Globalstar). ‘There is no equity in exposing BRS [Broadband Radio Services] to even a possibility that they will be at greater risk of suffering interference from ATC,’ the WCA told the FCC. ‘It should be obvious even to Globalstar that the process of transitioning markets, designing networks and launching new BRS services cannot proceed smoothly within the required deadlines if ATC operations already occupy the spectrum to which BRS licenses are being transitioned.’

Globalstar badly needs a way to leap ahead of its competitors in this increasingly crowded market where, despite the boost from enhanced emergency response activities, there will not be room in the long term for all six operators in the US (as well as the ATC trio, Globalstar competes more directly with Iridium and Inmarsat). The company had a headstart in upgrading its fleet following an IPO in 2005, but shook investors last year with a warning that there could be a hiatus in services as it transitioned its fleet. Globalstar has the most attractive handset size and service cost in the US, but revealed in an SEC filing in February that its low earth orbit (LEO) satellites would be unable to support two-way voice services until “some time in 2008” – and by then, Inmarsat and ICO will have launched directly competitive voice services, with Terrestar also looming. Globalstar derives the vast majority of its revenues from providing two-way voice services in North America and has a roughly 80% market share of the 150,000 MSS voice handsets in use in the region. Faced with the prospect that current satellites might no longer be able to support voice services by some time in 2008, and that these services would remain largely unavailable until a new constellation is launched in 2009-2010, it could lose share rapidly, especially as the ATC players will offer fairly small, low cost handsets.

Globalstar’s spectrum:

Globalstar is unique among the ATC proponents in that its spectrum allocation is not balanced between uplink and downlink frequencies. While it has access to 11.35MHz of spectrum on the uplink (1610-1621.35MHz), it is licensed for 16.5MHz of spectrum on the downlink (2483.5-2500MHz), although it has to date only been licensed to use 5.5MHz of spectrum in each direction for ATC. It has applied to the FCC for permission to use its entire licensed spectrum allocation for ATC, subject to non-interference with other systems. It seems likely that Globalstar will be unable to use much more than about 5MHz of its uplink spectrum for ATC, whereas it could potentially devote at least 10MHz of downlink spectrum to ATC. (The limits on the amount in play are to allow for guard bands to avoid interference with Iridium on parts of its uplink, and for separation distances of around 100 miles for radioastronomy sites in spectrum below 1613.8MHz; also, Globalstar currently reserves 2.5MHz of spectrum for simplex data services and at least two of its 1.23MHz channels for voice services. At S-band Globalstar will not be able to use the 2495-2500MHz band for ATC deploymen, once relocated broadband wireless (BRS) services begin to use this band, although this may prove not to be a factor in rural areas.)

Given the large frequency separation between Globalstar’s uplink and downlink bands and the relatively high frequency of its S-band allocation, which would all add to terrestrial network build-out cost, satellite analysts TMF believe the best option for Globalstar to develop a mass market ATC application would be to offer broadcast services using only its S-band downlink frequencies. This would lower the value of its spectrum assets, compared to the valuation they would attract if used for broadband wireless – radio and television licenses carry far lower value than cellular bands such as AWS. For instance, XM paid $90m and Sirius paid $83m for their allocations of 12.5MHz of spectrum each in 1997 and MediaFLO and Modeo were both able to acquire near-national spectrum for their mobile TV networks for very modest sums. On the other hand, mobile broadcast spectrum is becoming very sought after in other regions of the world, such as Asia, where several players are looking to deploy S-band mobile TV networks.

The IPO represented the return of Globalstar to the public market after its bankruptcy in 2002. It was founded in 1993 by Lorel and Qualcomm and borrowed heavily to launch its initial fleet of satellites in the late 1990s. By 2001, it was swamped in debt and a lack of revenues and customers and filed for bankruptcy in early 2002. Creditors now own a chunk of the new Globalstar, while equity holders of the old Globalstar lost their entire investment although it remains the only satellite operator to use Qualcomm CDMA technology, and its former stakeholder is the only manufacturer of terminals for its GSAT service, and recently unveiled new voice/data models at one-third of the weight and cost of previous units. Globalstar has contracted with Alcatel to build 48 new satellites by 2013, delivering the first batch in 2008-9, with a total cost budgeted at $1bn. It also plans to invest $2-$3bn in its ATC network, even if the FCC does not allow it more capacity there.