Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 July 2007

Vodafone could drive harder bargain than AT&T for iPhone rights

Queues formed outside the US Apple and AT&T stores last Friday as iPhone frenzy reached fever pitch on the much-hyped handset’s launch day, and initial reviews were generally positive, suggesting Apple could surpass its sales targets despite the high price of the unit. But while Apple loyalists fought to get their hands on a device, the battles that will really make or break the company’s fortunes in a harsh new market are still in progress – notably which operator will take the product into Europe, and under what conditions. Vodafone is emerging as the front runner – unsurprisingly, given its market reach – but it may have more cards on the table in negotiating with Apple than AT&T did.

At first glance, it seems that Apple might have an easier time in Europe than the US, where AT&T had the bargaining advantage of being by far the largest GSM carrier. Verizon Wireless may have famously backed away from the iPhone, but a deal with a CDMA carrier would have been tough for Apple too, forcing it to make a version of the handset for that network as well as for international GSM, and therefore to get involved with Qualcomm. However, AT&T could not really afford to let the iPhone slip away, especially with the threat that the rejuvenated T-Mobile might use it to lever its ambitious growth plans (and potentially sign a cross-border deal involving its sister companies in Europe). So AT&T agreed to an agreement with Apple that is unprecedented in north America in terms of the control and revenue share it gives the device maker, and a setback for the general operator push to grasp the balance of power with the phonemakers (see Wireless Watch June 11 2007).

In that battle of wills, AT&T may well have seen support for Apple as a way to sideline Nokia, especially with Motorola failing, in the past year, to come up with a suitably iconic homegrown handset to lead its charge for customers. Apple may have huge brand power, but it has none of the influence on the wireless industry of Nokia, which is engaged in something of a stand-off with the US’ leading cellco.

While Vodafone would also happily weaken Nokia’s power, especially as the Finnish giant is on the ascendant in the wireless power struggle right now, it is less likely than AT&T to do so by giving away key control to another potential thorn in its side. The company is the most powerful negotiator in the business because of its huge scale, and – along with the Asian majors whose upper hand against the phonemakers it would like to emulate – leads the charge for operators to drive the industry. The kind of coordinated marketing and promotion that Vodafone could bring the iPhone across different territories would be a major lure for Apple.

Vodafone, whose share price was rising all last week on anticipation that it would win the Apple deal, will have to be careful not to be too aggressive and play into the hands of other bidders such as T-Mobile, Orange and Telefonica O2, all of which have greater track records in generating customers and ARPU from high profile support for stylish, if low volume, units. Losing the deal to one of these rivals – especially if a multiyear exclusive is on offer, as in the US – would hit Vodafone’s share price hard, at a time when it badly needs to win some brownie points with its disgruntled investors. In a research note last week, Credit Suisse said: ‘The winner could sell more than 6m such devices over the next three years. Assuming half these were new customers, this could add 8p to our valuation if Vodafone were to win.’ The phone is predicted to retail at about €450 when it launches in Europe at the end of the year.

It is not only the carriers that stand to gain profile and revenues from snagging an Apple exclusive. There is also heated speculation over the identity of the iPhone’s component suppliers, with Marvell, in particular, seeing heavy trading and a stock rise of 5.8% on rumors that it provides key chips. One analyst estimated that such a deal for the iPhone could equate to a 7% increase in Marvell’s sales in 2008, despite the relatively small volume targets – compared to those of mainstream phonemakers – for the Apple device. Marvell is looking for major expansion in the handset space, following its acquisition of Intel’s XScale line, and the Apple talk is certainly helping to raise its profile during a critical transition period. Apart from multiple ARM cores, other components of the iPhone have not been confirmed, despite intense speculation, although Broadcom and Samsung have been widely tipped.

While operators, chipmakers and other elements of the Apple ecosystem will be keen to generate momentum from the almost guaranteed initial success of such as well promoted and brand-driven item, the real question is how Apple can sustain the performance for long enough to become a serious player in high end handsets, as these become an essential part of the overall consumer electronics revenue mix. It has no track record in this industry, and faces a wealth of competitors with greater knowledge of the phone sector and an almost equal commitment to branding – notably, in Europe in particular, Sony Ericsson with its Walkman and Cybershot models and the potential of the PSP handset. A research note from consultancy Accenture points out that when Apple launched the iPod, it was into a nascent market in which digital music downloads were still illegal, so the device was able to be a ‘market definer’. This role will not be open to the iPhone, which is not doing anything new in the handset market, with the exception of some useful and attractive navigation techniques, many of which, however, will be emulated by other devices, notably the LG Prada. Accenture refers to the cellphone market as ‘brutally competitive, very advanced, occupied and established’, saying that Apple is making ‘a big bet’.

This is undoubtedly true, and as the initial frenzy surrounding the iPhone dies down and it settles down to compete in earnest, it will be increasingly dependent on the operators to sustain the momentum behind the product and keep it at the top of their catalogs. This is where the risk of the multiyear exclusive comes in of course – as Nokia increasingly relies on direct channels, and seeks to take control of the marketing and channels for its brands and devices, Apple could, in a worst case, be stuck with selling only through two or three carriers worldwide, which may have turned their attentions to other, newer attractions by late 2008, when it would be looking for real volume. The iPhone brand will go a long way to retain operator commitment and interest, but Apple will also need to ensure that it keeps enhancing the product to keep it in a market leading position, and to build up a strong developer community, which is likely to mean, certainly a year or so from now, compromising some key tenets and opening up the platform entirely.

The US launch:

The service plan for the AT&T iPhone requires a two-year contract, starting at $60 a month. All the plans include a chunk of voice, unlimited data and the new scrolling feature for voicemail. The $60 gets 450 minutes of cellular voice a month, while consumers will pay $80 for 900 minutes and $100 for 1,350 minutes.

One of the neatest add-ins is that the devices can be bought and registered online through iTunes, where they can also be synced for music and multimedia files.

At the same time last minute details were slipping out through the developer community, confirming that Apple will not support Adobe Flash, but will use QuickTime and its generic H.264 codec for all video, and it will use an Apple version of PDF code, not Acrobat. Also that the Safari browser only keeps eight web pages in memory at one time, the phone will have no Java and when video plays on a web page, the phone will automatically leap to full-screen playback. The iPhone will use a pinch finger command to shrink content, a double-tap to zoom it and the screen will allow two-fingered scrolling.

Devices will be in everyone’s hands by this time next week, and we should expect the first reliable teardowns, from taking a device apart and looking at all the components.

AT&T also reinforced its high profile launch by tweaking the speeds on its EDGE network, the fastest available to the non-3G iPhone. User site Gizmondo listed improved speeds of 200Kbps, up from 40Kbps just a day or two before. AT&T Mobility’s head of media relations, Mark Siegel, said: ‘We’ve done a lot to improve EDGE and make it ‘i’ ready.’. He claimed that the lack of 3G support is not a problem because EDGE has far greater coverage than any 3G option in the US. AT&T is said to have invested $50m recently in upgrading EDGE data capacity, aiming to counter the fears that the advanced features advertised for the iPhone will be virtually unusable over non-3G links. The carrier claims the device has been optimized for EDGE and supports fast downloading even at speeds around 200Kbps because of techniques such as advanced caching, which avoids screen building.

Other news accompanying the launch included support for the YouTube video sharing site, whose owner Google has begun encoding its videos in the H.264 format to improve quality and save battery life when viewed on wireless devices. Apple claims that its phones will be the first equipped to use the new format and that over 10,000 videos will be available to iPhone users at launch, with the entire catalog available by the end of the third quarter. The iPhone will include a built-in Apple designed YouTube application.