Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 July 2007

Pulse~link’s lawsuit against Tzero could spark wider UWB battles

On June 12 US chip start-up Tzero, which focuses on high definition video over UltraWideBand (UWB), launched a product offering communication over both wireless and coax links. While we thought, isn’t that what fellow UWB start-up Pulse~link did a couple of years ago?, Pulse~link itself reached straight for its lawyers.

The legal action was announced last week and promises to kick off a legal battle over intellectual property rights across UWB, which is seen by Intel and much of the consumer electronics industry as a bright hope for high speed home media networks.
Underlying Pulse~link’s complaint is that it is not being left alone to plough its own furrow, after having its technology ignored by the WiMedia Alliance, a collection of companies that is setting the primary UWB-based standards (including Wireless USB), and is led by Intel and Texas Instruments. Tzero is in this camp, but Pulse~link claims that, unlike the other companies that fly under the WiMedia banner, Tzero is trying to invade its space – specializing in connecting televisions together with UWB over a variety of media, both wired and wireless, to form a high definition home communications network.

While Pulse~link accepts that it can’t really sue Tzero just for coming after the same business applications, it believes it can fall back on its 300-strong list of patents, some granted, some applied for, that see it dominating the intellectual property arena around UWB. The particular patent that it has dusted off and aimed squarely at Tzero is US patent number 6,970,448, which describes a way for two separate slave transceivers, operating in different bandwidths with different data rates, to be controlled by a third transceiver by use of timed command slots, which are capable of UWB communications up and down the spectrum. This appears to relate to one of the core methods for controlling multiple devices around a home that might suddenly want to broadcast huge amounts of data, like a video stream from a set-top to a TV, for instance. It talks about multiple orchestrated TDMA carriers and articulates in detail how similar technologies have been used in the past, for instance for satellite transmission, but which had various limitations that the Pulse~link patents get around. Pulse~link claims that, although Tzero uses WiMedia’s MultiBand OFDM as the basis for its technology, it must have used some of the Pulse~link patents in order to achieve what it claims in its latest press release.

Pulse~link’s President Bruce Watkins wants to make it clear that the company has often offered its patents for inclusion industry standards, but has never been taken up on its offer. As a result Tzero takes the stance that Pulse~link, despite inventing many core elements in UWB transmission technology, is the outsider and the only proprietary offering in the market. Watkins is very clear that he does not want an across the board legal battle with Intel, TI or the huge array of adopters, contributors and promoters that make up the WiMedia Alliance, which include Alereon, HP, Kodak, Microsoft, Nokia, NXP, Samsung, Sony and STMicro.

To avoid this, Pulse~link does seem to have picked a patent that differentiates Tzero from the rest of the WiMedia Alliance. Most WiMedia members are chasing the markets being created in Bluetooth and USB, where both standards committees have chosen the WiMedia technology as a basis for future generations, and which center on very short distance links. By contrast, Tzero and Pulse~link have focused on Lan distance UWB.

Watkins said: ‘This is only about Tzero. We really are trying to get along positively within our industry. We are engaged with several prominent WiMedia member companies for our specific market applications, and so we value and want to maintain positive community relationships.’

Watkins added: ‘Technically speaking, and from a patent standpoint, often there are a very limited number of technical pathways to overcome a particular problem. If you are the very first to tackle a problem that forms the basis of a new business idea, you are often the first to see all the ways that problem can be tackled. This opens an opportunity to file patents on applicable technical solutions that enable the very foundations of a new business idea.’

Despite its impressive patents stock, Pulse~link does not want to become an IPR-only business, and is building its Cwave chips to offer speeds of above 1Gbps both through the air and over coax. The company spearheaded a seven-year battle to convince the US regulator, the FCC, that UWB signals are beneath the noise floor of other communications, and so do not interfere with them. Since the FCC has given in on this point, the market has been invaded by other players, and regulators in Europe, China and Japan are all working in parallel to get to the point where UWB signals are allowed in those territories. This is significantly upping the stakes in the commercial UWB battle, as the WiMedia players start to roll out their first silicon.

Pulse~link was the first to demonstrate UWB over wired channels such as coax when much of the UWB industry scoffed at the idea and it also showed wireless HDMI using JPEG2000 in the summer of 2005. While it gets government and military business now, its main chance to grow as a company is to become the high volume transmission technology of choice for the digital home, for sending either uncompressed video signals between devices or for ultra-high speed transmission of video to portable devices and handsets.

This is where it will start to run into the WiMedia Alliance and its CE giant backers, such as Sony, which contributed significantly to the OFDM-based platform. ‘In our technical opinion the OFDM-UWB approach won’t ultimately work adequately to accomplish what we perceive to be the necessary performance required to successfully enable the market we pursue’ [in local digital video delivery], said Watkins.

UWB is also up against line of sight systems in 60GHz (see separate item), an area in which Toshiba recently made the critical breakthrough of implementing the technology in low cost CMOS rather than commercially prohibitive gallium arsenide. Since the IEEE failed to break a stalemate on UWB proposals for its 802.15.3a standard – with the WiMedia Alliance subsequently taking its technology off to be endorsed by another standards body, ECMA, instead – 60GHz has gained a higher profile as a potential IEEE-backed system for high speed digital home networks.

What Tzero and its WiMedia partners do next will really decide what will happen on the UWB front in this critical high speed personal transmission market. If Tzero just fights its corner, it will be a small news item and it will get resolved, probably with some form of out of court settlement. But if the WiMedia Alliance backs its member and wades in heavy handed, supporting its right to take the Multiband OFDM technology wherever it likes, then the UWB wars could get messy all over again, this time in the courts. Tzero’s most powerful friend is Samsung, with which it has worked on HANA (High Definition Audio-Video Network Alliance) technology, as has Pulse~link. The fact that the UWB digital home market could end up as a multi-billion device chip business, affecting the capabilities of every consumer electronics device, is bound to attract some powerful vested interests, and may make it impossible for Pulse~link to ringfence its current legal actions and keep them away from the machinations of the giants.

This analysis was first published in our sister publication, Faultline, which provides weekly insights into key trends and technologies in broadband digital media and the economics of the quad play. For more information, please email Peter White on [email protected].