Combining unequalled price aggression with massive growth potential, India is the market where we see the equipment majors testing their most creative strategies to gain a share of the huge territory without driving margins through the floor ‘ techniques that will then be applied to other emerging economies and even to developed ones. Ericsson, notably at BSNL, has focused on combining managed services with infrastructure to offer the latter at a knockdown price while gaining new levels of account control.
This is a technique that will be emulated by Nokia Siemens, which is also focusing on local manufacturing chains and low cost base station formats. Huawei is turning the cost efficiencies it developed at home in China to gain advantage in India, most recently with a $200m GSM/CDMA expansion deal with Reliance Communications.
Alcatel-Lucent took the other portion of that contract, with its share worth $400m, and is hoping to rely on its strengths across the convergence board to bolster its margins in India as that country starts to edge towards all-IP. Since the acquisition of Lucent, it is far more valuable for the French giant that India is a two-technology nation, since it gives it an advantage over the other Europeans with their GSM/UMTS-only portfolios. So it is to Alcatel’s benefit that Reliance, one of the world’s largest CDMA buyers, is pulling back on plans to convert entirely to GSM. Of course, the company that gains even more from that turn of events is Qualcomm, which last week was parading a new entente cordiale with Reliance, and an unexpected expansion of the carrier’s CDMA infrastructure.
The change of heart was partially forced upon Reliance by its own regulator’s failure to give it new GSM spectrum, so that it has to expand its current networks in order to take advantage of exploding mobile uptake in India. But it has also been enabled by a series of actions on Qualcomm’s part, which may well reflect the way that the CDMA giant manages to introduce new flexibility into its licensing practises, without publicly backing down from its business model.
Reliance had planned to spend $7bn on a GSM network in new spectrum, which would take its coverage across all 23 telecoms regions of India and make its parallel CDMA system largely redundant. However, the country’s Department of Telecom is reviewing license conditions as it tries to deal with a shortage of spectrum in the country, and is unwilling to encourage carriers to run separate national networks. With the new allocations on hold, Reliance will instead spend $740m over the coming two years on adding capacity to its eight-region GSM network and national CDMA system.
To the latter, it will double the number of lines to 70m ‘ it currently has 30.5m customers on this network. This is a significant positive sign for Qualcomm, which has been besieged by talk of major carriers deserting the CDMA platform, with Reliance being one of the most high profile examples. The chipmaker has worked hard to keep Reliance onside, especially since last year, when the carrier complained that royalty fees made the CDMA network less cost-effective than GSM because of handset prices, and that Qualcomm was charging higher fees in India than in other countries such as China.
Hence the new flexibility in Qualcomm’s licensing ‘ while not reducing the royalties, it has agreed to share technology and provide licenses to equipment vendors so they can manufacture handsets in India and bring down prices. The first result of this compromise is that Reliance has created a joint venture with Cal-Comp of Taiwan to manufacture CDMA handsets in India. The plant will open next year and Reliance has increased its order with the manufacturer from 3m to 12m units ‘ which will no doubt be sufficiently cheap that they will bring down the average price of CDMA handsets and work again to support the Qualcomm marketing message that CDMA is a cost effective technology for emerging markets.
CEO Paul Jacobs met Reliance chairman Anil Ambani in Mumbai to set the seal on the year-long negotiations, and also met with another major Indian CDMA operator, Tata Teleservices. The companies would not comment on royalty structures, but another of the Jacobs clan, executive vice president Jeffrey Jacobs, commented: ‘We never had any royalty issues; the company’s (Reliance’s) issue was that of the price gap between GSM and CDMA handsets. We have successfully addressed this issue’.
The new build-out by Reliance is mainly to address rural areas, where handset cost is particularly sensitive. According to the CDMA Development Group, since a 2003 ruling by the Indian Supreme Court that opened the market for CDMA to compete with rival GSM technology, CDMA has captured 47m, or 27%, of the country’s 178m mobile subscribers, but a shortage of 800MHz and 1.9GHz spectrum is inhibiting CDMA expansion in urban areas.