NTT DoCoMo’s dreams of making its i-Mode content platform a global standard now appear to be dead, with the UK’s O2 and Australia’s Telstra both dropping the offering after poor uptake, and others likely to follow. While wildly successful in Japan, i-Mode was launched too late and half-heartedly elsewhere to make significant inroads on Java-based systems and on major brands like Vodafone Live! Now its main hopes of international success lie, as for many standards of Asian origin (see separate item on mobile TV) in China, and the increasing pan-Asian collaboration on future multimedia platforms ‘ although this approach also suffered a major setback in May when a deal with India’s Hutchison Essar was cancelled in the wake of Vodafone’s takeover.
The decision by Telef’nica-owned O2 to drop i-Mode comes as no surprise after it decided in March to defer its German roll-out for an unspecified period. At that time, an O2 spokesperson said that the company was standing by its commitment to i-Mode and insisted that the technology was ‘performing in line with our expectations’ ‘ but then added that the i-Mode strategy was ‘under review’.
While the operator tried to downplay the German decision as largely one of branding (it would have to use another name, since KPN already offers i-Mode in the country), there was clearly a more fundamental problem with the content services platform. It had provided O2 with a useful quick route to multimedia applications as it waited for the right time to launch full 3G ‘ a decision it took more cautiously than many rivals ‘ and i-Mode was announced with much fanfare in 2005 in the UK and Ireland, accompanied by O2’s largest ever marketing campaign. However, i-Mode could only remain strategic if it retained the early lead it had over content platforms ‘ which it has failed to do ‘ and if handsets were attractive and cheap. Instead, the declining prospect of i-Mode becoming a global system have defocused attention on compatible handsets, and so prices have remained relatively high, and units clumsy. O2 is to stop selling i-Mode handsets on July 31 and will continue to support the service for two years after that, though it will encourage subscribers to move to newer mobile internet services, notably its Active portal, which is available on over 200 O2 handsets, compared with i-Mode’s 12. Its first move in this direction already happened last year, when the carrier ended free access to its internet offerings on i-Mode, and a far greater fillip will be seen when O2 launches its iPhone web services later this year (especially if Apple has come up with a 3G version for the carrier by then).
‘The service has proven to be successful with rich content and high satisfaction amongst users,’ O2 said in a statement. ‘However, a limited range of devices has restricted its growth and we don’t see that changing. I-Mode is part of the evolution of the mobile internet but not the end point.’
This is particularly evident in the carrier model. In the early days of WAP, i-Mode was hailed as a system that supported broad developer support, because in its model, content providers keep the bulk of the content revenue, leaving the operator to depend on charging for data network usage. But in the rapid move towards flat rate mobile internet, that will become unsustainable for operators.
Although i-Mode is very successful in Japan, where it has over 47m users (81% of the DoCoMo subscriber base), it has not fulfilled its parent’s hopes of gaining Europe-wide acceptance, although it has been adopted by a range of operators such as KPN of Holland and France’s Bouyges. In the UK and Ireland O2 has 550,000 i-Mode subscribers, 3% of the total mobile base. In the 15 non-Japanese countries in which i-Mode is currently offered, user take-up has been muted, with a mere 7m subscribers across territories such as Australia, Belgium, France, Holland and Russia. Its flagship adopter, AT&T Mobile, which launched i-Mode under the mmode brand in the US, is now part of the Cingular (or AT&T Mobility mark two) internet roll-out, and now Australia will also fall off that list, with incumbent Telstra also deciding to drop the system in favor of own-branded 3G services with a broader choice of handsets and content partners. Telstra posted the news on its web site, informing users that it will kill its i-Mode service in December. Existing prepaid i-Mode subscribers can use their credits for other offerings; other users are encouraged to sign up for Telstra’s Next G mobile internet service.
Most crushingly for DoCoMo’s hopes of setting international standards is the loss of an important agreement for i-Mode with Hutchison Essar of India, which is now a casualty of that operator’s takeover by Vodafone. This dashes hopes of gaining a major base for i-Mode in India, expected to be the fastest growing market for mobile internet services in the coming few years.
Remaining i-Mode carriers are Wind in Italy, Cellcom in Israel, MTS in Russia, Cosmote in Greece, Starhub in Singapore, Far EasTone in Taiwan, BASE in Belgium, KPN in the Netherlands and Germany, Bouygues in France and DoCoMo itself. The service is soon to be launched in Hong Kong, Macao and the Philippines by Hutchison and in the future DoCoMo says it plans to have the service up and running in a total of 26 countries.
i-Mode’s history:
In its early years, i-Mode was a competitor to the industry standard WAP (Wireless Application Protocol) mobile web approach, but the two have since converged – as is often the case with Asian advanced technologies, their owners start by seeking to set their own standards, and end up bowing to the weight of numbers of the US and European bodies and contributing their IPR to the common cause – but not before they have secured a highly influential position in the standards efforts and among the operators.
So, i-Mode had huge success in Japan after it was launched in 1999, because of its usability, multimedia facilities and its open source model, which attracted legions of developers. But in Japan, it was launched early (in February 1999) and into the world’s most advanced mobile phone user base, and was dramatically different from anything else on offer, far more attractive than WAP.
By the time it reached Europe from 2002, it was slow to win operator support or sufficiently attractive handset models. This delay meant that it entered a market where WAP 2.0, which looked to solve many of the problems of its predecessor and close the gap on i-Mode, was becoming well established among developers and underpinning major early mobile internet services like Vodafone’s Live! Customers were also confused by the need to purchase separate subscriptions for i-Mode voice and data. In territories with both services, Live! was gaining 4-5 times more new subscriptions in 2003 than i-Mode based offerings.
All this was addressed with the creation of the XHTML mobile internet mark-up language, which converged i-Mode and WAP/WML (Wireless Mark-Up Language) into a common architecture. XHTML is a presentation standard defined by the World Wide Web Consortium as a successor to HTML 4.0. A Mobile Profile – XHTML MP – was added by W3C, largely the work of NTT DoCoMo and the WAP Forum, which wanted to combine the features of WML, XHTML Basic and i-Mode to create a platform that would serve all their users and developers. They then added the features of WML that could not be found in XHTML. These included navigation aids, contexts and other features. The combined XHTML Mobile Profile plus these features is WML2, which also includes some WAP extensions for backwards compatibility. This advance brought i-Mode into the international mainstream, and also gave DoCoMo a controlling grip on the creation of new standards, and an easier route into mainstream operator contracts round the world.