The Next Generation Mobile Networks (NGMN) Alliance, founded as a vehicle to increase operators’ influence on future standards and policies, has cemented its rising influence by signing some of the world’s largest wireless vendors. It is also starting to make its presence felt, with new proposals for intellectual property rights (IPR) and the evolving 802.16m WIMAX standard.
The NGMN Alliance was set up by Vodafone, Sprint, T-Mobile, Orange, KPN, NTT DoCoMo and China Mobile in June 2006 and its new backers are Alcatel-Lucent, Cisco, Ericsson, Intel, Motorola, Nokia, Nokia Siemens Networks, Nortel, Qualcomm and Texas Instruments, representing most of the heavyweights of the sector, with the notable exception of the Asians such as Samsung and Huawei. Although Japan and Korea already have a more operator-driven model, it will be essential to win support from these giants if the NGMN is to ensure that its approaches to global issues such as IPR are adopted worldwide.
The new IPR agreement, announced last week by the Alliance, embodies one of the group’s key aims ‘ to make the knotty issues of royalties and licensing more unified and transparent throughout the industry in the 4G stage, therefore removing the threat to operators of unexpected costs and even legal actions, arising from companies claiming IP rights that had not been declared upfront. Standards bodies such as ETSI are now moving to enforce upfront declaration of patent claims, and NGMN also favors this. The body has always argued that standards bodies have failed to come up with any effective way of managing IPR claims and management, with the usual ‘reasonable and non-discriminatory’ mantra being vague and open to the kind of debates that are currently being fought in the law courts and antitrust offices (see Wireless Watch July 17 2006).
The Alliance says it has achieved consensus among all its members on future IPR guidelines, which would force notification of any patent claims prior to the finalization of a standard, enabling an estimate to be made of cumulative IPR cost in any platform. “NGMN has reached an unprecedented agreement with global technology providers to receive notifications of proposed IPR terms for next generation technologies. This chosen approach will create an environment of increased investment and innovation, thus accelerating adoption of mobile broadband services. We look forward to expanding our relationship into many new areas over years to come,” chairman Hamid Akhavan said in a statement.
While the Alliance may need to court Samsung, in particular, as a major holder of IPR in pre-4G systems such as WiMAX, it at least has scored the notable goal of gaining public support from Qualcomm, often seen as the major obstacle to new IPR policies. Andrew Gilbert, president of Qualcomm Europe, said: “The NGMN IPR agreement is unique in our industry and Qualcomm commends all the companies that have participated in agreeing to the NGMN disclosure policy and more transparency regarding potential overall costs for technologies beyond 3G, such as LTE, UMB, and WiMAX.”
Meanwhile, the NGMN continues to define its proposed architecture for 4G systems, aiming to set down certain guidelines to which all potential 4G technologies should conform, and which would achieve key operator goals such as interoperability and lower device costs.
The guidelines are, however, heavily skewed to the interests of existing cellcos, particularly as regards spectrum. Compatibility with existing networks and bands is important to the Alliance, and fits with one of its other major activities, lobbying for cellular operators to be able to hold on to existing GSM and other frequencies, and reuse them for future technologies, rather than facing renewed auctions. Such issues are clearly of interest to current 3G carriers, but work against the opposite view of 4G ‘ that it should not merely represent a far faster and richer version of current cellular networks, but should encourage a whole new set of disruptive operators with innovative business models, leveraging all-IP networks and the host of devices these will support. This vision, as evinced by Intel, Google and the rest of the internet community, involves a far more flexible approach to spectrum, which will not sit well with NGMN.
This could bring it into conflict with other industry groups, and WiMAX could be the first battleground because it is seen as a maverick standard with wide support from non-traditional cellular players. The NGMN Alliance recently sent ‘liaison statements’ to the IEEE’s 802.16 Working Group requesting that the group consider its network recommendations and its
Performance Evaluation Methodology while developing the next iteration of the standard, 802.16m ‘ requests that will be considered at the group’s next meeting in September. While no standard-in-waiting would be rash enough to ignore the wishes of the world’s largest cellcos, it will be a real test of the NGMN Alliance’s influence ‘ and its bid to be the leading driver of 4G standards and models ‘ as to how prominently its proposals figure in the 802.16m platform as it evolves in the politically charged IEEE committees. A far more meaningful test, of course, will be the results of lobbying of regulators as to next generation spectrum ‘ a battle that will engage the Alliance initially in the US’ 700MHz and Europe’s 2.5GHz debates. Signing Intel and Qualcomm to the same body may be a rare achievement, but far greater challenges lie ahead.
The NGMN architecture:
The guiding principles, as set out last year, are:
‘ High levels of data throughput alongside low levels of latency
‘ Low operation and maintenance costs
‘ Compatibility with legacy networks
‘ Support of high levels of authentication and security, and differentiated quality of service
‘ Improved terminal certification schemes
‘ Plus, a more transparent intellectual property regime