Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 July 2007

EC threatens DVB-H mandate but T-DMB supporters remain defiant

While the European Commission made the hardly unexpected move of officially endorsing DVB-H as the mobile TV standard of choice for the region, the rival standards remain defiant. As expected (see Wireless Watch July 2 2007) the European Commission has backed the standard whose creation it helped to fund, and whose premier backer is Nokia, one of Europe’s favourite children. In backing DVB-H as the standard for mobile TV services across all 27 EU member states, the Commission has turned its back on the technology neutrality it is favoring for upcoming mobile broadband spectrum auctions, in the interests of rapid roll-out and cross-region interoperability, which should encourage low cost devices.

The EU’s telecoms commissioner, Viviane Reding, said last week that member states should roll out mobile TV services based solely on DVB-H ‘as soon as possible’, provoking a storm of criticism ‘ particularly from Qualcomm, which pushes its own MediaFLO standard ‘ that the EC should let the market decide on the technology, and has no mandate to recommend standards. Others argued that mandating one standard could reduce open market competition and disadvantage those forced to use an alternative technology because of lack of spectrum.

Reding harked back to the world headstart that Europe gained by standardizing on GSM (carefully ignoring the disaster that resulted from a similar insistence on a single standard, UMTS, for 3G spectrum). She said: ‘We can either take the lead globally – as we did for mobile telephony based on the GSM standard developed by the European industry – or allow other regions to take the lion’s share of the promised mobile TV market. Wait and see is not an option.’ The EC estimates that the mobile TV market could reach some 500m people and be worth €20bn by 2011.

Although, so far, the EC has only added DVB-H to its list of approved standards, which does not constitute a mandate, it has made it clear that a mandate could follow. It will also urge member states to make spectrum available for mobile TV in the UHF band (470MHz to 862MHz) as quickly as possible as Europe switches from analog to digital TV. As with roaming and other telecoms issues, the aggressive Reding has made it clear that, if operators do not follow the EC line, she would be willing to impose DVB-H adoption in 2008.

‘The Commission is not choosing a winner. The market in Europe is already largely in favor of DVB-H. Unlike Austria, the Commission is so far not mandating a single technology by legislation, but instead gives the market the clear signal that she should move voluntarily but quickly to a single standard,’ the EC statements added. ‘DVB-H offers an opportunity for mobile TV services to develop the economies of scale they need for uptake across Europe and globally. A common standard provides certainty concerning technological decisions, avoids the risk of market fragmentation and enables economies of scale which will result in lower prices for consumers and faster take-up. Interoperability remains an important objective.’

Reacting to the EC decision, the FLO Forum ‘ the official industry body behind the Qualcomm MediaFLO platform ‘ issued a statement saying: ‘The FLO Forum believes that the intention of favoring any one particular mobile TV technology for Europe could stall the advancement of a healthy European mobile TV ecosystem.’ The group behind the T-DMB alternative said: ‘Members of WorldDMB continue to be mystified by the Commission’s unilateral support of DVB-H’.

Even the operators’ interest group, GSM Europe, was hesitant. Carriers are in a dilemma here ‘ a single standard could help them with cheaper handsets and greater vendor activity, but they have been fighting hard to take the whip hand in setting standards, rather than the equipment makers ‘ and the EC’s view appears to reduce that power, shifting it back to vendors and to committees. Some operators are also worried that they may not be able to access DVB-H spectrum in good time, an issue that is particularly thorny in the UK. ‘It’s too early to designate a single technology,’ said Eirini Zafeiratou, director of GSM Europe. ‘We embrace all sorts of technologies.’

Meanwhile, one of the ‘near-dead’ rivals to DVB-H in Europe, T-DMB, began to make the kinds of noises you would expect from a standard that had already won the war, rather than finding itself defeated in almost every market in the world except Korea. Last week Deutsche Telekom’s T-Systems said that it was launching a test broadcast for mobile TV in the Netherlands, working with Mobiele Televisie Nederland (MTV NL), and offering five TV stations on cellphones. This is despite the fact that neither T-DMB, nor its audio parent DAB, have yet to be offered a public multiplex in the country, and that incumbent KPN has been preparing its own DVB-H system since 2005 through the consortium Digitenne, which unites KPN, NOB, and Nozema, a Dutch TV transmission operator planning to offer DVB-T and DVB-H services simultaneously using Harris transmitters and Nokia handsets.

During 2006 T-DMB specialist RadioScape operated a trial for T-DMB TV in the Netherlands and it seems the T-Systems trial has emerged out of that. Elsewhere, Sweden’s Factum Electronics, a specialist supplier of DAB-based networks, says that it has won contracts to supply the Czech network operator Teleko and the French network operator Towercast with digital broadcasting systems using the new, more efficient version of DAB/DMB including DMB video services. Factum says that it now has customers in Belgium, Denmark, Germany, Hungary, Iceland, Italy, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland and the UK.

And finally last week, a new multiyear European project to co-operate with China on T-DMB was announced as Mobidec, which brings together key players from Europe and China, including government, trade bodies and the private sector. The launch statement points out that the DAB family of technologies is the only European multimedia broadcasting standard accepted for digital broadcasting by SARFT, China’s state broadcasting regulator, and it is in that fact that salvation for T-DMB may lie.

While in Germany and the UK, where respectively T-DMB and DAB IP have been used to offer mobile TV, the trials have been unmitigated disasters in terms of take-up and the quality of video offered, in China DAB licenses have already been approved in four districts. These will be used to broadcast both audio and mobile TV in Beijing, Shanghai, Dalian and Guangdong Province, which have combined populations of around 50m people.

Our sister service Faultline pointed out in its recent report and forecasts for mobile TV (email [email protected] for details), that although China is developing its own mobile TV standard, T-DMB services, with Samsung devices, were likely to be the back-up plan for getting mobile TV up and running in China by June 2008, in time for the Olympics.

Although 500m people worldwide are said to be within range of a DAB radio system – across 40 countries including Canada, Australia, most of Europe, India, China and South Africa – and there are more than 1,000 services actually live on air, as a video delivery system it is only successful in Korea and despite all the bragging on the T-DMB web site, it is only this temporary advantage in China that is keeping it alive.

While it is true that DAB is widely used in national multiplexes throughout Europe, these were designed for audio services, and while there is substantial penetration of digital radios in the UK, where there are around 8m devices, and also in Germany, Denmark, Norway and Switzerland, these may be totally unsuited for pure video.

The main advantage of using DAB is that in many countries there are existing multiplexes and in many where there are not, there is existing spectrum allocated for building one. The system was designed in Europe and initially came from a funded European project, one of the most successful, named Eureka 147. And on the back of some device success in China, it is possible that World DMB may create a second tier of services. For instance, Italy’s broadcaster RAI said last week that it was forced into offering Mobile TV over T-DMB, because it had no spectrum for DVB-H, and so this sub-community of mobile TV offerings has to find a way forward to survive against the richer, higher quality services coming out of pure datacast systems such as DVB-H.

Having household devices such as microwaves and fridges fitted with T-DMB music and video devices, and offering radios which are GPS devices along with cheap portable music and video players, all suggests that T-DMB can survive as digital radio, with slow take-up, showing a few videos every now and then, as a cheaper option for people who cannot really give their full attention to TV right now.

But there are many issues, including the fact that most of the allocated bands are unusable in the US. Another criticism is that T-DMB has just gone through a fundamental reworking as part of the upgrade of DAB to WorldDMB 2.0, meaning countries that have already embraced DAB will have all their existing receivers incompatible.

Another issue in the past has been that the power levels required for T-DMB chips (DAB chips) were designed for radios, which either have access to mains power or to larger batteries than mobile handsets or other portable players, and so the chipsets were never really built to offer long term battery life. Plus, DAB spectrum has to be allocated in slices of 1.536MHz, which translates to 1,536 OFDM sub-carriers with 1kHz of sub-carrier spacing each. The gross data capacity for the entire DAB signal is close to 3Mbps, but the main service channel offers just 2.3Mbps which really only gives a net useful payload of 1-1.7Mbps.

T-DMB will be around for a long time, but touting it as having ‘won’ the core standards war against DVB-H in Europe is so far from the truth that it makes the outpourings of World DMB look slightly untrustworthy. Instead it is a potentially dominant radio standard, outside of the US, which has a spattering of low class video capabilities, unless you completely ignore the international spectrum roadmap, as Korea has done.

Part of this analysis was previously published in the sister service to Wireless Watch, Faultline, which offers weekly insights on the economics of quad play and the digital media markets. Please contact Linda Elisha on [email protected] for further information.