Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 July 2007

Google boosts femtocell momentum but Vodafone sets the pricing challenge

The momentum behind femtocells continues to build, with Google, never one to stay off a bandwagon, the latest to lend its weight to the miniaturized home base stations. The search giant has made a ‘significant’ contribution to a $25m second round of funding raised by UK-based start-up femtocell maker Ubiquisys, in a move that reflects the larger company’s increasing preoccupation with wireless networks.

Google sees the rapid spread of open access wireless networks as the primary way to broaden the reach of its applications and online services, particularly its advertising. Any technology that makes it easier and more cost effective to deliver broadband access is therefore worth promoting, in its view – it has invested in other start-ups that promote innovative approaches to internet access, designed to accelerate the move to ubiquitous availability, such as community Wi-Fi pioneer FON.

However, there is also the possibility that the giant will decide to acquire spectrum and even build networks in its own right, in which case the femtocell investment may be even more strategic (see separate item).

The rest of the round, which brings Ubiquisys’ total funding to $37m, came from its original investors, Accel Partners, Atlas Ventures and Advent Ventures. CEO Chris Gilbert says the money will be used to support the shift to mass production for the ZoneGate device, which is being trialed by Japan’s Softbank, among others, and will also be integrated by Netgear into a home gateway product (see Wireless Watch July 9 2007). Gilbert expects to be shipping in volume before the middle of 2008.

Meanwhile, operator interest in femtocells continues to convert into real RFPs, with AT&T, as expected, being the latest to move (see Wireless Watch July 2 2007). The company has been hesitant lately about its fixed/mobile convergence strategy, after some ambitious promises back in 2005, but it aims to be an early adopter of the IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS) and an all-SIP approach to delivering services over its various networks. This makes femtocells a logical technology to explore, although like many US providers, AT&T’s initial interest is in improving coverage and lowering voice cost, rather than experimenting with advanced multimedia services. According to ABI Research, the RFP is looking for a ‘fairly basic’ level of functionality, at least in the first stage. AT&T may well be accelerating its FMC plans again in response to T-Mobile’s launch of its own offering, Hotspot@Home, which is based on dual-mode handsets and Wi-Fi/cellular hand-off using UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Access). While AT&T aborted its early trials of UMA, deciding to go straight to SIP, it may actually offer a UMA-based service as its first convergence experiment, when it launches the BlackBerry 8820, RIM’s first dual-mode unit, this summer.

Another giant looking to make an early move into femtocells is Vodafone, which already has an RFP in circulation. It reconfirmed its interest from the highest level, with femtocells winning a mention in CEO Arun Sarin’s first quarter results conference call. The company plans to start deployment in mid-2008. However, Sarin also raised the thorny issue of price, bringing its legendary purchasing power very publicly to bear on the nascent sector. The CEO said on the call that the cellco is “looking for a mass market price that is substantially less than $100” [per unit]. The $100 tag seems a realistic price target once volume is achieved (Wi-Fi access points can be half that, and to succeed with the mass carriers, home femtocells will need to be in the same range). However, it will be extremely tough to meet this profitably by mid-2008, and the pressure will be on the emerging sector to prove the technology further, in order to encourage early volume uptake by many carriers, and to deliver highly integrated chipsets that will drive down the bill of materials. This race will favor the large vendors, such as Alcatel-Lucent, since they have the flexibility to discount equipment in order to gain contracts, or to bundle it with other products and services ‘ the apparently accelerating adoption curve among major operators is likely, therefore, to precipitate some shake-out among the start-up femtocell manufacturers. It should also kick some of the larger chipmakers into action, either directly or through partnerships, with the UK’s picoChip remaining the only vendor with a proven product so far (despite some talk from other start-ups such as RadioFrame and NextWave).