The declaration by AT&T that only 146,000 Apple iPhones registered on its network in the handset’s first two days on the market created widespread shock, and over-excited talk about the much-hyped product’s failure. This sparked a down period for Apple shares, which slid 7.5% in a few days, a fall of some $10bn in total market capitalization.
This is one time that no-one can forgive Apple. In the past it has executed launches so well that they have become metronomic and surprise-free. It might be that this blip was a result of the problems that people had once they had bought their devices, getting home and finding that it was almost impossible to sign up with AT&T over a clogged network, but it might also be because many of the early devices were bought by people from outside the US, who signed up for AT&T service but will take the handset home to use just with Wi-Fi. We certainly know some of those, but are there 100,000 of them?
Because that’s about the number by which everyone agrees Apple missed its numbers – some analysts had pegged the early sales target as high as 400,000 or 500,000, getting carried away on the iPhone euphoria. An entire month’s sign-ups, or better still a quarter’s, will be more indicative, and given the positive reaction to the device from users, as word gets out of what it is like to own such a device, there may be a snowball effect.
Even with the early disappointment, as many as 25% of the buyers were moving from other US networks, so even at what is being seen as a low level, this will be taking customers away from AT&T’s rivals, and scaling up from just two days of sales it is still likely that Apple will make its first year sales targets. For its part, Apple said it sold 270,000 iPhones, representing $5m in revenue, in the first two days (the device was released on June 29, and Apple’s quarter ended on June 30).
Under pressure from European operators, Apple has also gone public on plans for an iPhone that does more than GSM, although initially it will support EDGE/Wi-Fi rather than full 3G. This will launch in major European countries in the last quarter, by which time Apple expects to sell have sold one million units. Asian markets and second tier European countries will follow in 2008 as, everyone hopes, will a UMTS model. Arun Sarin, CEO of Vodafone – which has apparently walked away from a pan-European iPhone deal because of lack of 3G and Apple’s onerous terms – recently called the lack of UMTS support in the handset a “concern’, saying: “The iPhone is clearly a good, software-driven device, but we’re concerned about wideband area coverage. 3G (capability) is something we look forward to and hope Apple moves forward to soon.’
AT&T may not be able to deliver 3G services on its iPhones, but it is pushing ahead with its moves towards all-IP multimedia applications and its initial experiments with IMS (IP Multimedia Subsystem). Last week it unveiled a mobile video service, the first of its kind in the US, that lets users share one-way streaming video from their 3G handsets (initially, the Samsung A707, A717 and A727, and the LG CU500v).
The carrier is targeting the service mainly at friends and family applications rather than the potentially more mature and lucrative sector or business unified messaging, perhaps because its 3G network has not achieved full coverage yet, and it is very early days for its IMS implementations (AT&T last year abandoned plans to use UMA as an interim convergence platform and decided to move straight to all-IP). The service, which requires a 3G connection, will be rolled out in the metropolitan areas of 37 US states where 3G is in place. Aside from special handsets, users must also pay a monthly video premium in addition to their regular wireless contract as well as per minute charges.
AT&T reported higher than expected second quarter profit despite the almost-1% hit on its share price caused by iPhone disappointment. Net profit rose 61% year-on-year to $2.9bn, on revenues up 87% to $29.5bn. On an adjusted basis, which excludes costs and accounting effects from acquisitions, profit rose to 70 cents per share from 58 cents per share, beating average analysts’ forecast of 67 cents. Adjusted revenue, which combines sales from AT&T, BellSouth and Cingular Wireless in both periods, rose 2% to $29.8bn, in line with market expectations. The company’s wireless unit added 1.5m subscribers in the quarter, bringing the total to 63.7m and exceeding the average forecast of 1.25m net additions. However, adjusted operating margins fell from 38.9% in Q1 to 37.5%, partly because of the cost of the run-up to the iPhone launch. AT&T also increased subsidies to attract higher value postpaid customers. In other words, it is investing now to increase revenue from the most profitable customer bases in the medium term ‘ a strategy that will be greatly helped by a pick-up in iPhone performance.