Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 July 2007

EU and US both lean towards liberalization in prime spectrum

While officially the US cellco sector remains opposed to open access plans for part of the 700MHz spectrum, Verizon Wireless has followed AT&T into a compromise position, seeming to reflect a genuine nervousness that Google could succeed in its offer to purchase licenses to ensure uptake of its own open approach to wireless networks (see Wireless Watch July 23 2007). Meanwhile, over in Europe, EU telecoms commissioner Viviane Reding has turned her attention to another prime area of spectrum, proposing to open up the 900MHz band currently reserved for GSM.

It was only a week earlier that Verizon denounced FCC chairman Kevin Martin’s proposal to mandate open access, from any device, on one-third of the spectrum to be auctioned at the turn of the year, calling it ‘rigging’ of the auction in favor of one multibillion dollar player (Google). Now – presumably seeing Martin’s fairly modest proposals as preferable to the more radical demands of Google and the internet community ‘ the US’ second cellco has agreed to the Martin plan, if grudgingly.

CEO Lowell McAdam said he would support the call for open access on 22MHz of the 60MHz total, but on condition that spectrum holders would not be required to guarantee that all applications work properly on their networks. Verizon Wireless said it remains opposed to compulsory open access on principle and believes it will make the spectrum less attractive and could lead to a ‘failed auction’. However, it believes the FCC will adopt some form of open access proposals and would rather influence the process from within.

The attempt to take the wind out of Google’s sails was likely also influenced by the news that a majority of the FCC members had backed the open access portion of Martin’s proposals, during a hearing before the House subcommittee on telecos and the internet. Democratic Commissioners Jonathan Adelstein and Michael Copps supported the plan, while Republican Commissioners Deborah Taylor Tate and Robert McDowell were undecided. The FCC will vote on rules for the upcoming auction before September, with bidding likely to start in December or January.

However, the CTIA ‘ the association that represents the cellcos ‘ remains opposed to any open access requirements, arguing that players should bid for licenses on the open market and then apply their chosen business models if successful. ‘The CTIA opposes encumbering this valuable spectrum with unnecessary regulations and restrictions that place bidders on unequal footing, limit the utility of the spectrum, and ultimately drive down the value to consumers and the US Treasury,’ the association said in a statement.

Over in the European Union, the main focus of carrier interest is on upcoming auctions in 2.5GHz, and on the future of the 900MHz GSM spectrum, which like 700MHz is seen as ideal for mobile broadband applications, especially in sparsely populated areas. Commissioner Viviane Reding wants to remove restrictions on how mobile carriers can use their networks and aims to start by ending limits on 900MHz ‘ something for which holders of this spectrum have been lobbying for years. The ability to run 3G or other technologies in 900MHz is particularly of interest to operators that have significant build-out requirements for advanced services in rural areas, where UMTS spectrum’s small cells make profitable deployment problematic, and to those who failed to win UMTS licenses at all. Creating new networks in 900MHz could also strengthen the case for GSM operators to be allowed to renew their franchises at expiry date, rather than returning them for re-auction.

Calling the current rules in 900MHz ‘outdate’, Reding accepted most of the demands made by the operators’ body, the GSMA, which argues that freeing access to 900MHz (and some remaining sections of the 1.8GHz band) would extend 3G coverage by 40% across the EU. Some operators have already begun trials of UMTS900, a market where Nortel, Nokia and Ericsson have been particularly active. Nokia and French mobile operator SFR completed a test call earlier this year, while Vodafone Portugal and Finland’s Elisa made data calls over 900MHz late last year, both using Option Wireless technology, with Vodafone relying on Nortel base stations and Elisa on Nokia.

Finland, France and Portugal are therefore expected to lead the way in rolling out UMTS900. From the beginning of this year, Europe’s CEPT cleared the path for the roll-out of UMTS900 in its member states but those states still need to implement the decision into their national RF plans, a process that has already begun in these three countries.

The GSMA has also called for regulators to harmonize rules on 900MHz on a global basis to encourage 3G uptake. It recently published research that argued that as many as 300m more people in Asia, Europe and Africa could enjoy access to mobile broadband if this spectrum were to be reserved and coordinated for 3G. The idea would be that 900MHz would create a first layer for HSDPA, and then in cities and dense urban areas the 2.1GHz band would also be brought into play.

In a statement, Reding said: “Radio spectrum is a critical economic resource which must be properly managed. We must facilitate the deployment of mobile communications by allowing new technologies to share spectrum with existing ones.”

The only operators that will be seriously disadvantaged by a liberalization of 900MHz rules ‘ at least until new auctions might be on the cards ‘ are those with only higher frequency licenses. Notable among these is Hutchison’s 3, whose UK arm is already demanding that regulator Ofcom allows it to access rivals’ 2G networks so that it can provide overlay 3G services in rural areas and remain fully competitive.