Motorola CEO Ed Zander may have fought off the bid by corporate raider Carl Icahn to join the company’s board earlier this year, but he still faces significant disruption from activist shareholders, some of whom are now agitating for his resignation in the wake of three consecutive quarters of falling sales, profits and handset market share.
The shareholders behind the call for Zander’s head (and those of three other board directors) do not control much of the company ‘ the initiator, management consultant Eric Jackson, owns only 134 shares – but their arguments are well publicized and could add to the sense of investor unease, putting further pressure on the beleaguered CEO.
Although the board officially remains firmly behind Zander, with director and acting CFO Thomas Meredith proclaiming last week that Motorola has ‘the right strategy and the right leadership’, there is widespread speculation around Wall Street that some directors are already sounding out possible replacements. Most of the speculation has revolved around reported talks with Michael Capellas, former CEO of Compaq (and president of Hewlett Packard when it acquired Compaq), and the man drafted in to rescue WorldCom after its massive financial scandal. As well as his experience in hi-tech and turnarounds, Capellas has the added bonus of being perceived as a man of high integrity.
No dramatic moves are expected until after the Motorola annual shareholders’ meeting in September (postponed from July to allow the management team to prepare more detailed strategic plans), but it will be a long hard summer for Zander, who released second quarter figures that were as bad as Wall Street had expected. Revenues fell from $10.8bn in the same period last year to $8.7bn, with the critical handset lines down 40% (with the lowest sales in two years) and making a loss of $264m, up from $31m in the first quarter and reversing an $804m profit a year earlier. Market share in handsets fell from 22% in mid-2006 to 14%, pushing Motorola into third place after the rampant Nokia, followed by Samsung.
Motorola is sticking to its strategy of extending the RAZR brand to new markets and incorporating the handsets into a broader ‘seamless mobility’ approach aimed at convergence and quad play as well as pure mobile operators. This may well make sense in the medium term (see Wireless Watch July 16 2007), but Motorola needs to demonstrate progress in the immediate months, and the short term indicators are not good. In particular, it is worrying to see that, even though Motorola has pulled back from its disastrously over-aggressive chasing of the ultra-low cost handset market last year, which killed its margins, its average revenue per handset has hardly improved ($120 versus $119 in Q1). Operating margins, then, remain weak, at negative 7.8%, compared to negative 4.3% in Q1. The strongest sign of hope, according to CIBC World Markets’ newest research note, is a boost to gross margins, which seems to reflect a definite, if slow, shift towards higher end handsets and new models just coming into the portfolio. Motorola’s top priority must now be to reduce operating costs and bills of material further in order to capitalize on that gross margin improvement, but traditionally this has been the area where the company has been least successful in competing with the hyper-efficient Nokia.
Regardless of what happens at the top of the executive team, the real pressure in the immediate future is on the new head of handsets, Stu Reed, who has been moved from his previous position in charge of re-engineering the supply chain. This reflects Motorola’s belated awareness that logistics will be even more important to its long term turnaround than flashy handset designs, and although it is arguable that Reed’s work on the supply chain has been only partly successful, and is certainly unfinished, there is high expectation that he will bring a new realism to the cellphone unit now it has to face up to the anticlimax that has followed the RAZR euphoria. That bubble blinded the world to the underlying problems that remain endemic in Motorola’s structures, but now that those problems are fully acknowledged, most analysts are prepared to give the Zander-Reed team a bit more time to put them right. ‘We expect a prolonged, gradual turnaround,’ said the CIBC note, reflecting the cautious optimism of much of the financial community. Whether Motorola’s own shareholders give the current management the same latitude will become clear when Zander presents a full turnaround plan at the September AGM.