In all the publicity about Google’s open access proposals for the 700MHz spectrum, another disruptive idea to shake up the US wireless market has been overshadowed ‘ but now M2Z Networks has re-emerged into the limelight, threatening to take the FCC to court on a technicality to force it to consider a request for 25MHz of vacant spectrum to launch a free wireless offering.
In May 2006, M2Z was set up by former FCC wireless bureau chief John Muleta and applied for the spectrum, promising to deliver free broadband services capable of covering 95% of the population within 10 years. The company has now learned its request would be denied, and says it will seek a court order directing the FCC to comply with Section 7 of the Telecommunications Act, which mandates the ‘Commission shall determine whether any new technology or service proposed in a petition or application is in the public interest within one year after such petition or application is filed’.
‘M2Z has been very patient on behalf of the millions of Americans who would benefit from our proposed service,’ said Milo Medin, M2Z’s chairman. ‘It took the FCC nine months to seek comment on our application, which is as long as it took the Commission to decide the largest telecommunications merger in history, the BellSouth/AT&T merger. Not only is it the law, but it is common sense to give license applications that increase competition at least the same treatment as license transfer applications for mega-mergers that lessen competition.’
M2Z has a similar business model to that suggested for 700MHz by Google, aiming to build a network that would be offered on a wholesale basis to other operators, especially those supporting open access to all devices and applications, and free, advertising-funded internet connections for consumers. Unsurprisingly, the idea is opposed by major incumbents, notably AT&T Mobility and Verizon Wireless. It has also proposed that, in return for uncontested award of a spectrum license, it would return 5% of revenues to the government to boost broadband initiatives.
Despite a general wariness in the VC community about broadband wireless operators ‘ after the high profile failures of start-up operators around 2000 ‘ M2Z succeeded in attracting financial backing from three prominent venture capitalists, Kleiner Perkins Caufield Byers, Redpoint Ventures and Charles River Ventures, and claims it can raise up to $400m.
Muleta claims his company can fulfil the goal set by the Bush administration’s broadband policy and by the FCC itself in his days at the regulator, of making broadband access available to 95% of the US population, mainly using wireless to fill current rural gaps and to reduce the cost of services even in well served areas, by offering an alternative to the incumbent telcos and cellcos. Initially it focused on demanding an allocation in the 2.1GHz AWS band, but once this was auctioned last fall, it is now shifting its attention to 700MHz.
Overall, it has raised an issue that is becoming increasingly important in territories where governments have decided that universal broadband is essential to economic and social progress ‘ in order to achieve that universal access, should spectrum be awarded for free, or at low cost, to operators promising to achieve this with a creative business model? This is a debate that has started taking hold in Europe, where approaches range from that of some Scandinavian regulators, which traditionally award licenses at very low cost to the providers promising to meet government objectives while making a profit; to the lobbying of ISPs in the UK, that one of the forthcoming 2.5GHz licenses, originally earmarked for 3G expansion, be set aside for public sector ownership, to support low cost access and social inclusion programs.