One of the thorniest issues facing any standard is that of interoperability ‘ how effectively this can be achieved and certified not just at a very basic level, but sufficiently to satisfy enterprise and carrier customers, and attract volume device makers. A new body, called the UniFi Alliance, has been formed to take up this challenge for enterprise WLans, aiming to go significantly further than the work carried out by the official testing body for Wi-Fi, the Wi-Fi Alliance.
The Alliance has already seen its role, and its speed of action, questioned in the consumer Wi-Fi sector. Here, on successive occasions, vendors have leapt ahead of the Alliance’s testing and certification schedules, and even of the actual finalization of the IEEE standards, in order to tap into a rapidly moving market at the earliest stage. This has sparked a dual response ‘ vendors and chipmakers setting up their own interoperability programs, one of the most notable being between Intel and Cisco, with partners; and the Alliance itself accelerating its efforts, or being prepared to test pre-standard equipment (as with its certification of interim specifications for WLan security, QoS and now the emerging 802.11n fast Wi-Fi platform).
For the enterprise sector, of course, the issues are more complex and risky. A major factor putting brakes on large scale corporate WLan deployment has been limited interoperability, which keeps costs high and increases the risk of being caught in a technology dead end. For instance, the standards bodies and Alliance do not address the interworking of multivendor switches with light access points, even though this combination is the fastest growing approach to WLan design. This has been partially addressed by industry initiatives such as LWAPP, but in general, large companies still find themselves pushed into adopting whole systems from a single provider.
The UniFi Alliance seeks to address this problem, and is spearheaded, like so many such initiatives, by a small vendor that sees the way to give its technology a broader platform by putting it at the heart of a would-be de facto standard. The vendor, Extricom, says its Alliance plans to build a “system-to-system” level of interoperability in WLan infrastructure, certifying interoperability of multi-application wireless Lans, devices, PBXs, location services, software and security appliances. This would contrast with the ‘basic’ level of certification offered by the Wi-Fi Alliance, said Extricom, which focuses on component-to-component interworking, particularly client-AP calls.
A higher level of certification would allow enterprises to adopt a ‘best of breed’ approach while still using relatively off-the-shelf products. David Confalonieri, VP of marketing, commented in an interview: ‘IT departments want to be sure “they don’t have to be the field guinea pigs integrating this stuff’.
“The Wi-Fi Alliance has certified more than 3,800 products and we have 300 members,” was the official response from that body. “Our certification programs go beyond the component level.”
Apart from Extricom ‘ a five-year old company chiefly known for its ‘blanket coverage’, achieved through parallel use of WLan channels ‘ the founders of UniFi are AeroScout, AirTight Networks, Ascom and Kineto Wireless. Though they say they have not directly invited Cisco to join, it will clearly be difficult to gain enterprise traction for their activities without the support of the major WLan vendors, including the increasingly strong switchmaker Aruba, now sufficiently successful to have attracted litigation from Motorola (see separate item).
Whether or not UniFi itself makes a major impact on enterprise WLans, there is clearly a need for an approach to multivendor, multi-application wireless networks that can support major corporate business plans, rather than the SME and branch office systems to which business Wi-Fi has largely been confined to date. This approach needs to offer interoperability testing and certification that is both more complex and more rapidly available than current programs. Such changes will be essential to fulfil the sales potential of the so-called ‘fourth generation’ of enterprise WLans, which aims to support far larger networks that can run a company’s whole converged voice/data/multimedia systems as well as emerging applications like unified communications. In such a scenario, it will be increasingly difficult for the start-up suppliers to hold their own.
The main trends of the fourth generation are:
‘ higher levels of integration with the wireline network
‘ lower cost and a higher level of commoditization, especially as new standards emerge
‘ new architectures to support greater scalability
This requires greater ability to mix and match components, and also an enhanced approach to WLan switching, a challenge that has been taken up by Extricom and other innovators like Meru and Xirrus, all focused on voice/data convergence, pseudo-mobility and high scalability. Earlier this year, Extricom announced the industry’s first four-radio access point, the EXRP-40 UltraThin. This contains four 802.11a/b/g radios which, using the vendor’s channel blanket architecture, can operate on any combination of four non-overlapping channels in any band for greater capacity, flexibility and QoS.
Other standards will face the same dilemmas as Wi-Fi. Already, in WiMAX, vendors are growing restive at the slow pace of official certification programs, as carrier customers start to demand interoperable products at an early stage. Currently, early WiMAX deployers generally say that even the longer established fixed standard, 802.16d, is not at a stage where they would be happy to mix and match base stations and CPE, at least not without the help of expensive systems integrators. The more large carriers look to step up their roll-outs, and add mobility and consumer CPE to the mix, the more pressure the existing WiMAX Forum processes, and the testing labs that support them, will come under, and the more vendors will look to take matters into their own hands.