Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 September 2007

Mobile satellite alliances boost Clearwire and NSN

The mobile satellite services (MSS) market, long in the doldrums, is experiencing one of its periodic spells of optimism, on the back of new spectrum and tie-ups with other technologies, and this time applications like mobile TV may ensure it is not just another false dawn. Hybrid offerings combining satellite and terrestrial technologies are the major hope for US operators, promising a lower cost base and more flexible range of services, even leading to a full quad play. This is the path being pursued by the holders of the relevant 2GHz spectrum, MSV, ICO and Terrestar, which are all assembling their much-needed partnerships. MSV is currently trialing WiMAX with Nortel (see Wireless Watch April 2 2007); ICO, which is carrying out an important trial of DVB-SH hybrid mobile TV with Alcatel-Lucent, has now Craig McCaw stablemate Clearwire, to its dance card; while Terrestar has chosen Nokia Siemens to supply it with its first all-IP system, the basis for a planned wide range of consumer, business and public safety services.

ICO and Clearwire, both companies in which Craig McCaw has significant stakes, have just announced a collaboration on a mobile video trial using a combination of satellite and Clearwire’s WiMAX spectrum. The pilot will aim to test the value proposition and cost effectiveness of delivering an advanced interactive mobile video service to consumers, and will also study the technical feasibility of using Clearwire’s 2.5GHz spectrum and ICO’s 2GHz spectrum more efficiently in combination. Since Clearwire and Sprint are now pooling their resources in terms of network build-out in 2.5GHz, this could position ICO to gain one of the most coveted cellular partnership, Sprint Nextel, and creates a powerful ecosystem around Clearwire that also numbers the two satellite broadcasters, DirecTV and Echostar. The ICO trial with Clearwire is expected to begin in early 2008 in Raleigh, North Carolina and in Las Vegas, everybody’s favourite market for mobile video tests (mobile TV companies MediaFLO and HiWire are both trialling there).

Clearwire ‘ like Sprint ‘ is interested in the possibility of delivering interactive video and broadcast TV over WiMAX rather than relying on an additional or third party network such as MediaFLO. Bringing satellite into the equation could help to extend coverage and functionality rapidly, especially in areas where Clearwire does not want to build out itself. ICO is already testing Alcatel-Lucent’s DVB-SH system (see inset). ‘Our next generation wireless personal broadband networks are built to deliver data, voice and video over a single network,’ said Scott Richardson, chief strategy officer for Clearwire. ‘Working with ICO to trial an interactive mobile video element that can potentially enhance our service offering not only in areas where we don’t intend to build our own network, but that can also potentially enhance the use of infrastructure and spectrum where our coverage overlaps, makes a lot of sense.’

‘Mobile two-way video, advanced interactive navigation, plus emergency calling and messaging becomes an even more compelling value proposition when integrated with a wireless broadband network such as Clearwire’s,’ said Tim Bryan, CEO at ICO.

For the trial, ICO will integrate its Mobile Interactive Media (MIM) suite of services, devised with Alcatel-Lucent, with the Clearwire network. ICO MIM will provide multiple channels of mobile video to large screen devices.

Meanwhile, the Terrestar contract is an important one for Nokia Siemens, not so much financially but because it gives it a chance to prove its capabilities in an unfamiliar but growing market ‘ hybrid terrestrial-satellite systems, currently focused on the US but likely to be cleared in other regions too, including the EU. Even more significantly, it enables the Finnish-German venture to show off a technology it has been talking up for over a year, but without commercial success so far ‘ Internet-HSPA. I-HSPA was conceived by Nokia pre-NSN, and has become the basis of a standard that aims to provide an all-IP, flat network, giving operators the low cost base and efficiency of the emerging IP technologies like WiMAX, but using existing 3G technologies. It eliminates legacy circuit switching, flattening the network and optimizing it for native IP applications.

NSN will provide Terrestar with its flagship product, the Flexi Base Station, which is designed to support a variety of networks, and is commercialized for W-CDMA/HSPA and WiMAX. The Flexi W-CDMA product will be implemented as part of an I-HSPA flat architecture, and NSN will also supply engineering, design, and optimization services. This network will be integrated with the satellite systems in Terrestar’s 2GHz hybrid satellite spectrum across North America, and will offer a migration path to LTE in future. Terrestar has also agreed to be part of a joint marketing initiative to showcase I-HSPA to NSN’s prospects (presumably something that would have sweetened the indisclosed contract price).

‘Today’s announcement marks a series of firsts for Nokia Siemens Networks: we’re deploying the first I-HSPA network, we’re delivering the first satellite band Flexi, and we’re deploying the first direct tunnel packet core,’ said Sue Spradley, head of the vendor’s north American unit ‘ a tough job, since the company has less market mindshare in this region than its native Europe.

The network will be deployed in 2008 and will be geared to offering wholesale and direct services to public safety agencies, rural communities and wireless carriers.

DVB-SH:

In May, Alcatel-Lucent announced it was working with satellite company Hughes to develop technology for ICO’s trial of its planned next generation services, Mobile Interactive Media (MIM). MIM will be a converged mobile media service for consumer entertainment and communication, based on ICO’s new geostationary satellite (ICO G1) and the Ancillary Terrestrial Component (ATC) technology, which supports the integration with wireless networks. This promises to reduce the cost and handset size of mobile satellite offerings and allow for cellular roaming.

IP-based communications between the devices and satellite base station will use Hughes’ GMR air interface technology, with a focus on internet, VoIP and data applications. Hughes will develop an integrated satellite terminal and antenna system to incorporate GMR and DVB-SH technologies, as well as a GPS receiver.

While many mobile satellite players still find their primary differentiation in emergency response applications, ICO is determined to go after the consumer mainstream, claiming two key differentiators over cellular-only systems – advanced location services, and high quality video/TV. ‘ICO MIM lies at the intersection of three highly prized consumer services: interactive location-based services, using GPS with GMR for navigation plus live traffic, weather and social networks; emergency calling and messaging, for times and places when the traditional terrestrial networks are unavailable; and mobile video, on larger screens and with better quality than currently available,’ said CEO Tim Bryan.

Alcatel-Lucent is in final negotiations with the operator to be the end-to-end network integrator for both the satellite and terrestrial networks. Olivier Coste, president of Alcatel-Lucent’s mobile broadcast activities, said at the time: ‘We consider hybrid satellite/terrestrial networks very powerful solutions to provide mobile broadcast services to consumers. Moreover, by leveraging the large ecosystem of the DVB-H open standard family, we believe that DVB-SH will enable a broadband range of mass market multimedia applications.’

Iridium:

Iridium, now seven years out of Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, is planning an IPO, based on an uptick in its subscriber growth since early 2006, and its need for funds to upgrade its satellite fleet.

The company is sticking rigidly to its strategy of relying on business and machine-to-machine communications services only, rather than being lured into consumer offerings like most of its rivals.

“We are moving towards an IPO with the timing based more on the markets than our need and our readiness for it,” said Matt Desch, Iridium’s CEO. He expects the public offering ‘ in 12-24 months – plus a private equity round to raise about $500m for the company, which was bought out of bankruptcy protection in 2000 by a group of private investors for just $25m (pre-Chapter 11, the Motorola-backed firm had spent $5bn on deploying its 66 satellites). Evercore Partners has been appointed to advise on the private equity funding, which is expected to complete early next year, despite some cooling in the recently rampant PE sector following the US downturn.

Iridium has been increasing its subscriber base at a double-digit rate over the past 18 months and now has about 212,000 subscribers, including about 100,000 using its satellite mobile phones. It has also reported seven quarters in a row of profitability, claiming this has stemmed from ‘finding our niche’ in industrial and business services, and sticking to it. The plan is to spend $2bn on a project, called ‘Next’, to replace the satellite fleet from 2013. Before that, Desch is looking for 10-12% earnings growth per year, and expects to maintain that rate for a decade, generating about $1.5bn internally.

Meanwhile, Motorola has escaped owing billions of dollars to creditors of Iridium by winning a ruling in a lawsuit related to the company’s 1999 bankruptcy protection filing.
The ruling cleared most counts in the claim against Motorola. Iridium’s creditors were trying to force Motorola to return $3.7bn it was paid to build Iridium’s satellite constellation. US Bankruptcy Judge James Peck in Manhattan ruled that, even though the capital markets turned out to be “terribly wrong” about Iridium’s profit forecasts, the start-up’s ability to raise money in the market meant it was not “insolvent” during a critical period. There are still outstanding claims to be heard, focusing on whether Motorola controlled Iridium and breached terms of the contract to supply the satellite system.