Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 September 2007

Interview: HiWire remains bullish about US chances for DVB-H

Chatting to Charles Townsend, the CEO of Aloha Partners last week, it became pretty clear that no-one is raising a white flag in the US over MediaFLO’s dominance of the US mobile TV market, least of all Aloha. The company owns a national 700MHz license and with SES Americom is hoping to create a DVB-H mobile TV service to compete head-on with MediaFLO, called HiWire.

Aloha has two 6MHz channels of 700MHz spectrum but there has always been speculation that the company is in fact a spectrum trader and not really interested in building what might be a $500m network, but instead, just proving the value of the licenses with a view to sale at a vast profit. Why, we asked, wouldn’t Qualcomm augment its single 700MHz channel by offering to buy the Aloha spectrum and ensure that MediaFLO can see off all challengers?

‘Because it’s not for sale,’ says Townsend simply. ‘We expect that MediaFLO will go after Channel 56 when the auctions come around. It wouldn’t pay us what we think the spectrum is worth.’

‘We think that there will be two mobile TV networks in the US – MediaFLO and ours,’ he continues. We pointed out that Alcatel was a pretty powerful operation and it has already cut a deal with Craig McCaw’s ICO Global Communications satellite company to put its DVB-SH service out during 2008 in the 2GHz S-Band, offering blanket US coverage about the same time that MediaFLO achieves the same, and then infilling cities with booster signals to achieve better in-building penetration thereafter.

Townsend claims that, even with Alcatel’s plan to boost the DVB-SH signal with additional terrestrial transmitters on 3G towers: ‘That system won’t go through walls. So people will only be able to use it outdoors. It will be fine for in-car devices, much the same as the satellite radio services which offer in-car services today, but we don’t think it will go through walls.’

What does he think of the prospect of Sprint using WiMAX to offer a rival to both HiWire and MediaFLO in the near term, possibly taking the cable operator TV to market on a handset?

‘The Sprint WiMAX network will be pure data at first,’ he responds. ‘ 2.5GHz is very expensive to build out, and if Sprint wanted to plan its network for video it would mean building 10 times as many cells as in the 700MHz spectrum we have. We don’t know what Sprint is doing, we know that it has tested MediaFLO, but we expect that its video to the handset will remain streaming video over its EV-DO network for some time to come.’

But with Verizon and AT&T committed to MediaFLO, can HiWire then build out a US-wide network based purely on the traffic that T-Mobile might bring to it? Townsend squirms at this question. He is clear that HiWire will not commit to the broad spending that a DVB-H network will require until it has an operator behind it, but demurs when we suggest that T-Mobile, with its 25m customers, is the last major operator in the US that is available to be tied down to a mobile TV service. The implication is clear, but Townsend refuses to acknowledge it, that AT&T is in a state of vacillation about mobile TV and perhaps signed for MediaFLO so that it can cover the Verizon launch if it has to. It may still be talking to HiWire (and others) about backing a different network, and a potential change of heart at AT&T, combined with the numbers that T-Mobile can bring to the party, really would enable DVB-H to take its fair share of the market.

But what would lead to a change of heart at AT&T? Again Townsend won’t address it directly, but says: ‘When you take a long hard look at cable TV channels, you find that most people watch just 15 channels. When you look across TV demographics you find that all the chunks of 15 TV channels that are watched add up to around 45 channels in total. If you narrow this down by excluding some of the viewer groups (HiWire is targeting 15 year olds to 40 year olds) you end up with around 30 channels. We have the spectrum to offer 30 channels (well at least 24 channels, and double whatever MediaFLO can do) while MediaFLO can only bring 12 to 15 channels.’ His argument is that anyone that doesn’t want to wait until well into 2009 to begin building a mobile TV network with discarded analog TV spectrum, has to go with either HiWire or MediaFLO, and that the only one of these that can bring the full suite of channels needed for mass adoption is HiWire.

HiWire has always maintained that it is just two years away from a national build-out of its network, and that it will cover 181m potential customers. In April it began consumer trials of its service in Las Vegas, the same market rival Qualcomm MediaFLO chose for its initial launch, so that it could offer a direct comparison in a market where traditional television broadcasters had already vacated the 700MHz spectrum.

HiWire is working with transmitter manufacturers Rohde and Schwarz and DMT, and with RRD for the software platform, with no equipment from DVB-H leader Nokia in sight. If it did talk to Nokia, then perhaps it could take the opportunity to plead its case, to raise some funding from the Finnish father of DVB-H to help build the network and so wrongfoot its rival Qualcomm.

This interview was conducted and originally published by Faultline, Wireless Watch’s sister service, which provides weekly in-depth analysis of the economics and technologies of quad play. Please contact Linda Elisha on [email protected] for further details.