Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 September 2007

Vodafone tries to steal iPhone thunder with MusicStore launch

As the mobile internet market evolves, device makers and cellcos are adapting their business models with varying degrees of reluctance, and also trying to keep the upper hand in their relationships with one another. This will be a difficult challenge for the operators, in particular, since the walls round their gardens are tumbling down and the phonemakers are increasingly promoting their own brands and appealing directly to consumers via open internet services. Nokia has been in the forefront with the launch of its Ovi mobile web services family and its Music Store (see Wireless Watch September 3 2007). The latter will provide a serious challenge to the dominant mobile music platform, Apple iTunes, and other contenders like Sony. But the operators have not been quiet ‘ Verizon has already joined with MTV and RealNetworks to offer Rhapsody America (see Wireless Watch August 27 2007), and now Vodafone has gone public with its implementation of the operator-driven platform MusicStation.

Like Nokia, Vodafone has announced the service along with some top end, music-focused handsets, notably Samsung’s touchscreen SGH-F700V, the 8Gb HSDPA version of the Nokia N95, and the Sony Ericsson Walkman 910i. The MusicStation service will be preloaded onto these three devices, a move that only highlights the dilemma that will face phonemakers in future ‘ how to balance the promotion of their own preloaded music services (the new N95 is one of the flagship devices for Nokia Music Store) with keeping the cellcos, likely to be their primary channel to market for many years, on side.

The operators, of course, face the same dilemma, especially if services like Nokia’s start to gain serious traction. While Orange has threatened to boycott the Nokia music phones that feature preloaded Music Store, Vodafone has taken the opposite ‘ and more realistic view ‘ and has even professed itself open to some form of cooperation with vendor services. Jens Schulte-Bockum, global director of terminals for the group, said in an interview last week: ‘We’re not necessarily hostile as a matter of principle to the idea that vendors like Nokia implement relevant services on handsets and make a contribution to this openness and this emerging space themselves. We’re discussing that with Nokia. The end game that we’re working towards is one that I would describe as mutual openness and peaceful coexistence.’

The F700 is an exclusive for Vodafone for now, and one of several handsets being touted as ‘iPhone killers’ in Europe ‘ in particular, it supports HSDPA and a pull-down Qwerty keyboard, unlike the Apple device.

In another echo of Nokia, the Vodafone launch ‘ which kicks off in the UK and will then be extended to other Vodafone territories ‘ will be seen in the short term as a response to the Apple iPhone, whose European distributors will be officially announced next week. But the stakes will be far higher than just wrongfooting Apple and its carrier partners ‘ MusicStation is just one aspect of a far wider strategy for Vodafone to offer mobile internet services that can compete on their merits with the phonemakers’ offerings, just as it did in the first generation of mobile data services, by creating the Live! portal and brand rather than merely carrying third party offerings.

MusicStation was created by UK specialist Omnifone and at February’s 3GSM event the company announced that it had signed 23 cellcos, with a combined subscriber base of 690m in Europe and Asia, to support its framework ‘ reflecting a growing trend for operators to join forces to create content services and frameworks, and so seek to keep control and fight off the internet giants. It now says 30 cellcos are on board, though Telenor is the only one, before now, to go live. Omnifone also claims partnerships with operators in Australia, Belgium, Czech Republic, France, Germany, Greece, Hong Kong, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, New Zealand, Philippines, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Singapore, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Turkey and the UK, but Vodafone is the first major to go live and will be seeking first mover advantage as well as control over the future development of the system. On the content side, Omnifone says it is working with ‘the world’s major music labels’ as well as independents, and now has 1m tracks from Sony BMG Music Entertainment, Universal Music Group, EMI Music and Warner Music, among others.

The service works by letting users search, download and play music on their cellphones and sync it with their PCs to create playlists, which can then be shared with other MusicStation users. The offering is compatible with 75% of handsets that are already on the market and can be downloaded directly to the mobile phone, even if it doesn’t include a music player. Unlike the iPhone, the music is stored centrally, so if a phone is lost or stolen, there is no need to repurchase the tracks.

Aware of the importance of building brand quickly in online services, the operators have put aside their usual insistence on their own branding and will all use the MusicStation name and look and feel.

Vodafone’s UK launch will offer unlimited music downloads for £1.99 ($4) a week. The timing ‘ pitching against the upcoming European launch of iPhone ‘ was certainly no accident, and Vodafone CEO Arun Sarin reinforced the point when he told the UK’s Sunday Times newspaper last week: ‘It’s a 2G phone, not 3G. When it’s a broadband phone we will be interested in carrying it.’ Vodafone has been working hard to alleviate shareholder disappointment that it walked away from an international exclusive deal to carry the iPhone, which is set to be offered by O2 and T-Mobile in the key territories.

‘We think we have very good insights into how customers want to use content services,’ Tim Yates, chief marketing officer of Vodafone UK, told reporters at Unstrung. ‘Nokia’s is an interesting service, but we have good, in-depth knowledge of mobilizing services’ For the first time, we’re giving unlimited access to music. We don’t think anyone else will have a service like this in the UK, at least for this coming Christmas season.’

The MusicStation service will be accessed through the Vodafone Live! portal and charged on the customer’s Vodafone bill. Tracks are downloaded over the air and subscribers will also be able to create a profile to receive relevant music news and updates and share tracks with other MusicStation users. However, to keep prices down, Vodafone will not initially allow users to copy downloaded tunes to other devices such as PCs, according to Al Russel, head of content services at Vodafone UK. This facility will be offered as a premium service for an additional fee.

Longer term, there is speculation over whether Vodafone could seek to strengthen its own-branded music services by adopting the Rhapsody platform being pushed in the US by its joint venture partner Verizon (see Wireless Watch August 27 2007).