Last year Mobile WiMAX conversations were dominated by two themes ‘ when certified equipment would come to market, and who would emerge as dominant in control of 802.16e IPR. This year both issues are clearer, though by no means resolved, and the debates have moved on a step. Vendors are racing to position themselves not just for baseline certification but for clear performance differentiation, and are also looking to establish their IPR credentials across the OFDMA market, rather than specifically in WiMAX. These two natural evolutions are illustrated by the latest activities of ArrayComm, the smart antenna specialist that has, in recent years, focused its main efforts on 802.16e, but whose overall goal is to gain a strong IPR and platform licensing position across the mobile broadband market. Last week it announced a partnership with Freescale, that seeks to differentiate that company’s WiMAX base station offering in advance of certification, and clarify the former Motorola unit’s none too coherent public position on 802.16e. ArrayComm also filed a patent infringement lawsuit against WLan chipmaker Atheros, indicating that it is ready to step up its IPR activities even beyond WIMAX.
ArrayComm boasts a range of advanced smart antenna techniques (collected under the badge A-MAS or ArrayComm Multi-antenna Signal processing) which it originally applied to its own broadband wireless network, i-Burst, but has since refocused mainly on 802.16e. The 802.16e wave two profile supports two key antenna techniques – AAS (Adaptive Antenna System) and MIMO (Multiple Input Multiple Output) – but ArrayComm claims that A-MAS enhances this baseline specification by adding interference mitigation and other enhancements that are exclusive to the company. It supports MIMO, AAS, and combined MIMO/AAS modes on both client devices and base stations.
According to ArrayComm’s co-founder Martin Cooper (best known as the ‘father of the cellphone’ and author of Cooper’s Law while at Motorola), the company aims to reinforce and demonstrate these claims with two ends in view ‘ turning ‘interesting’ joint projects into real revenue streams as certification gets underway, and maximizing the licensing revenues from technologies underlying A-MAS.
Freescale is the latest addition to the ecosystem that ArrayComm has been building around itself since it threw in its lot with WiMAX (see Wireless Watch December 16 2004), all but abandoning its own broadband wireless platform, iBurst (although this is still maintained as a niche product by Kyocera and powers some operator deployments in countries such as South Africa). Since then, ArrayComm has worked closely with KT, Samsung, Intel and Texas Instruments (see Wireless Watch March 6 2006), among others, and recently announced Alvarion and SOMA as direct customers. With its input, Freescale is creating a base station reference platform for 802.16e wave two, based on a combination of A-MAS and the larger company’s MSC8144 quad-core digital signal processor, the latter handling both MAC and PHY processing.
“While baseline profiles and certification waves are a good start, even greater performance gains can be achieved by leveraging ArrayComm’s software,” said president Steve Sifferman in a statement. The partners are claiming that these gains could amount to as much as four times greater coverage and capacity, and doubled data rates. The reference design was announced at Freescale’s Technology Forum in Tokyo last week.
The announcement reinforced the impression that, in 2007, Freescale is finally getting bullish about WiMAX, having been hesitant about it before and concentrating mainly on the RF side and on future plans to incorporate 802.16e in its portfolio of low power products targeted at the digital home. In January Freescale unveiled its development platform for WiMAX baseband applications, using the Power Architecture technology and incorporating its MPC8555E PowerQUICC III communications processor, StarCore DSPs and an FPGA (however, it was pipped to the post for the first public customer using the PowerPC architecture for 802.16e, by IBM, when Nex-G defected).
From ArrayComm’s point of view, Freescale is a valuable addition to its partner list, though it is clear from Cooper’s comments that this list will not be confined to WiMAX but that the company aims to take a stake across the OFDM-based emerging networks, from fast Wi-Fi (the most immediate target of the Atheros spat) to LTE. Already, the firm’s web reaches beyond 802.16e, especially through the ongoing Kyocera relationship, which gives it an indirect link to Qualcomm and others. Qualcomm and Kyocera were jointly responsible for the latest proposal for the currently stalled 802.20 mobile broadband standard, and continue to work closely on future developments based on OFDMA in the forward link and OFDMA/CDMA in the reverse link. Another indirect connection to this shadowy but potentially important R&D is TeleCIS, whose 802.16e assets Qualcomm purchased earlier this year, and which has been a long time associate of ArrayComm (the two announced a joint development deal in 2005, shortly after ArrayComm’s CEO Dr Sam Endy left to head up TeleCIS. In another twist, he left a year ago to become head of the mobile business unit at Atheros).
It seems Endy has been less successful in his latest move at staying friends with his former company. ArrayComm is suing Atheros, the third placed WLan chip vendor, for allegedly infringing three patents (US Patent Nos 5,592,490, 5,642,353 and 5,828,658), all related to multi-antenna signal processing, in its XSPAN chips, which are used by several Wi-Fi vendors in routers for the 802.11n draft standard. The smaller company, which is seeking damages and an injunction, says it has tried to negotiate a settlement for the past two years but that its ‘intellectual property is being knowingly, willfully, and unfairly exploited’, as Sifferman put it. In a statement, he continued: ‘ArrayComm licenses its patents on fair and reasonable terms. However, when someone misappropriates and exploits our intellectual property without a license, we have no option but to protect it through every means available to us. We believe that Atheros XSPAN chips, and products that incorporate those chips, infringe ArrayComm’s patents.’
Atheros’ CEO Craig Barratt formerly worked for ArrayComm and is a named inventor on two of the patents involved (5,592,490 and 5,828,658). He and his company have not yet commented.
Beyond the specifics of this case, ArrayComm’s action and its timing show the company seeking to raise the profile of its IPR and establish its position as the wireless industry becomes engulfed in one of its periodic waves of patent-related legal actions. More importantly, like larger licensors like Qualcomm, the start-up will want to test some of its claims, at the negotiating table or in court, as the jostling for IPR stakes starts to gather steam in emerging OFDMA-based platforms like LTE and UMB too. With these three platforms and 802.11n all using certain core technologies in common, there is expected to be a major crossover of design elements and patents, reaping richer return on the R&D (and litigation) investments of the vendors than ever before.