Skype has always been hailed as a disruptive force in the traditional voice market, and has succeeded in wreaking havoc in many areas without really fulfilling its promise as a commercial business. Hence eBay’s admission last week that it had overpaid for the free VoIP provider ‘ but that came as no surprise. What is more interesting is Skype’s rumoured deal with cellco 3 to offer its own-branded VoIP offering, with its own handset. This illustrates a range of issues that need to be addressed across the telecoms and internet communities before the mobile internet will ever take off ‘ the role and relationship of traditional and new carriers, the link between services and devices, and how profits can be generated and shared along the value chain. Meanwhile, continuing to establish the UK as a testing ground for new telecoms models, incumbent BT has made its latest attempt to join the mobile internet vanguard, promising to create the largest Wi-Fi network in the world in partnership with FON, another disruptive force that now seems to be coming in from the cold and under the wing of a telco protector.
In the same week that Skype founder Niklas Zennstrom departed amid the disillusionment of parent eBay with its overpriced VoIP gamble, Skype intensified its alliance with 3, which last year took on the unlikely role of champion of the cellco internet provider model. The contrast reinforced the idea that a brave cellco, that is prepared to pull down its walled gardens rapidly and decisively, may still position itself more effectively for mobile internet and VoIP success than the classic internet giants, which have a long battle ahead to gain significant mindshare in the mobile world. If mobile behaviour was the same as fixed broadband behaviour, the likes of Skype and Google would win every time over the jaded brands of the mobile carriers, but there are two major differences ‘ the failure to date to create a usable mobile internet interface, and the branding power of the handset itself. Both these differences from the PC experience relate to the device, and both mean that the company that controls the device controls the business model ‘ something Nokia has always known, and that Google and now Skype, with their plans for their own handsets and user interfaces, are belatedly recognizing.
The deal with a cellco like 3 is important to Skype because, in a world where open access networks are not yet a reality except in Wi-Fi, this gives Skype a quality network, and more importantly, offers users a usable experience. Several carriers and phonemakers now preinstall Skype, and anyone with an internet phone can download it, but this is where the differences from the PC world become glaringly obvious. Unless the interface and performance is tailored for the device, as 3 promises to do, the mobile Skype experience is severely lacking. This goes for many popular internet applications, including search, and until recently cellcos looked to turn that to their advantage by creating pseudo-open internet portals that were more usable and attractive than braving the open web. Now that Wi-Fi handsets and other factors are making that unacceptable to users, cellcos need to give their power users, at least, more freedom and work out how to make money from that. The clue lies in the fact that the internet companies still need the help of the cellcos to make their applications usable. Skype has deals with Motorola and other phonemakers but in practise, without significant effort from the phonemakers, downloaded Skype software often performs poorly on mobile devices.
This has driven the company to consider creating its own device, optimized for its service and promoting its brand ‘ following the trend set by other internet players like Apple and, reportedly, Google. Now sources say the Skype phone is close to reality and has been created with 3 as a low cost handset that will focus on free VoIP for the mass market, and premium VoIP with high quality of service for business and power users.
This shows that internet players, in the short term at least, will gain easier access to the mobile user base by working with enlightened cellular carriers than trying to destroy them, and that cellcos and handset makers will prove more valuable allies than internet experts like eBay for the initial push into mobility ‘ mobile internet, as the likes of Skype are discovering, is very hard to do, and almost impossible without major commitment from companies that actually understand mobile technology and business cases (Nokia’s primary argument for why it will beat Google in this sphere).
And 3 is a good choice of partner for an internet player looking for initiation into the mysteries of mobility. Once a solid opponent of destroying walled gardens, the Hutchison-owned operator underwent a radical conversion last year and became one of the most forward thinking of the cellcos in terms of embracing internet models and allies, rather than seeking to prop up its closed world a little bit longer (see Wireless Watch November 20 2006). Almost a year ago, 3 unveiled its X-Series broadband internet service, demonstrating the combination that will be essential to all operators in mobile broadband – of flat rates; bundling of different content and media; multiple platform support including television; and web 2.0 functions and payment models. Skype was on a list of major internet partners, also including Sling Media, Yahoo, Google, eBay, Microsoft and Orb, as well as handset makers Nokia and Sony Ericsson.
Another UK carrier looking to take its place in the mobile internet world is BT, although unless it can get its hands on 2.5GHz licenses, probably for WiMAX, in the auction planned for next year, it remains without the asset of spectrum (except through its MVNO deal with Vodafone). The company, like T-Mobile USA, has sought to make up for its shortcomings in this area as best as it could through using Wi-Fi, and has created a major network of hotspots, Openzone, plus the fixed/mobile convergence service Fusion, which uses a combination of Wi-Fi/UMA in the homezone with access to the Vodafone 3G network beyond that. Now it is going a step further, and like 3 is partnering with a disruptive force to achieve this. BT is working with Spanish start-up FON, which has an innovative community Wi-Fi model that has gained traction in many countries, to build what it claims will be the UK’s largest Wi-Fi system. This will support near-blanket coverage of most significant population centers, and a range of services from free Wi-Fi to converged and enterprise options.
BT’s 3m-plus Total Broadband customers will be able to join the FON Wi-Fi network, which has more than 190,000 hotspots worldwide. By doing so, BT’s customers can participate in the FON community model, which allows users free access provided they open up their access points to other users. Those who keep their APs closed, or those making use of a ‘FONero’s’ AP, have to pay fees.
BT is seen harnessing modern approaches to wireless business models, such as community access, in a bid to gain scale and provide an alternative to the advanced 3G networks of the UK, and says the deal will create the world’s largest Wi-Fi community. It did not reveal financial details though it has taken a stake of undisclosed size in FON.
Although BT has been active in metrozone projects too, it may be growing cautious about these, given the recent commercial failure of several high profile initiatives in the US. Martin Varsavsky, founding CEO of FON, whose investors include Google and eBay, claims that by building Wi-Fi coverage inside commercial and residential buildings, and then harnessing this on a wider scale, customers gain better coverage and quality of service than with outdoor metrozones, which require high levels of capex to support true broadband performance. As with cellular femtocells, the use of an indoor Wi-Fi router allows the network to be extended using low cost devices ‘ sometimes even paid for by the consumer ‘ and using the customer’s own DSL backhaul.
If BT gains WiMAX spectrum next year, it could integrate a licensed spectrum network with its various Wi-Fi deployments to speed its time to market and offer a higher quality infrastructure for a range of business models, including municipal networks.
BT FON wireless routers will use the fixed line broadband connection owned by BT customers and make it available over the air via Wi-Fi. The router will split the customers’ Wi-Fi link into two, creating a security protected private network for the BT subscriber while also making part available to the public. BT customers will be able to access the FON public network for free when traveling elsewhere in the world. BT and FON will share these revenues, but declined to give financial details.
FON is looking to make similar deals in other core territories to acquire a global presence. It has already signed with Neuf Cegetel in France, where it has 600,000 FON routers, and with Time Warner Cable in the US. It is also present in Japan, South Korea, Germany and other countries and is “conservatively” targeting one million hotspots worldwide by the end of 2008.
Zennstrom departs eBay:
eBay has announced that the CEO of Skype, Niklas Zennstrom, has “stepped down to pursue other projects”, with head of strategy Michael van Swaaij temporarily taking his role. The development is seen as acknowledgement that eBay overpaid for the VoIP provider (the sum was $2.6bn) and that the unit has not met its targets. Now it is set to write down the value of Skype by $900m.
In a statement, eBay said the move has triggered earn-out settlement agreements totalling about $375m to the former executives and others as a part of the eBay acquisition agreement. It pointed out that the sum is less than the maximum possible $1.2bn earn-out payment, had all the business targets for Skype been met, but added that a $1bn impairment charge would be placed on eBay’s Q3 results.
Skype generated just $90m in revenues in the quarter ended June 30 this year.