Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 November 2007

Enterprise data and emerging markets drive Vodafone to new confidence

Vodafone CEO Arun Sarin was emboldened by a near-50% increase in data revenues and generally strong results to raise the subject of acquisitions in front of his usually risk-averse shareholders last week, with Chinese expansion a key topic of discussion.

With China set to relax its telecoms market regulations and allow operators to offer both fixed and mobile services, the climate for inward investment is also expected to improve, and Sarin aims to use Vodafone’s $13bn (3%) stake in China Mobile as a bargaining counter. This could possibly be traded for investment in other parts of the Chinese market. As Sarin told the London Financial Times: ‘That is a nice kitty or endowment to either stay where we are, or take wherever we want it’.

Sarin also told investors last Thursday that Vodafone was likely to go after new acquisitions in the coming year, particularly in Asia and Africa. The cellco is widely rumored to be preparing a bid for a 25% stake in Telekom Malaysia’s mobile arm. He reiterated that Vodafone’s main aim in making investments is to gain a controlling stake in a company over time, though it might also be swayed by ‘a very strong dividend stream’.

Shareholders have been frustrated that Vodafone’s Verizon Wireless joint venture will not reinstate dividends until at least 2009, and claim the value of that 45% stake, which is highly cash generative, is not reflected in the Vodafone share price. Sarin, who is under far less pressure in his CEO post than he was a year ago, has constantly resisted pressure to exit Verizon Wireless, and told the investor conference in Barcelona that he he understood why majority partner Verizon wanted to wait until the rapidly growing business, which is expanding and buying spectrum, had no debt before announcing new dividends.

Shareholders are generally more positive about investments in emerging markets, provided these do not show signs of Vodafone returning to its somewhat reckless acquisition patterns of the previous decade. The company has taken stakes in operators in India and Turkey, among others, and now hopes to raise its 50% holding in South Africa-based Vodacom, which operates in many African nations. Some analysts expect the company to raise its Vodacom stake to 80-85% for around $7.2-$8.3bn, as venture partner Telkom, the South African incumbent, is currently reviewing its options. Sarin said he expects some clarity from Telkom in ‘a couple of months’.

Sarin will also look for new fixed broadband acquisitions in countries where DSL ‘penetration is low and prices are high’. Vodafone recently spent $1.1bn on buying the Italian and Spanish fixed line businesses of Swedish telecoms group Tele2, and owns Arcor in Germany, and Sarin cited Portugal as another example of an attractive market where there is the chance to be a major converged player.

But he insisted that convergence is the name of the game, not full quad play. ‘We are a mobile player,’ he said. ‘You aren’t going to hear words like triple and quadruple play from us. We are focused on making sure that we are offering things customers want…and we will offer broadband services where they make money.’

In the first half of Vodafone’s fiscal year, it saw data service revenues rise by 48.8% year-on-year to £967m ($2bn), the growth primarily driven by enterprise business. This is a very strong result for the cellco, which has earmarked expansion in the corporate market as a key objective, but which has often struggled to make an impact there. Data services, excluding SMS, now account for 6% of the cellco’s total service revenues, and in Europe, enterprise business accounts for 28% of a total of £12bn ($25bn) in service revenues.

3G was another strong area, a matter of great relief given the long wait for real progress in this area, but there were some doubts among investors, mainly because Vodafone had not quite hit admittedly bullish analyst expectations. However, the operator raised its full year profit and revenue forecasts and pointed to the figures as a sign that, despite the tribulations and shareholder nervousness of a year ago, its strategy is starting to pay off.

Vodafone raised its revenue forecasts by about £1bn to an increased range of £34.5bn-£35.1bn; and is now expecting to make an adjusted operating profit in the range of £9.5bn-£9.9bn, higher than the £9.3bn-£9.8bn it had previously predicted to the City of London. Analysts had anticipated an upgrade in the wake of bullish outlooks from Orange and Telefonica O2, which served to trigger rerating of the whole sector the week before.

In the first half, Vodafone’s adjusted operating profit grew 1.6% to £5.2bn as revenue increased 9% to £17bn in the six months to the end of September. As well as enterprise data and 3G, emerging markets delivered revenue growth of almost 40%, offsetting just 2% growth in Europe. The steepest rise was in Egypt, where revenue leapt 33.1%, while Turkey rose 28% and Romania 24%. In its first month of sales in India, the company sold 400,000 of its ultra low-cost handsets, which retail at $25.

The main cloud on Vodafone’s horizon remains the question of whether it can transform itself into a mobile internet company or whether it is condemned to become a bitpipe provider, which will ultimately hit margins significantly. Despite the revenue growth from enterprise, this is largely coming from mobile email and basic access, rather than more premium services, and is driven by greater availability of 3G, making data cards and advanced PDAs more usable. Although Vodafone has been making great strides in knocking down its garden walls and taking the initiative in multimedia internet projects such as its recent embrace of Nokia’s Ovi portal, there is little indication in its figures yet that its growth is coming from anywhere but basic access, and with this being largely flat rate, expansion will tail off as markets saturate ‘ hence the focus on fixed broadband and emerging markets.

As long as there is room for such expansion, Vodafone can enjoy the luxury of a revenue stream that does not involve sharing with other partners in the value chain, as content and multimedia services do. It can charge a relatively high data charge (€30 or $44 a month), which does not squeeze its margins too much, because there is plenty of uptake left among business and power users ‘ but this will change as the mass consumer market takes off, and with it a host of low cost providers and MVNOs. At this point, traditionally high margin services like SMS will come under pressure from internet-based alternatives like mobile IM. In the first half, revenue from messaging services rose 9% to £2bn while the new Mobile Internet service has 500,000 subscribers since it launched in May in eight markets. Parts of Vodafone, at least, will be hoping the latter does not grow too quickly at the expense of the highly profitable former.

Vodafone added 20.5m net new subscribers in the first half of this year, bringing its total customer base to 241.5m worldwide.