Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 November 2007

Verizon bows to open access, and like Sprint will not wait for 4G

When Google and others started demanding open access in the run-up to the US 700MHz rulemaking, the concept was greeted with horror by the established mobile operators. However much it might already be gaining ground in east Asia and western Europe, the idea of transferring the full PC/internet model to the mobile world, and allowing any device to access any service on any network, was terrifying to the US majors. Now Verizon Wireless – which at one point was suing the FCC even over its watered-down open access provisions for part of the 700MHz band ‘ has done a complete U-turn and says it will provide open access options across its network by the end of next year, about the time when we may expect any disruptive operator that buys a 700MHz license to be starting to come to market.

Verizon Wireless’ decision indicates several trends, and shows why the company, partly under the influence of its co-parent Vodafone, continues to grasp the nettle in new markets more effectively than AT&T. Rather than cede any high value mobile internet users to new players ‘ whether or not backed by a Google wholesale system – or to the real trailblazer, Sprint Nextel, Verizon Wireless will reverse its strategy and ensure it stays in the driving seat. It believes it is building a sufficiently strong applications differentiation to keep many people hooked on its network, with services like VCast and Navigator, and like Sprint it will not have missed the fact that an open device is a device the operator does not have to subsidize.

Sprint Nextel realized the benefits of being first into the mobile internet market, for all the short term pain that would cause in terms of new investment in equipment, software, devices and marketing; and in terms of the dramatic shift of business model to one based on flat rates and mass, often unprofitable traffic. Whether Sprint is financially and operationally strong enough to withstand that short term pain remains to be seen, but that does not alter the fact that its vision was correct, nor that Verizon Wireless is a company in far fitter shape to take the risks of transition to open access on the chin.

Just days before Verizon Wireless said it would adopt LTE for its next generation systems, which will be when open mobile internet really takes off (see separate item), it announced it would ‘provide customers the option to use, on its nationwide wireless network, wireless devices, software and applications not offered by the company’. This choice will be nationally available by the end of 2008.

Of course, we are still talking about EV-DO and cellular networks at this stage, not full IP, and so Verizon will need to get the developer and handset community behind it to ensure that its open moves result in an upswing of applications on EV-DO. In early 2008, it will publish the technical standards the development community will need to design products to interface with the Verizon Wireless network. Any device that meets the minimum technical standard will be activated on the network, and they will be tested and approved in a $20m testing lab which the operator is expanding to meet the anticipated extra demand. Any application the customer chooses will be allowed on these devices.

“This is a transformation point in the 20-year history of mass market wireless devices — one which we believe will set the table for the next level of innovation and growth,” said Verizon Wireless CEO Lowell McAdam. “Verizon Wireless is not changing our successful retail model, but rather adding an additional retail option for customers looking for a different wireless experience.”

The operator added, perhaps rather hopefully, that it believed the majority of customers would continue to prefer the full service offering for its convenience, but it was finding a ‘small but growing’ group of ‘bring your own’ customers demanding a more reliable and functional network than unlicensed Wi-Fi.

Over at Sprint Nextel, the plans for the network that will underpin its own mobile internet ambitions may be under a cloud ‘ though speaking in the Mobile WiMAX Congress in France today, Christopher Weasler, rejoicing in the title of VP for global advocacy for the WiMAX operating unit Xohm, insisted the deployment was still on track and that investment in WiMAX had been a board decision, not just the preserve of the departed CEO Gary Forsee. But whatever the future CEO decides about the future of Xohm, Sprint is pushing ahead with its own open vision, knowing that stealing a march here is one way that it can try to close some of the gap with the big two, and differentiate itself.

A high profile example came with the recent launch of Kindle, the electronic book reader from online retail giant Amazon, which will work with Sprint’s EV-DO network. The device itself has had mixed reviews, especially when compared, in pricing and design, with Sony’s rival product. But regardless of that, the ideas behind Kindle are important and indicative of the trends driving the US mobile internet.

People who buy a $400 Kindle ‘ made by an unnamed Chinese OEM – can then download a book in less than a minute over EV-DO to the book-sized reader. This may point to future Amazon plans to be a well targeted MVNO, addressing one of the few ways that looks really hopeful for profiting from the mobile internet, the delivery of specific applications of high perceived value to the user base. From Sprint’s point of view, Kindle is an early example of a scenario the operator has frequently outlined ‘ where huge numbers of different connected consumer electronics devices, none subsidized by the operator, spend brief periods tapping into the high speed network.

While WiMAX and LTE will be more effective vehicles for open access because of their cost efficiencies and performance, Sprint and Verizon are clearly not planning to wait until they have their 4G networks in place to stake their claim to the open internet market and try to keep the new raiders outside the camp.

In the next edition of Wireless Watch we will publish a full analysis of Verizon Wireless’ strategy in the light of its important statements on open access and network selection.