Reaction to Verizon Wireless’ pledge of open access, and its announcement of an LTE strategy that could support the economics for that, was swift and not entirely positive. AT&T’s CEO Randall Stephenson was predictably dismissive, but in staking his competitive position, he made some points that were more telling than those of the internet community, gushing about their victory over the old carrier model. In effect, Stephenson said that the open mobile internet is a red herring in the US, and that consumers prefer subsidies to unlocked devices, and applications that work easily on a small device to those created in Java for multiple platforms. These issues must be addressed cannily by operators if they are to avoid the mistakes of European 3G ‘ making assumptions about a market that did not yet exist based on the preferences of a few power users, or of the very different cultures of Japan and Korea. And in the week that Vodafone and Telefonica ‘ currently, with 3, the most dynamic of the tier one carriers in adjusting to the realities of the internet ‘ established their own mobile advertising programme in opposition to those of Google and Nokia (see separate item), it was clear that Verizon’s moves are not an abject climbdown, but part of a trend for cellcos to try to shape the mobile internet model in their own image before it is too late and they lose it to Google or Nokia forever.
AT&T’s Stephenson claimed that his company’s network is as open as Verizon’s is planned to be, since any device can be attached to it using an AT&T SIM card. In an interview with Light Reading, he said the reaction to Verizon Wireless’ announcement had been overblown, and that of course wireless would, over time, become open access like wireline. However, he said: “You can take a Nokia phone and connect it to our network, just put in your own SIM card. We don’t see customers do that. They want the phone subsidized.”
This is, of course, a far cry from the full openness of the PC world, but outside the world of free Wi-Fi and broadband, all internet models do impose some form of restriction on which devices can safely connect to their systems, and many are looking to adopt a SIM approach. More important is that, once connected, the user can choose any application or service from his or her device, something Verizon has promised once a product has been certified for compatibility, security and so on ‘ and which is not, of course, true of AT&T’s current flagship handset, the iPhone, although even Apple is in the process of making concessions to open development. Apple and the operators warn of the dangers of unrestricted access, especially on mobile networks with limited bandwidth and high QoS expectations, and on immature platforms like iPhone. AT&T simply goes a step further and says users do not want fully open applications, because these are not yet sufficiently usable, though Java apps can run on the AT&T network.
At first this sounds like the famous protestation of Hutchison 3, a couple of years ago, that it saw no demand for internet access beyond the walled gardens ‘ a view it quickly changed when it became one of the trailblazers for an open mobile internet experience. Like Verizon, the operator was recognizing that it could not remain entirely closed, and would do better to grab the lion’s share of the new market than lose out to internet players. But also like Verizon, 3 is not quite as open as its marketing suggested, and knows that a perception of full openness can be more important than the reality. In fact, its most popular services are heavily optimized for its network and brand, even when they are huge internet brands, with the extreme being a handset specifically tailored and branded for VoIP service Skype. In theory, any internet-enabled handset can use Skype, but in fact the experience is clumsy unless the interface is tweaked for the application and so 3 gains an advantage by delivering a superior mobile Skype experience. Verizon Wireless will also be optimizing some applications for its network and handsets, and keeping others, such as the VCast television offering, to itself, all to maintain differentiation and premium margins. “Verizon alone decides what phones and applications will be acceptable to its network. It would be preferable to have a neutral third party either making the decision on acceptability for Verizon, or conducting evaluations which would be accepted by Verizon,” said Gigi Sohn, president and co-founder of Public Knowledge.
And the all-important issue of subsidies remains. Currently, operators like Verizon can exploit the fact that subsidies and open access are an either/or. Once the mobile internet services and experience improve, and if they come with significantly reduced overall data costs, users may feel it is worth moving away from subsidized gadgets, especially if particularly appealing devices, like iPhones or PSPs, become available on the open market. This is a trend that Sprint Nextel has been banking on to differentiate its Xohm WiMAX services and to offset, with loss of subsidies, the heavy costs of delivering and supporting broadband internet on a flat rate basis. But it is likely to be years before this trend is a general one, especially before Xohm-style advanced networks are built out and suitable devices and interfaces created. Until then, operators can rely on keeping most of the user base, outside the power user sector, happy with subsidies and an element of lock-in, even if that is increasingly heavily disguised by tie-ups with internet brands and greater levels of support for open browsing.
Meanwhile, the internet giants are also watering down their open access stance, and looking to work more closely with the operators, rather than against them, putting Google and the more far-sighted cellcos within feet of one another’s points of view. Google drummed up operator support for its recently launched Linux/Java-based Android mobile software environment, and the Open Handset Alliance that supports this as a de facto standard. Once again, Vodafone and Telefonica were the frontrunners, indicating the real power bases of the new internet ‘ the operators and internet players that manage to work together, not in opposition. Google’s much rumored gPhone turned out to be a software platform, and potentially a way for operators of all kinds to brand a handset with the Google name, as 3 is doing with Skype, to proclaim its web credentials. The search giant has confirmed it will bid for spectrum in the January 700MHz auction, but it is highly unlikely that it will set itself up as an operator directly. It could either use its spectrum to power play among the operators, as Craig McCaw of Clearwire does so well, or it could act as a wholesaler for mobile internet providers. These will almost certainly have to be highly specialized, delivering on a specific application or brand, in order to have a chance of making a profit. The lessons of the recent booms and busts in US MVNOs and municipal Wi-Fi activities have proved one thing ‘ without an established network and customer base, generic, broad brush wireless offerings have little hope of a strong profit model, and the future will lie with a patchwork of smaller, more targeted providers, playing on a high value service such as enterprise unified communications (with interfaces and device partnerships to suit) and/or a powerful brand, a la Virgin Mobile.
By offering its user base the choice of open or traditional models, Verizon no doubt hopes that what AT&T says will prove true ‘ that most will prefer the latter, and like a demanding child, once offered the free choice, the consumer base will lose interest and stop clamouring for something it has been denied.
In the meantime, its new open credentials not only steal the thunder from Sprint, the main advocate of openness, at a time when the third largest cellco is floundering, but should encourage more, not less, partnership from influential internet players. The more Verizon appears to meet the open access lobby halfway, the more it is likely to make it unnecessary for these companies to take competitive actions of their own, or to pressurize the FCC further into making stronger open stipulations. This is a lesson the European cellcos should have learned in roaming ‘ if you address the issue yourself, you retain control and credibility, and can get away with conceding far less than when an irritated regulator gets involved.
We would expect Verizon’s announcement to be followed by a pledge of support for Google’s Open Handset Alliance, a tie-up that has been long rumored anyway ‘ AT&T has also said it would support this if it saw sufficient interest. But all these cellco-internet alliances are not really fulfilling the dream of openness, but rather sewing up the power and the profit in the mobile world among a (partially) different set of players. Optimizing services for the operator’s network and devices does deliver a better experience than letting the users loose with a browser to work it out for themselves. Nokia constantly uses this argument ‘ that the mobile internet cannot, yet at least, be just the internet, but must be delivered in a special way to make the most of mobile form factors. In Nokia’s case, it wants to control this by carrying out the tweaking on its application servers and delivering applications and content seamlessly to different devices and networks. Operators, of course, would rather perform this task (or have it done for them by a hosted service) from within their networks in order to differentiate the experience they deliver and attract customers. And internet players want it to be done in the device’s software, making the choice of network and application provider irrelevant ‘ but know that, until their software platforms are a great deal more effective on small scale devices than they are now, they can at least generate usage (leading to advertising and service revenues) and brand awareness by working with the major network owners.
Once again, in taking a conservative line (and no operator/internet partnership has been more retrograde, in openness terms, than AT&T’s with Apple) Stephenson managed to highlight a basic truth, that the internet software architectures are in their infancy in a mobile world that their vendors do not yet understand. “Here are all these people that make large, carrier class operating systems. And here’s a new entrant who’s never built a carrier class operating system,” he said.
So, grudgingly or not, the internet giants will need to work with the established operators ‘ after all, even if Google acquires a swathe of 700MHz spectrum, it will just be one network in one country, hardly the basis of universal Google presence ‘ and/or with mobile specialists like Nokia. Yahoo, which despite being serious about mobility for several years longer than its arch-rival has a far lower profile, has appreciated this well and we have tipped it for some time to be the provider of much needed heavyweight applications to fill the gaps in Nokia’s rapidly developing and potentially world changing Ovi web services strategy. Yahoo is also seeking to wrongfoot Google by pipping it to the post in deals with key operators, especially by being less ambivalent about its willingness to work with cellcos or against them than its enemy, and by pursuing partners in key growth markets with limited wireline internet penetration, such as parts of Asia and Latin America (see separate item). In other words, the cellcos remain the most important route to market for mobile internet services, and will be for a long time, and they know it. While Verizon is making concessions to openness, they are not as dramatic as they at first appeared, and are fully geared to keeping the operator firmly in control of its user base. Google may find itself having to make far greater compromises on its open access vision in order not to cut itself off from the major operators, however shiny their new open access clothes.
Canada’s auctions:
The FCC may have mandated a degree of open access and supported a possible shift to wholesale networks that could support multiple new operators, but north of the border, Canada is going further, setting aside a huge 40% of spectrum in the upcoming auction for new entrants. Shares in the three incumbents – Rogers Wireless, Telus and Bell Canada – saw a total of $2.85bn shaved off their collective market capitalization as their shares dropped by an average of 10% on the news. The regulators also decided that the incumbents would have to allow these new entrants to roam on their networks for between five and 10 years.
“These auction rules are likely to enhance fears of aggressive new wireless competition across the country,” said Vince Valentini, an analyst at TD Newcrest, in a research note. “However, we believe these fears will end up being overstated, as we see aggressive new competition being likely only in Quebec.”
Operators expressing interest included Quebecor’s Videotron cable division, long distance calling reseller Yak Communications, and Matthew Bassett, the son of late media pioneer John Bassett who founded CTV’s predecessor Baton Broadcasting.
Mandatory roaming will be effective as soon as a new entrant wins spectrum, analysts said.
Google GPower:
We may think that Google lacks the experience needed to turn its hand to running mobile networks or designing handsets, but even more lateral is its announcement of GPower, a power generation initiative using renewable energy technology to replace coal-fired electricity. The new R&D program is codenamed ‘RE