Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 December 2007

Rejection of SKT-Donahue plan may be major error for Sprint Nextel

Since the departure of CEO Gary Forsee amid continuing operational and performance problems at Sprint Nextel, the carrier has been widely expected to look for a joint venture partner, especially for its Xohm WiMAX business, or even a full acquisition bid. However, its board rejected out of hand an offer of a $5bn investment ‘ just about the planned capex cost of the national WiMAX network ‘ from Korea’s SK Telecom and Providence Equity Partners.

The snubbing of the offer, without even agreeing to a meeting, seems hasty, given Sprint’s current financial decline, the deeply divided nature of its board and its failure to find a new CEO and COO. SKT would, in many ways, be a perfect partner. It has strong ambitions to expand internationally, including in the US ‘ it already has the Helio MVNO, co-owned with Earthlink ‘ and is prepared to put significant cash behind these objectives. It would bring Sprint real world experience of deploying a WiMAX (WiBro) network, and far more importantly, real knowledge of operating an advanced mobile broadband service. The promise of being the first US major to offer this type of service, complete with open access, new breeds of devices and user interfaces, and new value chains, has been the vision behind Xohm, and that holds good, even if Sprint’s shareholders are running scared of following through with the investment, because of the problems in the CDMA and iDEN businesses. With SKT, the financial risk would be lessened, and Sprint would have a partner that understands this market more than almost any operator, because of Korea’s peculiarly advanced broadband culture. Without Xohm ‘ and increasingly it seems that Xohm will require some external support ‘ Sprint becomes a struggling third-placed carrier with operational difficulties, no obvious 4G path and little differentiation.

The main sticking point in at least considering this apparently interesting SKT offer seems to have been one of the provisions, that former Nextel CEO Tim Donahue, who retired from the chairman position at the merged operator earlier this year, should return as CEO (a turn of events that might well put the cancelled Clearwire deal back on the table, given the close association of Donahue and Nextel with Clearwire founder Craig McCaw, formerly major shareholder and turnaround wizard at Nextel).

One of the problems that has dogged Sprint Nextel’s slow process of consolidating the merger has been the continuing deep culture split between executives and board directors from each side of the fence. It is understood that the Sprint-oriented directors were fiercely opposed to a Donahue return, and tend to blame problems with assimilating Nextel, and with Nextel’s network, for their current woes ‘ while their counterparts of Nextel origin blame the dominance of Sprint management post-merger and that team’s poor execution and bureaucracy.

Donahue says he was prepared to bring in a fresh wave of executives to revamp Sprint Nextel’s marketing and operations teams, the carrier’s main weak spots. Sprint’s most influential activist shareholder, Ralph Whitworth, was said to be a force behind the anti-SKT decision, and he welcomed it publicly, saying the CEO post should ‘not be up for auction’.

But Donahue would surely have been better than the prolonged and confidence draining vacumm Sprint is currently enduring, especially when he brought SKT’s money and expertise with him. Donahue gained a strong reputation for, with McCaw’s backing, turning Nextel from a failing operator with a motley collection of spectrum to the US’ fifth largest cellco, with enviably high margins and low churn, based around differentiated services like the original push to talk application, and later, offerings such as Boost targeted to specific demographics. Both these examples show that Donahue’s Nextel was in some ways ahead of its time, recognizing the contribution to customer loyalty and profitability of having well targeted, unique data services. Such insights would not harm Sprint now, especially if Donahue could bring in what the merged carrier has so disastrously lacked since the departure of Len Lauer last year, a strong COO. The downside, of course, would be that appointing Donahue would prolong rather than heal the destructive Sprint-Nextel dividei, and some board members want to hire an objective outsider for that reason.

The Donahue-led group said in its bid letter to the board that it was prepared to invest $5bn or “potentially substantially more” in the form of securities convertible into equity after some period of time at a stock price 20% higher than Sprint’s share price today as well as a non-cash dividend of 3% to 4%, according to the Wall Street Journal. Sprint has a market capitalization of about $42bn. The consortium also said it was prepared to sign a definitive agreement with Sprint within 10 days.

The letter went on to say the group would bring “a deep wireless management team, a strategic relationship with a leading global wireless operator, significant strategic capital, and the public market sponsorship of an accomplished private equity investor.” This sounds like the recipe for Sprint Nextel’s rescue from the doldrums. Refusing even to discuss such a plan is perhaps the most worrying factor of all for those who believe US telecoms would genuinely benefit from Sprint Nextel’s WiMAX vision. It says that political manoeuvring and old divisions are driving key decisions rather than the strategic forward thinking that, for all his faults, former CEO Forsee possessed. This was highlighted by statements from some directors that a key factor in the CEO search would be to find someone willing to relocate to Kansas, where it is hoped to consolidate operations. This hardly spoke of lofty ambitions in the headhunting process, since if the job were attractive enough, the location should not matter greatly to candidates. The question of location has been a factor in putting Dan Hesse, CEO of former Sprint local lines spin-off Embarq, in the front ranks of potential candidates, since he is already based there. As long as this approach prevails, prospects for Sprint look grim, and Xohm perhaps would be better in the hands of a different operator ‘ even SKT itself.

(Other rumored candidates include former Sprint president Ronald LeMay and a top executive at Procter & Gamble, while interim CEO Paul Saleh is also campaigning for the role, though his appointment would be widely seen as a last resort. Comcast COO Steve Burke and former head of Vodafone Japan Bill Morrow have apparently been approached for the job but turned it down.)

SKT:

From SKT’s point of view, rejection will be disappointing, as it would have given the company the chance to have a significant influence on a WiMAX deployment in a key market, but one that is hard to enter for an outsider ‘ the four-year old Helio venture has had limited success, though SKT has remained committed to it despite the pulling back of partner Earthlink.

The largest Korean mobile operator is in need of some new ventures. At home, its market is saturating, and it faces new competition from the fixed line carriers that have won Wi-Bro licenses and will start offering their own mobile IP services. Although SKT is publicly enthusiastic about Wi-Bro and WiMAX, in its home country it faces far higher risks from the technology, with its potential to pressurize the CDMA base, than the other Wi-Bro operators.

SKT’s market share in its home mobile market is declining and number portability has led to customer defections to KT Freetel and LG Telecom. Abroad, it is a different matter of course, and it has the opportunity to apply its expertise to a new customer base.

It is starting to get involved in some foreign ventures, including TD-SCDMA trials in China and mobile TV activities with Deutsche Telekom, as well as Helio.