With the allocation of mobile TV spectrum delayed or confused in many European countries, operators are looking for an interim solution, and a new commitment by UK cellcos T-Mobile and Orange puts TDtv, from NextWave Wireless, firmly in the running. The technology was created by IPWireless, now part of NextWave, as part of its strategy of creating products for the TDD portion of the UMTS spectrum. European operators gained TDD spectrum with their 3G licenses but have rarely used it, and while IPWireless’ TD-CDMA system failed to gain much traction. NextWave is also proposing an evolution of the platform for the TDD implementation of LTE, but the world at large is likely to support the variant backed by Ericsson and derived from China’s TD-SCDMA LTE. In light of all that, NextWave/IPWireless sees mobile TV as its major opportunity in the cellular world, and head of marketing Jon Hambridge went as far as to claim that TDtv would be the natural choice for existing mobile carriers, while new entrants to the wireless market would be the likely adopters of DVB-H.
Another contender is the Alcatel-Lucent backed DVB-SH, with the French giant claiming that its strongest targets are Spain and Poland, which ‘have no spectrum’, as sources told us at the Mobile TV World Congress in Paris recently. This is despite the fact that these countries both have strong DVB-H trials.
But indeed, although it initially seemed that Spain had just put off spectrum allocation while it held elections, now the Minister of Industry there has confirmed the Alcatel view, saying that the regulatory changes will not be completed until the tail end of 2008, meaning build-out would be in 2009 and services would start in 2010.
The UK has similar, if not worse, problems and this has the country’s cellcos looking for an interim solution. So Orange and T-Mobile have agreed to use the TDtv system in their spare 5MHz of TDD spectrum, planning a commercial trial in London, and then the launch of a 100-channel system.
If the Alcatel-Lucent source is accurate, then Poland will be faced with the same dilemma after its DVB-H trial and the splintering of technologies across Europe will be unavoidable despite the EU Telecoms Commissioner Viviane Reding pushing through DVB-H as the ‘approved’ European standard for mobile TV.
There are, or have been, DVB-H trials in at least 17 of Europe’s 27 countries, and this includes the big ones ‘ UK, France, Germany, Italy and Spain ‘ but of these only Italy has a live service (in fact two) and France and Germany are hoping to launch services during 2008, with Austria and Switzerland also expecting service launches. Ironically the countries that are not yet in the European Union, but likely to join, including Croatia, also have DVB-H trials, and are likely to have a better chance of freeing up spectrum than the existing members.
DVB-H should not be the only standard for Europe because many countries on the borders of France, Germany and Italy will not have any kind of mobile TV until a year after their digital TV switchover, when there may possibly be some UHF spectrum to use for mobile TV. Many cellular operators are planning a leap straight to mobile internet and that could use up huge swathes of spectrum, shared, as it might be by auction, between three or four cellular players per European country. Waiting until 2012 or so only to find that you are outbid for spectrum is not a good outcome for any business that relies on mobile TV ‘ whether that be broadcasters or tier two cellcos.
So the question that many operators around Europe are asking is ‘what can I put in place for now?’ and at the head of that queue will be Orange and Vodafone ‘ both of which have huge unicast TV services, eating up cellular spectrum. We have been told by Orange that if it does not move some of its mobile TV off unicast by the end of 2008, it will no longer be able to add more 3G customers. The biggest crunch for Orange is in France, where there will be a DVB-H service by the end of 2008, and it has bid for two channels of its own. It can also try Alcatel’s DVB-SH, and perhaps augment its own channels with that technology or with MBMS.
Vodafone also has the DVB-H service in France for its SFR associate, and another in Germany, and it already is on the DVB-H service in Italy, but now it will have a double problem – what to do about Spain and the UK, two of its biggest markets. There are fewer unicast TV customers in Spain, so its most acute problem is in the UK where it now has either to engage with DVB-SH or follow up its own TDtv trial ‘ emulating Orange, and perhaps working with Telefonica O2, sharing towers and build-out in the same way that Orange and T-Mobile are sharing costs.
The TDtv system needs a transmitter, costing around $10,000 plus installation and tower rental costs, on around 30%-50% of base stations, plus a $20 chip in each handset. The most popular TV channels that are already offered in unicast can be moved to broadcast, taking the lion’s share of unicast traffic. The top eight channels of any given TV bouquet take upwards of 90% of all TV viewing.
The Bristol trial, which the four largest UK cellular operators bought into, showed that this spectrum can support 15 broadcast TV channels, so there would be room for more than one operator to offer its own channels, with other less popular channels falling back to unicast. NextWave actually says that the system could deliver as many as 28 TV channels, and with the rest in unicast, that could lead to the 100-channel bouquet they are talking about.
If the operators were to be really aggressive they might dynamically select the leading channels per base station, and only fall away to unicast when the TDtv channels were full, but our understanding is that this would take some planning and operator coding, although such a system has been tried and works in Hong Kong at PCCW.
The Orange and T-Mobile deal is being touted as a temporary move until 2012 when digital switchover happens. For about two years there has been an idea that Channel 36 in the UK could be freed up from air traffic control radar and the application moved to other available spectrum and DVB-H placed into UHF before 2012. However the cost of doing this has to include replacing all the radio equipment for the radar, and a period of running the two systems in parallel, before build out can take place. The longer this decision is put off, the lower its economic value, since it would only be worthwhile until UHF spectrum from digital switchover is auctioned. Chances are it is already too late.
The beauty of dealing with either the TDtv technology, or DVB-SH, is that these systems cost similar amounts to one another, once a few hundred thousand customers are signed up, and this is way less than a DVB-H network. The cellcos would also be in complete control of subscriptions and advertising revenues, without partnering broadcast operators ‘ a task that is proving complex in many countries across Europe where they all want to run free to air services ‘ ignoring the cellco’s need for improved ARPU. Virgin Mobile, now part of Virgin Media, is an MVNO on the T-Mobile network in the UK, and could be one of the outlets for any mobile TV service launched by T-Mobile there.
NextWave used the MWC show in Barcelona to announce the commercial trial and also launch a TDtv Device Integration Pack designed to make it easy to get started in the network. It offers a low-power TDtv card, a complete MBMS software stack, which is also required to drive TDtv, and the MediaFusion multimedia client software from PacketVideo, another NextWave company. The system will enable handset makers to deliver TDtv handsets to market in 2008.
Meanwhile at MWC, Qualcomm was demonstrating its MediaFLO system, but also using pure MBMS (the technology NextWave uses, but the pure version is in FDD spectrum, rather than TDD). Telefonica and its rivals in Spain may find that pressure to opt for MBMS or TDtv or the Alcatel DVB-SH system will increase as its neighbors have fully functioning broadcast mobile TV systems, a move that will continue to jeopardize the future of DVB-H.
PacketVideo:
NextWave subsidiary PacketVideo announced a new way to bring TV and video to mobile devices, with the Mobile Broadcast Receiver. This is a device the size of a matchbox that can bring video to even low bandwidth handsets without the phone needing any adaptation.
PV’s mobile receiver device decodes a digital TV signal and repurposes it for use on the phone, sending it via a wireless signal, such as WiFi, to a playback device. The receiver uses patented protocols to ensure optimum rendering of the TV signal on the playback device, and provides secure access to premium channels. This allows mobile subscribers to upgrade to advanced mobile TV services without changing their current handset.
The mobile broadcast receiver will be available in versions for all major mobile broadcast standards, including DVB-H, MediaFLO and TDtv as well as for WiMAX. The device can also be customized with the operator’s badge or branding for the retail market. The mobile broadcast receiver is compatible with many handsets including the Nokia N Series, Apple iPhone and HTC smartphone devices.